Gordon Brown's "Business Budget" was exactly that. A smoke and mirrors masterclass which robbed the poor to pay the rich a little bonus to keep them sweet.
As that well-known left-wing rag The Telegraph says today: ,
"Mr Brown will claw back nearly all the cost (of the 2p tax cut) by scrapping the 10p lowest rate of income tax. As a result, low earners will start paying the basic rate sooner." A senior tax consultant at accountants Grant Thornton says it is "ironic" this effectively penalises some of the poorest families who will pay for his so-called give-away.
Ironic? it's a bloody disgrace. Despite welcome money for the NHS and education, the public services will see spending grow by just two per cent in the coming years. Effectively, a decrease. Yet this "Budget For Business" as the Chancellor called it, cut corporation tax , raised the inheritance tax threshold and trashed the Tories 'plans for a tax on green flyers. It's designed to please Middle England - New Labour's usual target audience.
As one wag put it , "Brown has just delivered what should have been George Osborne's first budget. Add the recently-announced cuts in public sector pay, the £76billion for Trident, and it doesn't sound quite so great as the Brown-friendly media said, does it?
The Chancellor has a masterly command of how the economy works .What a shame he doesn't use his undoubted "towering intellect" to benefit those who most need his expertise. And deliver a Labour budget.
Thursday, 22 March 2007
SMOKE AND MIRRORS BUDGET CLOUDS REAL ISSUES
Posted by
susan press
at
11:58
Labels: Budget, Gordon brown
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
Hey Susan,
You ought to publish something along these lines on labourhome.org as well.
I can't help but getting a feeling that many right-wing Labour bloggers will see fit to praise Brown's smoke screen budget there. It would be good if they were countered by posts such as this one, which, albeit not in great detail, point out the true nature of our Chancellor's "Tory slaying" budget.
Other posters on Labour Home have noticed this now and I have posted, too. The Brownites seem to be, er ,livid.
Quite right - i agree with you - liked the Telegraph line too - here's my own take on the budget -
http://www.duncanmcfarlane.org/Budget_Response_Mar07/
or http://inplaceoffear.blogspot.com/
The assertion that clobbering the poor pays for most of the 2p doesn't sound like economist talk ... it sounds like Tory talk ... particularly with changes in Tax Credits worth 250% of the lost tax break. But we need to hope GB revisits the weak bit and fixes things for singles earning £7500 and other examples of losers.
Biggest losers are women 60-64 (naturally), part timers and I think single working poor. Brown should obviously be looking after those.
That said I think there is a lot of good politics in rendering the Tories speechless and I think we need to exploit that as far as we can. This is the budget - for better or for worse - we need to fight with on the doorsteps over the next 6 weeks.
Oh right - anyone who criticises any Labour chancellor is a tory - that's pretty weak stuff Chris.
The tax credit system is so complex and involves having to fill out so many lengthy forms taking so much time that most people entitled to it don't get the time to claim it.
£2.3 billion of tax credits don't get claimed each year.
http://money.guardian.co.uk/tax/story/0,,2025224,00.html
You are defending a Tory budget cross dressing as socialism.
Feel free to transvestite the doorstops though if you won't vote for a candidate for Labour leader who wouldnt raise taxes on the poor or throw all the increased NHS spending away on PFIs.
Meant to say that candidate is John McDonnel - http://wwww.john4leader.org.uk
(goes without saying really)
Chris - dead late and need to go to bed, But you're utterly wrong.More tomorrow
Post a Comment