Showing posts with label Labour leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Labour leadership. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 September 2010

MANDELSON AND DAVID MILIBAND

Peter Mandelson's astonishingly nasty outburst about Ed Miliband will deliver the Labour leadership to him.
It is surely a sign of rampant panic that the opposing camp are unleashing attack dogs uttering pronouncements which would shame the Tories on "scroungers and immigration."
One wonders, in hindsight, whether Mandy deliberately kept Gordon Brown in power to ensure a New Labour victory. for whoever took over after defeat
The spoke in the wheel is the leadership process which delivers a third of the votes to members and a third to trade unions.
In the past week I have heard rumours that the vast majority the second preferences are all going to Ed .
At this stage in the game, most of us have already voted. I urge those who haven't to help ensure we start a new phase in Labour's history - unfettered by people like Mandelson who should now be consigned to history. We know ed Miliband is only mildly to the left of his brother.
But the symbolic defeat os the ultra New Labour candidate can help us build support for policies which will signal a break with the Blairite years.

Sunday, 5 September 2010

SERVANTS OF THE PARTY - NOT THE ESTABLISHMENT

Andrew Rawnsley has a piece in today's Observer which, predictably, backs David Miliband for the leadership. Why? Because, according to Rawnsley, he is of the Blairite mould which believes elections are won and lost on the centre ground.
The point not made is that New Labour moved so far to right post-2001 that it was in territory so akin to the Tories that few could tell the difference.
Rawnsley's only concern is winning back the support of Middle England. The fact that millions of core, working-class voters walked away bothers him not one jot. He is at the very epicentre of the media establishment who lectured the Party for years - while it collapsed and died all around us.
None of the five leadership candidates is of the stature or experience of previous generations. Robin Cook would have wiped the floor with all of them Likewise Tony Benn, John Smith, Neil Kinnock and Harold Wilson. But we have to make a choice. Realpolitik ordains that, in the end, it is about one of the Milibands. Some I know are refusing to vote for either.
Rawnsley is an elitist. He describes Jon Cruddas as being of the "intelligent left" which presumably means those who don't back Miliband D are complete numpties. There was nothing intelligent about Cruddas swinging back to his comfort zone. Or disappointing the many supporters who had faith in him as a future Leader.
We should, Rawnsley says, learn lessons from the creed of Tony Blair who won three elections in a row.
It was not Blair personally who won those elections. It was Labour. Labour voted for by people who thought it represented them - a broad coalition who finally walked away disenchanted and disillusioned with Labour's last years in power. And the rapid trajectory to the right which Blair pursued in his final term
To win them back, we do not once again become courtiers of the City, we do not demonise immigrants, we do not allow the poor and jobless to be victimised , and we do not advocate wars and nuclear weapons and we take on the might of the people at the top.
I do not think the sight of the permatanned, Botoxed Blair touting his book around and hoovering up mililions is an inspiring one. It is time for him to retire from the stage, and time for the Labour Party to choose a leader who will at least not embrace the worst aspects of the ideology which it will take us many years to change .
Don't waste your vote in this election - vote for Ed Miliband second preference. However different one might like things to be, we have to start somewhere. Dispatching Blair's chosen heir is at least a start.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/sep/05/blair-miliband-labour-leadership

Thursday, 26 August 2010

BLOOD BROTHERS

To say I'm angry is putting it mildly. While the ConDems cut fuel allowance, tax credits, welfare benefits and come out with the most reactionary Budget in decades we poor souls in the Labour Party witness the spectacle of a Labour leadership contest which has become a farce.
Remember all that hooey about it being a pluralist contest which would give everyone a chance to vote for candidates of all shades of opinion.
We might as well have cut to the chase three months ago because from beginning to end it has beena two-horse race.
The latest twist in this endless saga is that "leading left winger" Jon Cruddas has come out for David Miliband. The very same Jon Cruddas once touted as a future left-of-centre leader.
Now returned, strangely to the Blairite fold.
It beggars belief that anyone allegedly left-of-centre in the Party would back a candidate who wants more of the same policies which have consigned Labour to opposition. The same policies which will give Cameron a landslide at the next election because there is nothing whatsoever to distinguish David Miliband from CamClegg .
What is even more cynical is that it was Cruddas who enabled Diane Abbott to get on the ballot. Likewise David Miliband . Left cover for both while, obviously, the game was to deliver another Blairite leader.
Now you know and I know there is very little to distinguish any of the candidates who have a hope of winning from each other.
That said, a victory for David Miliband will be, symbolically, a disaster for all of us who want some semblance of change. So, like most people I know my second preference will go to Ed Miliband.
What angers me most of all is that the left were denied a chance to vote for the candidate of their choice - and have a real debate with a credible contender
These Machiavellian right-wingers not only denied John McDonnell the chance to get on the ballot, they are trying to ensure we have Blair Mark Two. UNITE has answered Cruddas's call by urging members and trade unionists to vote for Ed Miliband. They are right to do so.
But Jon Cruddas has blown whaetver left credentials he had ( and I never thought he had any anyway) right out of the water. Hobson's choice - but sadly our only one if we want to rescue Labour .

