Showing posts with label David Davis by-elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label David Davis by-elections. Show all posts

Saturday, 21 June 2008

BENNITES 4 DAVIS?

Interesting debate over at Dave Osler's blog as to whether Tony Benn should have announced his support for David Davis. In truth, I am a bit ambivalent about this one as those of us in our middle years go back an awfully long way politically with TB and it's weird and miore than a little unsettling I agree to see him advocating a Tory. But let's ask ourselves why.

Firstly, a craven PLP caved in utterly and allowed Brown to get away with the 42 days legislation. The Cabinet is similarly supine and unprincipled.
Brown manipulated the vote as one of "no confidence" and thereby thought the issue woul,d be dead in the water once he had got it through Parliament not by winning the argument but by bullying and deals.
Once Davis had announced he was resigning Labour almost immediately said it would not stand a candidate. Sorry - but if you think you have the public with you ( and that was the New labour line) and the moral high ground then you shoukd be prepared to put it to the test. By NOT standing a candidate, Labour has allowed its standing to sink even further in the public's estimation . Big tactical mistake.
Of course if Labour had stood a candidate neither TB nor Marshall-Andrews ( or anyone else on the Labour Left) could have spoken up for Davis. They would be expelled from the Party.
So, in the context of the situation as it stands, and the fact that 42 days has been another tipping-point for many Party members, Benn is right to carry on campaigning. But I do understand why some will disagree....

Sunday, 15 June 2008

DAVIS THROUGH THE LOOKING GLASS

A topsy-turvy world indeed when David Davis is standingup for civil liberties - and the appalling Kelvin McKenzie backs the official line from the Labour Government.
My MP, with dozens of others, supported the 42 days in the face of serious pressure from the Whips. And now? Events, as they say, are always the deus ex machina which turns everything round so now despite his "victory" Brown is facing the prospect of an unmitiagated by-election drubbing for the sake of a policy which very few on the Labour benches actually supported.
One of the many stories which Tony Benn tells is the advice his father gave him many years ago ie to "dare to be a Daniel." Sound counselling indeed. But there were only 37 Labour MPs who had the courage of their convictions the other day and those who didn't are not in a better place at all as a result of their surrender. Quite the contrary
Today's Scotland On Sunday has an excellent piece by one Tom Brown (no relation) asto where Gordon should go to salvage what remains of his Premiership. It's familiar
ground to anyone on the Left but its commonsense shrieks out The tragedy is I just do not think anyone in the Government is listening anymore. As for the PLP well they seem to have donned their lemming costumes and walked a little but further towards the abyss. It could all be so very different......
.http://scotlandonsunday.scotsman.com/12700/Tom-Brown-The-amount-I.4186789.jp