Jon Cruddas, Great Red Hope of the Islington dinner party circuit, is reported in the Mirror as saying it's time for Labour to turn left. The time for Labour to turn left and away from neo-liberalism was in June 2007 when Gordon Brown became Leader.
Of course, it was Cruddas and his comrades in Compass who aided the coronation of Brown, which made it so easy for Brown NOT to change tack and claim an overwhelming mandate in the PLP for same old, same old. So I'm afraid as far as I'm concerned it's a case of too little and probably too late. Cruddas is right to say the Party is in despair - however he is one of the chief architects of the despondency which is driving so many Party members to the point of walking away. And a significant number of others, sadly in my locality, to hand in their Party cards.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-stories/2009/09/09/turn-left-gord-115875-21658866/
Thursday, 10 September 2009
BIT LATE IN THE DAY, CRUDDAS
Posted by
susan press
at
00:16
3
comments
Labels: Jon Cruddas, the abyss
Tuesday, 12 May 2009
THE HISTORY OF MS POLLY TOYNBEE
In today's Guardian, Polly Toynbee finally puts the knife into Gordon Brown and says he must go. Just as two years ago she counselled Gordon was the only man for the job.
Her antidote to the current miasma is another coronation - this time for Alan Johnson.To say this smacks of desperation is putting it mildly.
One can only smile wryly at her suggestion we "valiant few" still left as Party members should go to our MPs and urge them to instal AJ ASAP without an election as if that would make a ha-porth of difference to Labour's chances.
I'd like to remind Polly that a "valiant few" of us tried in vain to get our MPs to have a contest last time for the Labour leadership. We were resolutely ignored by the vast majority of MPs.Over 300 of whom now bear the responsibility for installing a Leader who has turned out to be a catastrophe. That catastrophe just might have been less had he had to face opposition from a swathe of candidates and a proper debate about Labour's future. But the kingmakers in the PLP ordained otherwise and now we are where we are.
I see little point in a leadership contest now. But if Brown were to go, we would have to have one. We would also have to have a General Election pretty much immediately afterwards in a climate febrile with disdain for all politicians, disgust at MPs who cut welfare benefits then demand £400 a month themselves for food on top of a Ministerial salary, and even "left-wing" MPs who claim for posh rugs and furnishings.It is a mess of such fantastic proportions that we can only sit back and see what June 4 brings. But a whisky and revolver for Gordon Brown without some fundamental U-turns on policy and humility in front of the electorate is not the answer.Polly's "mea culpa" is below
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/may/11/labour-gordon-brown
Posted by
susan press
at
12:47
5
comments
Labels: Labour leadership, the abyss
Wednesday, 17 September 2008
TORIES AT 52 PER CENT ...........
Apparently, the latest MORI poll that's going to be the headline story in tomorrow's papers. Roughly translated - 121 Labour MPs left. What a great legacy for New Labour. Just how long can Brown stay in office? My guess - as long as the next by-election defeat. And that will be it......
Posted by
susan press
at
18:06
5
comments
Labels: the abyss
Tuesday, 9 September 2008
THE VIEW FROM THE TUC FLOOR.......
Depressing reading from the BBC website. Yes I know it's a lazy way of blogging but I'm playing catch-up woith six different things at the moment. No comment needed, really.
ROB MACKIE, NATIONAL UNION OF MINEWORKERS
The government is going downhill fast. It is just becoming less and less popular with people. It's sinking. The problem is that Gordon Brown and his colleagues are going away from what Labour is meant to be all about. They are not doing anything to help our members. They've got to do something soon or they will pay a heavy price at the election.
ROSA DAVIES, UNISON
Things are getting worse and they don't look like getting better soon. Financially we are no better off under Gordon Brown. I think he has been an abominable prime minister. I didn't mind Tony Blair so much. He didn't do anything that really annoyed me. The feeling is that Brown is being a bit stupid. We don't have to have such a big tax on fuel, for instance. He's not doing anything to help that's really relevant. I would rather not vote at all than vote for the Tories or the Liberal Democrats, but traditional Labour values seem to have gone out of the window.
ADRIAN JONES, UNITE
Brown isn't listening to the people. He has maybe about 18 months to start doing so, or we will end up with a Tory government. I don't think replacing Brown will solve anything, but all the normal working man sees is unfair taxation, while massive companies, especially fuel companies, are getting away with paying very little. Last year I thought we were ready for a change of Labour leadership. I was optimistic that Brown, who had been a strong chancellor, would be the same as prime minister, but he lacks the same strength as Blair. Blair was more vocal and could think on his feet. I actually preferred Blair to Brown. We are feeling exposed to the global economic problems and it's the government's job to protect us from that.
ELIZABETH TAYLOR, NATIONAL UNION OF TEACHERS
I just can't believe how lost Gordon Brown is. He's missing the point at every turn. We thought he would be more competent than that. PR is so important in this age and Brown is sending out the wrong messages. Of course, it's clear Blair got out at the right stage and there are big problems, but I think Brown should resign. He can't go back and sort things out now.
ALAN CARR, UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE UNION
Brown hasn't done terribly well. He's failed to communicate and to take the concerns of union members seriously. The problem with talking about replacing Brown is that there's no heir apparent. I think the door is close to being completely closed for Brown. There was a chance to do something new when he took over from Blair, in areas like the policy over Iraq. But the opportunity was lost. Brown should implement some radical policies like the SNP have in Scotland. There was feeling when Brown came in that he was substantially to the left of Blair. There isn't that feeling now.