Wednesday, 25 August 2010

BROTHERS IN ARMS

I have been away in Whitby for a few days and come back to some important tasks before I head for Ireland on Saturday.
Task One was to get in touch with all the CLPs in the country for the NEC hustings.
Which i have now done and thanks for the messages of support I am getting.
As the final countdown begins for the Labour leadership, it is clear the final choice will be between the Miliband brothers.
David Miliband's latest statements confirm that if he becomes leader there will be no retrenchment from New Labour policy and he will go for the centre-right ground. It is therefore very important Miliband Senior is stopped in his tracks. I am sure we will all vote accordingly.

Thursday, 12 August 2010

STRAW BACKS DAVID MILIBAND

The ludicrous nature of the PLP nominations process is again highlighted today as Jack Straw reveals he is voting for David Miliband.
The MP for Blackburn and former Home Secretary was among the band (including D Miliband himself) who gallantly rode to the rescue of Diane Abbott and got her on the ballot paper.
As the September 1 deadline for the ballot papers going out aproaches, one can only ask why?
Even on the left, the ranks are divided. I note with some surprise that the Irish Post has a double-page spread from Campaign Group member Linda Riordan explaining why she is voting for Ed Miliband
The irony is that the only MPs who are likely to vote for Diane are those who originally supported John McDonnell. And not all of those transferred their vote.
And some of those who did, like Linda, don't seem to be exactly supportive.
I think Diane will get a reasonable vote from the constituencies but she was set up at the outset by MPs who never had any intention of voting for her.
However thrilling it might have been at the outset to have been parachuted onto the ballot, I bet she's not feeling so euphoric now.
The sad fact is she has been used as a token nod to inclusive politics in a contest where the winner was always going to be white, male, and middle-class I don't think it's good enough. Next time, we have to do it better. And really mean what we say about being inclusive

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

MONEY CAN BUY YOU SUPPORT......

On Saturday I got a txt message from Ed Miliband asking if I was supporting him. Being a realist, I clocked that Miliband Junior was not actually at that minute staring at his mobile anxiously waiting my reply. He gets his minions to do it from Labour Party records.
By way of contrast, in the current crop of NEC elections, I did my best to contact as many CLP Secretaries as possible, with no help, and no money, just a wodge of second-class stamps donated by a friend and a list of CLPs donated by a well-wisher. The rest I did for free on the internet.
A few notches up the scale, there is a bit of a hoo-hah over the money David Miliband has put into his campaign. Around £200,000 or thereabouts.
Diane Abbott is right today to complain at the unfairness of canddates being able to buy support, infleunce and possible power just because of rich supporters.
The Labour Party apparently put a "modest" cap of £156,000 on the amount each leasdership candidate could spend. No-one apart from D Miliband has remotely approached that figure.
His camp say loftily it's all AOK because he just happens to be someone who has so much popularity that the money pours in. Wrong. Miliband has rich supporters which the others don't.
In fairness, David Miliband would be in a pretty good position to take a pop at the leadership with or without pots of money. So whuy does he feel the need to blatantly smash the opposition with expensive mail-outs .
Far fairer for the Party to allow each person the same access to membership records, CLP secretaries , envelopes and stamps. And a level playing-field. This contest has turned into an American-style contest where money is in danger of deciding the result.

