A late , too late, plea from COMPASS. How do Cruddas and Trickett square this one? And why would anyone atttend their farrago of a conference now?
An overwhelming majority of Labour members, supporters and left-leaning voters oppose the Government's plans for detention of terrorist suspects for up to 42 days, according to a survey conducted by Compass earlier this year. The consensus could not be clearer: there's little appetite for any extension beyond the current 28 day limit.
Neal Lawson is urging people to lobby MPs.........here's the e-mails cruddasj@parliament.uk
trickettj@parliament.uk
Wednesday, 11 June 2008
HAS ANYONE TOLD COMPASS THEY HAVE SOLD OUT?
Posted by
susan press
at
14:42
Labels: faux left. COMPASS
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

12 comments:
The answer to the question is "yes, you have, repeatedly" but, in terms of the general point, it's difficult to see how Trickett and Cruddas can continue to be the parliamentary leaders of Compass after taking a position directly contradictory to the position of the organisation and its members.
Perhaps I have laboured the point a bit but I was deliberately circumspect on this one.Yes, it is indeed difficult to seehow COMPASS can have any Parliamentary credibility now
Well, Trickett and Cruddas may increase their credibility with people who do support this measure - which is quite a lot people in a general sense.
The problem is that those people aren't members of Compass.
To be honest I think John McDonnell looks pretty stupid walking way from the conference in a huff.
Let's look at the facts and leave the drama queen antics of John McDonnell to one side.
FACT 1
Compass are against the 42 detention bill
FACT 2
So is John McDonnell
FACT 3
Trickett and Cruddas are members of Compass but they are not Compass nor are they representatives of Compass other than being part of the Compass group of MPs
FACT 4
Compass have no control over how any MP, let alone Trickett and Cruddas vote
Given the above, why is John McD having a hissy fit? Compass have not suggested that MPs vote in favour of the bill, nor have they any control over how any MP votes. John McD just looks plain silly. It's grandstanding of the worst kind - i.e. where there is no logical reason!
"FACT 3
Trickett and Cruddas are members of Compass but they are not Compass nor are they representatives of Compass other than being part of the Compass group of MPs"
That's not a fact. Trickett is a co-opted member of the Compass Management Committee.
" Trickett and Cruddas are members of COMPASS but they are not COMPASS nor are they representatives of COMPASS other than being part of the COMPASS Group of MPs."
I see. Silly me. Alice In Wonderland stuff from another anonymous delusionalist
David - thanks for the correction. Fair comment
Susan - I still don't understand how two MPs voted means John McD gives a logical reason to boycott the Compass conference. Presumeably John will boycot the Labour Party conference and all other Labour Party meetings as so many Labour MPs voted for the 42 day bill?
John McD is in the rather odd position of sticking two fingers up to a political organisation (Compass) where two MPs voted for the bill in opposition to the organisation's position. But he is still a a member of the Labour Party where the official policy was to support the 42 day bill and hundreds of Labour MPs voted for it. It just does not make any sense at all. It just looks like a pretext to flounce away from the conference. If he so dislike Compass he should not have accepted the invitation to speak.
I understand John is the darling of the LRC and you need to support him but surely when he does foolish things like this a friend should say "you look a little silly."
For those of us outside Compass, Compass pretty much is Cruddas, Trickett and Lawson.So with Cruddas and Trickett having voted for it, that's pretty much it for Compass.
anon said:
"For those of us outside Compass, Compass pretty much is Cruddas, Trickett and Lawson.So with Cruddas and Trickett having voted for it, that's pretty much it for Compass."
I guess if that if you see Compass as just these three people if tow out of three support the 42 day policy I get why you might be pissed off with Compass...
But I don't agree with the premise is just these three people
From all the e-mails etc we all get from Compass, it looks as if Compass is a platform / organising base for Cruddas, Trickett and Lawson.
If Compass want us to think it isn't, they should think about communicating in a different way.
The people who are part of Compass are socialist, and these MP's do not get a easy time from us, make no mistake they will never get an easy time if the mess about like this.
Hi Susan, don't know if you're interested, but my diary of the Conference is now posted on my blog - http://spennypost.blogspot.com/
Comments welcome from you, or other attendees.
Post a Comment