Posted by
susan press
at
13:29
1 comments
Labels: the abyss, TUC conference
Sunday, 27 July 2008
THE PLOT THICKENS....
Tony Woodley was spotted having a drink with David Miliband . A signal, says the Sunday Times, that Something Is Afoot.
Posted by
susan press
at
11:25
7
comments
Labels: Labour leadership, the abyss
Friday, 27 June 2008
LOSING OUR DEPOSIT
Three years ago I stopped off overnight in Henley on Thames en route to Brighton for the Labour Party Conference. Nice pubs, great curry house. Lovely spot. But hardly a bastion of labour movement solidarity. Nevertheless, in the three years since the socialist dawn of May 2005, Labour's share of the vote has dipped from 14 per cent to 3 per cent and a LOST DEPOSIT. Not just staring into the abyss, but sinking ever further into it. When , when , when is the Parliamentary Labour Party going to act to stop the relentless march of the Labour Party to electoral oblivion in 2010. And stop allowing Gordon Brown to get away with one ill-judged policy after another. At least Ben Bradshaw had the grace to say it was "a terrible vote." That, Minister, is putting it mildly. So where did Gordon get it wrong?
1.Ensuring there was no contest for the leadership
2. Ensuring there was no-one in the cabinet from the left-of-centre
3. Inviting Tories like Digby Jones and Quentin Davies into his "big tent" and excluding the left-of-centre
4. Not facilitiating withdrawal of troops from Iraq and Afghanistan
5 Abolishing voting at Labour Party Conference
6 Dog-whistle politics on immigration and border controls
7 Macho posturing on 42 days, nuclear power, civil liberties
8 Further triangulation to the right and more Blairism
9 Public sector pay
10 10pence tax fiasco
I
Posted by
susan press
at
09:52
13
comments
Labels: by-election disaster, the abyss
Tuesday, 6 May 2008
WE ARE NOT THE STUPID PARTY......
Former New Labour acolyte Polly Toynbee makes many sensible remarks in today's Guardian -but still manages to draw the wrong conclusions. Quite rightly, she argues that voters are punishing Labour because a Labour Government punished the poor.
Labour, she says, is now the "stupid Party". Which shows just how disengaged this Guardianista is from the realities of life outside the media elite. Yes, the Government is almost unbelievably stupid. The Prime Minister more so. It almost beggars belief that in less than 12 months the country has swerved from goodwill and support for Blair's long-awaited replacement to poll showings lower than any in my lifetime. So what are they to do? Do the obvious progressive thing and bridge the widening gap between rich and poor, tax the rich, build more council houses, stop privatisng and outsourcing everything, stand up for civil liberties and internationalism. No, they are heading to the Right and ignoring every bit of sound advice from backbench MPs and activists. The phrase "lions led by donkeys" springs to mind.
Despite Polly's ire, she is also unable to grasp the obvious nettle and veer away from the predictable conclusions of someone who spends their spare time on the Fabian dinner party circuit - with warm words for right-wing hope James Purnell who is yet another New Labour clone and no solution whatsoever to the problems which we face.
To use Tony Benn's old phrase, it is the POLICIES not the PERSONALITIES at fault here. Though God knows I can't imagine enjoying a pint with any of the Brown coterie.
Polly, the Party on the ground is far from stupid. The grassroots know the game is up unless the Government reverts back to Labour - not New Labour - policies. Frankly, they know more than the politicos, wonks, apparatchiks and overpaid journalists who have solidly backed this reactionary Government - and Gordon Brown. Last year, the Party wanted a leadership contest and was denied it by MPs , plus the influential, omniscient likes of Toynbee, Martin Kettle, and COMPASS guru Neal Lawson who all joined forces and held hands in support of a man who is the biggest disaster as Leader we have ever had. In retrospect, how stupid was that.
We are where we are, which is looking into the abyss. But don't blame the Party. Apologies for ranting but I get SO angry reading commentators who haven't got a bloody clue how much the ordinary Labour Party members are sick of being preached at and lumbered with awful policies which will lead us even further into the mire. However much we protest......
Posted by
susan press
at
14:00
3
comments
Labels: media village, Polly Toynbee, the abyss
COMRADES COME RALLY......
The most important gathering yet this year of the Labour Left is on Saturday May 10 in London. Supporters of the LRC will join readers and supporters of Labour Briefing ( and hopefully others broadly in agreement) for a post-election analysis of where we go next and how we stop New Labour leading us to defeat at the general Election. The key speakers are Tony Benn and John McDonnell MP and I expect this event will garner far more media attention than is usual - far more importantly, it's the start of what I hope will be a concerted and determined fightback bringing some hope to the many disenchanted and disaffected. Venue is the University of London Union in Malet Street (nearest Tubes Goodge Street, Tottenham Court Road, Russell Square) . Other speakers include Murad Qureshi of the Greater London Authority and LRC Vice-Chair and NEC member Christine Shawcroft I will also be putting in my three penn'orth about the local elections.
Posted by
susan press
at
12:53
1 comments
Labels: energy policy, Labour left Forum, the abyss
