Just finished what may well be the last volume of the Benn Diaries. And it's strange to read a diary so contemporaneous with very recent events. I was there at many of the meetings /conferences/marches referred to in this latest volume. Which I can't help feeling - due to the slant editor Ruth Winstone wished to take - concentrates far too much on the personal rather than the political.
In truth, it is a rather melancholy read for anyone of my age who remembers Tony Benn when he was not a lovable old "national treasure" but a radical left-wing Cabinet Minister feared by the media and the Establishment. And I suppose it's rather upsetting to learn that life can be as lonely for a famous octogenarian as anyone else.
Mortality hovers around almost every page but thankfully, Tony Benn has the comfort of a huge extended family who are obviously extremely supportive.
I find it odd though how both Hilary and Stephen Benn moved to the right. Stephen was in my old constituency of Brent South in the eaqrly 1980's and then definitely a Bennite AND a Benn. Now he is married to a woman who was one of Tony Blair's advisors and clearly a New Labour enthusiast , along with Hilary.
It was interesting to read how Benn Senior refused a place on the stage at the 2005 Labour Conference for a keynote speech which son Hilary was giving. Quite rightly, he surmised it would be used by the Leadership as a signal of surrender - and that it would also upset his supporters on the left.
Outside the obvious family loyalties, Benn is so adept at friendship that he crosses not just factional, but party lines and stays personally loyal to those who have strayed far from their original ideals . An admirable and difficult virtue......however the book's postscript, I thought, illustrates how quickly things move on. Written only in July, it praises Gordon Brown as a "breath of fresh air" who Benn has hopes will listen to a diferent agenda and not govern from "top down" as occurred in the Blair years.
Just 10 weeks later, Tony Benn was speaking out at a Labour Briefing fringe meeting and absolutely horrified at Brown's proposals on Party ( non) democracy. The Blairite policies he denounces, like ID cards and draconian terrorism legislation, are now of course also being championed by Brown with the same bullishness and refusal to listen to the Party. I am reminded of that quote from Macbeth "We have scotched the snake, not killed it. "
New Labour, unforutunately, for the moment, marches on... happily so does Tony Benn
Showing posts with label Tony Benn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tony Benn. Show all posts
Thursday, 3 January 2008
BENN DIARIES - SOME THOUGHTS
Posted by
susan press
at
10:19
6
comments
Labels: Gordon Brown, Tony Benn, Tony Blair
Thursday, 5 July 2007
CONSTITUTIONAL CREDIT
Credit where credit is due and it seems Gordon Brown's proposals to discuss constitutional issues are being broadly welcomed - as they should be. No longer will Prime Ministers be able to take us to war at whim and, in fairness, Brown seems determined to give Parliament - and our people - back some autonomy. As Tony Benn says in today's Guardian
"Gordon Brown's statement in the House of Commons on Tuesday was by far the most comprehensive analysis of constitutional relations that I have heard in my
lifetime and could have a profound influence on our political future. I welcome
his readiness to encourage a debate and hope that opportunity will be taken up
by all those who have been campaigning for such reforms for so long."
lifetime and could have a profound influence on our political future. I welcome
his readiness to encourage a debate and hope that opportunity will be taken up
by all those who have been campaigning for such reforms for so long."
Posted by
susan press
at
10:55
0
comments
Labels: Gordon brown, Tony Benn
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