Friday, 9 July 2010

CASH FOR CANDIDATES

At last week's UNISON leadership hustings in Leeds, Andy Burnham remarked, quite rightly, that it was time to retreat from "the old ways" of parachuting candidates in and the culture of control freakery which for years has disallowed debate and discussion at events like Party Conference. So it's immensely depressing to note that, yet again, money and famous connections are likely to determine the outcome of the Labour leadership election.
David Miliband has received an astonishing £185,000 from pals like Lord Putnam and that geezer from Blur who fancies his chances as an MP.
Ed Balls has a mere £28,000, from novelist Ken Follett, Ed Miliband £15,000 and poor relations Burnham and Abbott have declared nothing.
Maybe I am naive - but I view the fact that money can seemingly buy expensive leaflets, PR machines and ultimately the highest office in the Labour Party as deeply wrong.
This campaign should be about ideas, not who has most friends in high places. There should be a cap on individual donations -or the same amount allocated to all.

Wednesday, 9 June 2010

THANKS FOR ORGANISING......

I want to thank all the Party members, LRC supporters and socialists who tried so damned hard to get all six candidates on the leadership ballot.
MPs were lobbied , urged by organisationms from the Fabians to Compass and the LRC to allow a free, frank and honest debate on Labour's future.
Yer nearly 80 Mps chose to (needlessly) nominate David Miliband and nearly 60 his younger brother. Ed Balls, to his credit, did not seek any more nominations after reaching the 33 required.
As Dianne Abbott herself said, the threshold was upped from the original five per cent to 12.5 per cent to keep the left out.
The only reason she is on the ballot is down to the selflessness of John McDonnell in withdrawing - and some last-minute horse-trading.
It is not to the credit of the PLP or the NEC that things have worked out this way. They simply did not listen to the views, not just of ordinary Party members, but to major trade unions like UNITE , the GMB and CWU.
I know there are many thousands of disappointed left Labour Party mmebers out there. I urge you all to support Diane Abbott as first preference and make sure theleft gets a creditable vote. But let's not forget either how she got there. And how wrong it is that a candidate supported by thousands of grassroots trade unionists and socialists will not be on the ballot paper.

LETTER FROM JOHN McDONNELL

Dear Comrades

I am writing to let you know that I have withdrawn from the Labour Party leadership race this morning.

I stood for the Labour leadership as the candidate of the Left and trade union movement so that there could be a proper debate about Labour’s future in which all the wings of the party were fully represented. It is now clear that I am unlikely to secure enough nominations and so I am withdrawing in the hope that we can at least secure a woman on the ballot paper.

We came into this campaign knowing that it would be really difficult to obtain sufficient nominations but we knew we had to try. The support we received from rank and file party members and from trade unionists was just overwhelming but we still could not overcome the barrier of gaining sufficient support from Labour MPs.

I appealed to the party leadership to lower the qualifying bar to allow all the candidates on the ballot paper. It was perfectly possible within the existing rules for this to be done. Reducing the bar to 5% would have allowed all the declared candidates to get on the ballot paper and the Party to have a full and open debate about its future direction. The party hierarchy refused and instead threw its weight behind one candidate.

I know that many Labour activists and trade unionists will be disappointed.

I want to thank you for all your hard work in lobbying and campaigning to secure sufficient nominations to get me on the ballot paper. You could not have worked harder.

I am urging everyone to continue the fight for democracy within the party so that in future elections rank and file members will be represented by the candidate of their choice.

We must also now throw our energies into the campaign to resist the cuts that the Coalition government is launching against our community. Providing
leadership in this struggle is critically important in this coming period. We will be convening rallies and demonstrations and linking up with trade union action to resist the cuts. Let’s rise to this challenge.

Yours in solidarity,

John McDonnell MP

Tuesday, 8 June 2010

15 NOMINATIONS FOR JOHN McDONNELL

Thanks to: Linda Riordan, Katy Clark, Jeremy Corbyn, Ian Lavery, Jim Dowd, Frank Field, Kate Hoey, Dai Havard, Graeme Morrice, Dennis Skinner, Mike Wood, Ronnie Campbell and John Cryer.
It is surely now time for Dianne Abbott to consider standing down. Or for the NEC to do the decent thing and alow all six on ballot.

