AT this stage in the game, I think most of us have made our minds up how we are going to vote in the leadership election. Some, I know, are not going to vote at all.
But I don't believe in paying £38 a year for the privilege of disenfranchising myself.
When the ballot papers arrive, I will cast my first preference for Diane Abbott and my second for Ed Miliband. and I will do so with no illusions whatsoever.
My vote for Abbott is to stop the left being humiliated. Her candidacy, however, was designed to ensure it.
An MP who had only two nominations after three weeks of campaigning was suddenly railroaded onto the ballot because of the real prospect of a credible left challenge.
As the grassroots clamour grew for John McDonnell to go on the ballot paper, so did Abbott's support in the PLP.
Mysteriously, people like Phil Woolas, Harriet Harman, Jack Straw appeared from nowhere and effectively - with the final vote from David Miliband - nailed a candidacy which they knew was no threat whatsoever to the status quo. And so it has proved.
At recent hustings, Abbott has agreed cuts have to be made (50 per cent rather than 60 per cent ) and ignored the socialist alternative of progressive taxation and nailing the tax dodgers .She has not impressed the grassroots outside London and many LRC members I know up here are simply cutting to the chase and backing Ed Miliband.
I will not do that.
Abbott's stance on Iraq, immigration and civil liberties distinguishes her from the rest
Buty had she really been interested in promoting the cause of Labour Left, she would have supported John McDonnell and done her best to get him on the ballot. He withdrew with dignity. The truth is he would not have had to withdraw at all if she had not stood at the eleventh-hour.
I don't think the Labour left will gain much in the long-term once the ballot papers have been counted. Those in the PLP who aided her appearance on the ballot will actually vote for others. The big trade unions have already swung behind Ed Miliband.
Reluctantly she will get my first preference. But don't expect me to be a cheerleader .
As LRC Secretary Andrew Fisher explains in this article, it could all have been so much better.
And once the contest is over, and Abbott is back on the sofa with Portillo, we will have to keep arguing the case for a real left alternative.

6 comments:
John McDonnell would have been divisive and his candidacy would have been a waste of time - and would have given more excuse to marginalise the left.
Diane Abbott at least gives some variety, but McDonnell has absolutely no appeal outside the LRC left. At least Diane Abbott has kept the contest civil. I think a McDonnell candidacy may have changed that, and I'm glad he didn't stand
Merseymike, you could not be ore wrong. John McDonnell was backed by a broad swathe of trade union activists and has far more appeal than Diane Abbott - which is why he was stitched up. Keeping the contest civil ie bland and boring is a pretty high price to pay.
A McDonnell candidacy would have set a socialist agenda and been supported by far more LP members than Diane Abbott's as time will prove.......
I think he has a core of activists - but they are a very small number in terms of actual votes - and Diane Abbott has much more appeal in terms of non-aligned people who like her style and distinctiveness. I simply think you are wrong and that few people would have supported McDonnell outside the activist hardcore.
Given that after defeat, political parties tend to tear themselves apart and this puts paid to any sort of recovery, give me bland and boring any day. Labour have slowly increased in the polls since the election and that is unheard of for an opposition when the government are experiencing a honeymoon - Blair was clocking 50%+ after 1997. A blood-letting leadership campaign where the party knocks chunks out of itself would be very damaging and justifying this purely so that John McDonnell could get his 5% tops of the vote doesn't make a lot of sense.
A candidate from the LRC left hasn't got a prayer, simply because the support isn't there, and so I think it makes sense to look for what is achievable rather than regret something which wouldn't have actually got the outcome you want - indeed it would have made it far more difficult for Ed Miliband to advocate some of his policies for fear of the more right wing candidates branding him as too lefrt wong!
Obviously we disagree. But those who vote for Labour leader are NOT non-aligned- the fact is too Diane Abbott had LESS real support in the PLP in trms of nominations.
And far Less support in the trade unions where she has little track record of activity and is simply not taken seriously.
Her support in the CLPs is also tiny - only 21 have nominated her .
The LRC left I think would have mustered rather more than that. We will never know.
One thing I do agree with you is by simoky having a left candidate it has shifted the others - so that's a good thing.
But the votes of both union and CLP members are individual, and DA is far, far better known. I think she will get a fair few votes amongst non-activists, I think very few unions would have voted McDonnell over Ed Miliband - remember that at least 3 Campaign group MP's including Linda Riordan are voting for Ed Miliband.
being realistic, though, neither DA or JM were ever going to win, and personally, I think Ed Miliband is the best bet.
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: I'm writing 'John McDonnell' on my ballot paper and sending it back.
DA's candidacy was doomed from the start, not only because she needed the leg-up, but also because her leftist credentials are completely undermined by the schools issue.
The problem with being on the left in Labour currently is that unless your nose is squeaky clean, you're nowhere, whereas playing a long and active role in the most reactionary, war-mongering and detrimentally pro-market Labour government in history makes you a prime candidate for the leadership. It's an utter disgrace.
Post a Comment