Saturday, 21 June 2008

BENNITES 4 DAVIS?

Interesting debate over at Dave Osler's blog as to whether Tony Benn should have announced his support for David Davis. In truth, I am a bit ambivalent about this one as those of us in our middle years go back an awfully long way politically with TB and it's weird and miore than a little unsettling I agree to see him advocating a Tory. But let's ask ourselves why.

Firstly, a craven PLP caved in utterly and allowed Brown to get away with the 42 days legislation. The Cabinet is similarly supine and unprincipled.
Brown manipulated the vote as one of "no confidence" and thereby thought the issue woul,d be dead in the water once he had got it through Parliament not by winning the argument but by bullying and deals.
Once Davis had announced he was resigning Labour almost immediately said it would not stand a candidate. Sorry - but if you think you have the public with you ( and that was the New labour line) and the moral high ground then you shoukd be prepared to put it to the test. By NOT standing a candidate, Labour has allowed its standing to sink even further in the public's estimation . Big tactical mistake.
Of course if Labour had stood a candidate neither TB nor Marshall-Andrews ( or anyone else on the Labour Left) could have spoken up for Davis. They would be expelled from the Party.
So, in the context of the situation as it stands, and the fact that 42 days has been another tipping-point for many Party members, Benn is right to carry on campaigning. But I do understand why some will disagree....

11 comments:

Duncan Hall said...

Have just seen Tony (and Davis actually) in Beverley. I was doing a gig for the Teenage Cancer Trust and Tony came up and spoke briefly about it. He was doing one of his sets with Roy Bailey in Beverley earlier, and I think David Davis had come along to watch it.

Tony was fairly straightforward on the subject really: 'He doesn't want to lock people up and I don't want to either'. He did say it was a 'funny thing' that he was going to go off and campaign for a Conservative MP.

I agree, it is a funny thing. Having said that, as there isn't a Labour (or, as far as I know, other socialist) candidate - I guess this becomes an opportunity to continue the debate about 42 days. I have to say a broadly left/liberal audience seemed extremely supportive today (even though he was only mentioning the Davis thing as an aside).

I'm still a bit 'I'm not sure' about my own view - but I think Tony's probably right to use this campaign as an opportunity to keep the arguments about 42 days going.

susan press said...

Think I agree. Hope you had a good time and that TB was in good form.

Anonymous said...

Surely the issue is he is still standing as a Conservative

If he was standing as non party 42 TB may, May be understandably

but as DD is anti himan rights pro hanging

would TB have supported him if as home sec DD had hung the Birmingham six ???

Sorry TB your wrong on this one

Duncan Hall said...

I agree - that is the problem. I Suppose the only thing I can say on the other side is that this isn't a real by-election. The other serious parties aren't treating it like a by-election (as both the Lib Dems and Labour have a policy of contesting every seat) and even the Conservatives are not funding the campaign as a normal by-election. As such, while there is the uncomfortable truth that Davis is the conservative candidate, this is really an odd type of protest, and the protest is about 42 days. As such it's not really that different from being on a march and being a bit worried about some of the other views of the people marching near you (an experience I imagine we've all had in the last few years). If Tony and other non-conservative speakers can broaden this out to other issues - both about terrorism itself (as Tony did re: the war) and about other civil liberties issues (including some the Davis wouldn't want to touch) then it's possibly worthwhile. Essentially the by-election is a platform, and people who want to get the point across about 42 days will do so more readily from that platform now it's been built.

I'm not sure about it; don't like it much - but I can certainly see the point.

Chris Paul said...

It's not a real by-election and Labour should have spiked the writ in parliament IMO. Davis is a right winger with occasional maverick moments e.g. on 42 days, but not on 28 days, hanging, gay rights, locking up asylum seekers etc et bloody cetera.

Tony Benn is being delightfully Bennite on the surface but actually sadly illogical. If someone did the same for a so-called referendum on anything he didn't like, particularly in such a lop-sided constituency, he would be declaring the whole thing a farce.

An election in Haltemprice and Howden could NEVER be a referendum on this matter. NEVER.

Or at least it only could be if Davis stood down completely and no party political candidates were up, and there was a pro-42 days and a pro-liberty candidate and that's all, promising to resign at the General Election and to pay Davis to do the case work and be their delegate until then.

Davis hasn't even been courageous particularly. He only threw his toys when his main opposition promised not to stand against him.

Anonymous said...

I agree with a lot of what you say, Susan, esp. about Labour not standing a candidate but even so I can't back a Tory even on a single issue like 42 days. And remember what kind of politics Davis has.

Anonymous said...

There was another way for Tony Benn - he could've stood himself. He could've criticised the government on 42 days and Davis on other civil liberties issues.

I bet a lot more of us would've gone and campaigned for him than for Davis.

susan press said...

I think the consensus seems to be growing that Benn may have called this one wrong. I'm not sure.I understand why he is backing Davis. But, yes, what about the other stuff.....maybe the problem is the lines between Tories and New Labour have blurred so badly that there is very little to choose between - and on some issue, lie this one, the Tories have a better position

Duncan Hall said...

In answer to your earlier question, Susan - Tony was on very good form. He seemed much healthier than last time I saw him, actually (which was a while ago - the John4Leader rally in London, I think).

I'm not sure he's called it wrong - were there other ways to go? Definitely. Do I support Davis? No. But I can see why Tony's doing it, and if he is able to reach a few more people and get the arguments across about this issue, then it's worth doing it. It's a shortish campaign on a particular issue; he hasn't become a Tory!

susan press said...

of course not...

Merseymike said...

I think this is all purely tactical. Keep the issue on the agenda, the Lords will throw it back to the Commons, and lets hope by then enough MP's see sense and say to the Government - no, enough.

If the by-election didn't happen then the pressure would be off, unfortunately.

I don't think anyone on the liberal-left is a fan of Davis, but this really is about this single issue, and it is very important.