JOHN McDONNELL APOLOGISES FOR THATCHER JOKE

To put a bit of perspective on this, a friend of mine is set to quit the Labour Party if John McDonnell doesn't make the ballot. Thousands of people have joined Labour to vote for change.
There will not be change if all the candidates share the same politics,
For decades, the press has hounded Labour politicians. The distortion of John's comments from a jocular quip - which caused no offence - to a trade union audience into a full-on media bashing is regrettable but typical of the tactics of the right.
It is now also being used by rival supporters to try and persuade John to stand down.
Gaffes litter political history. Aneurin Bevan sparked outrage when he said at a rally back in the 1930's that the Tories were "lower than vermin." There were calls for him to be thrown out of the Labour Party. Ken Livingstone got into bother with the Evening Standard. And then there's Boris Johnson's remarks about Liverpool. Liam Byrne....... the list goes on. It happens
The people who are getting so upset about this particular remark, for which McDonnell has now apologised , shoukd recall the upset Thatcher caused to millions of working people, her ruthless destruction of the trade union movement, and her callous disregard for the millions on the dole.
Those calling for John McDonnell's head also need to get a grip - and focus on what matters, Which is the future of the Labour movement - and a concerted campaign against the cuts which look set to whisk us back in that time-machine to the 1980's. Thatcher or no Thatcher. If you want a reminder, she is visiting Downing Street today.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/politics/10263076.stm

Monday, 7 June 2010

TRAMP THE DIRT DOWN....

The Tory blogosphere is currently in uproar about a throwaway remark made by John McDonnell about Margaret Thatcher.
I would like to remind those blowing a gasket over what was basically a quip at a trade union hustings that Thatcher "assassinated" the NUM, the trade union movement, the hopes of millions on the dole, and indeed the Labour Party as a Government for 18 long years.
I would also remind those frothing at the mouth that it was the late not so great Kenny Everett who inspired hysterical laughter at a Tory rally when he urged the Party faithful to "bomb Russia" and throw away Michael Foot's stick. My guess is that, like John, he did not expect to be taken literally. But the Tory press will of course use any stick to beat the left with. Their apoplexy is nonsensical.

Friday, 4 June 2010

DIANNE ABBOTT - SO MUCH FOR DIVERSITY

Labour's Acting Leader Harriet Harman today called for 50 per cent of the Shadow Cabinet to be women. a measure, to be frank, I do not agree with.
Why? Because I happen to think political principles are far more important than gender and also because the current parlous state of diversity and democratic choice is not being supported by the people in the PLP who seem hell-bent on ensuring neither left candidate is on the leadership ballot paper.
As Dianne Abbott points out here, the current rules are a disgrace. And, yes, it is a worse disgrace that thanks to a gerrymandering procedure dreamed up to keep the left out neither she, not fellow left contender John McDonnell, is likely to be able to meet a threshold set ridiculously high.If Ed Miliband supports Harman's call for equality of opportunity he should put his money where his mouth is and tell male supporters to lend nominations.
In the interests of all of us, male and female, in the Labour Party.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/guest_contributors/article7143741.ece

Tuesday, 1 June 2010

JOHN MCDONNELL IN TODAY'S GUARDIAN

From the Fabians to the FBU, it is a truth now almost universally acknowledged that unless all the six decalred candidates for Labour leader get on the ballot the Party Establishment is set to make another huge mistake.
MPs have been coming under increasing pressure in the past few days not to nominate candidates who don't need any more support - and vote for their chosen preference when it comes to the crunch.
We shall see whether Mps are going to listen to the grassroots - or wilfully ignore the groundswell of support for real renewal - and a real debate. The next few days will tell whether or not we all start to work together again - or whether it is going to be a case of several candidates who basically all agree with each other. But whose views are not necessarily those shared by many in the Party and the trade union movement. John McDonnell argues the socialist case for Labour in today's Guardian.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/01/labour-leadership-hustings-john-mcdonnell

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/jun/01/labour-leadership-hustings-john-mcdonnell

Thursday, 27 May 2010

CENTRE LEFT JOINS FORCES IN INTERESTS OF THE PARTY

This letter steps up the ante on the growing calls for a fair and democratic contest. Well done all....


http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2010/may/27/mps-candidates-ballot-labour-leadership

Wednesday, 26 May 2010

FRANK FIELD NOMINATES JOHN McDONNELL

As the febrile atmosphere re the Labour leadership continues to grow, thanks to Frank Field and Dai Havard for nominating John McDonnell, who now has 4 official nominations ( with more to come) The Miliband boys are now ensured a place on the ballot so let's politely ask them to truly listen and send the message out loud and clear to MPs.
Across the political spectrum in the Labour Party, the mood is not one of same old, same old. Grassroots members want to be heard - and this time they are doing their utmost to ensure we have a democratic debate. Not a shoo-in Nominations are not votes - and there are now plenty to go round. More here: http://www.frankfield.co.uk/

GET SIGNING!

