The next time someone berates me for criticising New Labour, I will point out that Help The Aged, not just the usual left suspects, says it is a "national disgrace" that there are now 2.5million pensioners living in poverty. That's 300,000 more in 2006/7. The number of children living in poverty has also gone up for the second year running. Another of New Labour's pledges shot down in flames.
What's the problem? Well , tax credits , lauded by many, fail on two counts. 1. They subject millions to the indignity and unfairness of means-testing. 2. Millions more don't claim them so are even worse off than they could be under the current imperfect system.
What we need is a fair, progressive tax system which makes benefits universally available -and lifts our older people and low-income families out of the ghetto which tax credits and a refusal to tax the richest has created. I do not doubt that when New Labour made its pledge to end child poverty all those years ago it was a sincere one. But the New Labour way - taxation by stealth smoke and mirrors - has patently failed. We need an open and transparently socialist taxation policy
Tuesday, 10 June 2008
AN ABSOLUTE DISGRACE
Posted by
susan press
at
18:01
Labels: child poverty, Govt policy
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
Susan, a sizeable proportion of the UK is going to get even more poorer when the welfare reforms kick in in october. Disabled people could lose upto 400 pounds a year and maybe more, some will just not be able to work and will refuse the offered work and face sanctions. Why isn't the left up in arms about that as well.
Hi Susan,
You are certainly right about the need for more redistribution, but worth noting that the likes of Child Poverty Action Group, End Child Poverty, Oxfam and so on are calling for more tax credits to reduce poverty because researchers found that this was the most effective way to reduce levels of poverty amongst families.
Similarly, Pension Credits had prior to this year led to some of the sharpest falls in pensioner poverty since the introduction of the old age pension.
There's certainly a role for making it easier to claim benefits (which is in fact what making them universal but increasing taxes would do). The priorities to reduce poverty, though, are to get the government to increase benefits, whether means tested or universal, faster than inflation every year. When they did this, child and pensioner poverty fell, when they stopped doing this, it rose.
There should also be an acknowledgment that it's not just children and pensioners who matter when it comes to reducing poverty, and that working age adults without children also need more help. Levels of poverty amongst this group of people have actually risen since 1997.
Frenetic, I agree absolutely about welfare reforms. I want the government to increase benefits but I don't think tax credits are the way to do it.However much they are increased, I think the take-up is something like 60 per cent. Our role as socialists should be ensuring those esarning the very least are not subsidising those who earn the most. What has happened to low income adults without kids , for example, is a classic case of that. And people don't think it's either fair or excusable. Food prices are risng at an appalling rate.As is everything else. And it is going to get worse.
inflation linked pensions and benefits are meaningless when the very people who need those benefits spend a disproportionate of their income on food and fuel- the very items that have seen way above average inflation increases.There should be a different way of measuring state benefits and pensions that takes into account 'essential items' inflation .Due to the massive rise in energy prices the winter heating allowance is simply insufficient to meet the fuel costs of most pensioners.
Along with the 10p tax fiasco the latest poverty figures will further undermine people's faith in the purpose of this Labour government.I should add I'm not from the traditional left of the party, I had some right old ding dongs in my old CLP with the left in recent decades, but the party in government seems to have shifted to the right leaving me on 'the left'.
Child labour problems.:
According to ILO estimates, there are some
250 million children between the ages of 5 and14
years who are in economic activity in developing
countries alone. For 120 million of them, work is a
full-time activity. The remainder combine work with
schooling or other non-economic activities.
While most child labour is found in the developing
regions of the world, industrialized countries are not
entirely free of it either. In Eastern and Central
Europe, for example, child labour has been
reappearing in the wake of social and economic
dislocation caused by the transition to a market
economy.
In absolute terms, Asia, being the most densely
populated region of the world, has the largest number
of child workers. 61 per cent are found in Asia, 32 per
cent in Africa and 7 per cent in Latin America
Post a Comment