ACTIVISTS awake! In the past few hours NEC members Christine Shawcroft and Tribune editor Chris McLaughlin have signed Duncan Hall's letter to the NEC which has doubled signatories in a matter of hours. Please e-mail me SsPre2@aol.com if you wish to add your voice to the growing opposition to another stitch-up ........and add your CLP or trade union

THIS PLP IS BIG ENOUGH.......OR IS IT ?

Guardianista Jackie Ashley is a permanent resident in the Westminster media bubble with little concept of life outside London and the ( what was) New Labour elote. Yesterday she expounded on the merits of the forthcoming mayoral contest for London and the Labour leadership candidate. Message, Ooona King is a woman and black so therefore must be the 2012 candidate. Dianne Abbott is a black woman too so John McDonnell should "do the decent thing" and stand down. This is tokenist rubbish. Never mind the genders, what about the politics?
John's riposte is in todays's Comment Is Free and, as he points out, this eagerly-awaited contest is rapidly becoming a farce in which there could well be only two candidates.
No women, no ethnic minorities, no-one from a trade union background, no-one from outside London, no-one( hell forfend) from a working-class background., and quite probably no-one from the left.
In short, a two-horse race already stitched up by the PLP which will make the Labour Party a laughing-stock if it goes ahead.
I mean no disrespect to the Milibands. But many Labour Party members are getting very angry indeed at the appalling prospect of two MPs hoovering up nominations - which neither of them now need - to get on the ballot. And thereby depriving other candidates and the the Party of the chance to seriously talk about where we need to be to defeat this Coalition Government in a couple of years' time
Even in 2007, when we had the coronation of Gordon Brown, Labour's deputy leadership race had five candidates - and people felt seriously involved.
Can you imagine three solid months of hustings in which Milibands junior and senior traverse up and down the country talking to each other? A nightmare
The whole point of the electoral college as successfully campaigned for in 1981 was to stop MPs vetoing potential for debate and having the only say in who was leader and deputy .
The rules were sadly skewed in the 1990's to quell dissent which is why we have these absurdly high nomination thresholds. But dissent and discussion in very different times is now exactly what we need if this Party is to get up off its knees and build and grow in the years to come. It's time to send out a message that we are a broad church once again.......and get everyone on that ballot paper.

Tuesday, 12 May 2009

THE HISTORY OF MS POLLY TOYNBEE

In today's Guardian, Polly Toynbee finally puts the knife into Gordon Brown and says he must go. Just as two years ago she counselled Gordon was the only man for the job.
Her antidote to the current miasma is another coronation - this time for Alan Johnson.To say this smacks of desperation is putting it mildly.
One can only smile wryly at her suggestion we "valiant few" still left as Party members should go to our MPs and urge them to instal AJ ASAP without an election as if that would make a ha-porth of difference to Labour's chances.
I'd like to remind Polly that a "valiant few" of us tried in vain to get our MPs to have a contest last time for the Labour leadership. We were resolutely ignored by the vast majority of MPs.Over 300 of whom now bear the responsibility for installing a Leader who has turned out to be a catastrophe. That catastrophe just might have been less had he had to face opposition from a swathe of candidates and a proper debate about Labour's future. But the kingmakers in the PLP ordained otherwise and now we are where we are.
I see little point in a leadership contest now. But if Brown were to go, we would have to have one. We would also have to have a General Election pretty much immediately afterwards in a climate febrile with disdain for all politicians, disgust at MPs who cut welfare benefits then demand £400 a month themselves for food on top of a Ministerial salary, and even "left-wing" MPs who claim for posh rugs and furnishings.It is a mess of such fantastic proportions that we can only sit back and see what June 4 brings. But a whisky and revolver for Gordon Brown without some fundamental U-turns on policy and humility in front of the electorate is not the answer.Polly's "mea culpa" is below


http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/may/11/labour-gordon-brown