A few years ago I got a fair amount of gyp for daring to suggest Jon Cruddas was not the aspiring born-again leftie he was cracked up to be.
But JC's complete misunderstanding of the zeitgeist and recent backing for David Miliband showed just how right many of us were to be sceptical about his so-called credentials.
Well, what goes around comes around and I learn from an impeccable source that Cruddas did not come clean about his backing for the pro-Iraq Miliband until VERY late in the day.
I also learn that several close former allies on the left were tearing their hair out at his support for New Labour's chosen heir. They regard it as abetrayal and want no more truck......
I am no cheerlleader for Ed Miliband - but let us at least give him some credit for avowing a different stance on civil liberties and speaking out against Iraq. And let's remember that "leading left winger" Cruddas voted to lock people up on the 42 days issuye , was in favour of ID cards and of course voted for the war. Hope he shuts the door on his way out........
Wednesday, 29 September 2010
A FOOTNOTE ON JON CRUDDAS......
Posted by
susan press
at
00:04
0
comments
Labels: Jon Cruddas
Thursday, 26 August 2010
BLOOD BROTHERS
To say I'm angry is putting it mildly. While the ConDems cut fuel allowance, tax credits, welfare benefits and come out with the most reactionary Budget in decades we poor souls in the Labour Party witness the spectacle of a Labour leadership contest which has become a farce.
Remember all that hooey about it being a pluralist contest which would give everyone a chance to vote for candidates of all shades of opinion.
We might as well have cut to the chase three months ago because from beginning to end it has beena two-horse race.
The latest twist in this endless saga is that "leading left winger" Jon Cruddas has come out for David Miliband. The very same Jon Cruddas once touted as a future left-of-centre leader.
Now returned, strangely to the Blairite fold.
It beggars belief that anyone allegedly left-of-centre in the Party would back a candidate who wants more of the same policies which have consigned Labour to opposition. The same policies which will give Cameron a landslide at the next election because there is nothing whatsoever to distinguish David Miliband from CamClegg .
What is even more cynical is that it was Cruddas who enabled Diane Abbott to get on the ballot. Likewise David Miliband . Left cover for both while, obviously, the game was to deliver another Blairite leader.
Now you know and I know there is very little to distinguish any of the candidates who have a hope of winning from each other.
That said, a victory for David Miliband will be, symbolically, a disaster for all of us who want some semblance of change. So, like most people I know my second preference will go to Ed Miliband.
What angers me most of all is that the left were denied a chance to vote for the candidate of their choice - and have a real debate with a credible contender
These Machiavellian right-wingers not only denied John McDonnell the chance to get on the ballot, they are trying to ensure we have Blair Mark Two. UNITE has answered Cruddas's call by urging members and trade unionists to vote for Ed Miliband. They are right to do so.
But Jon Cruddas has blown whaetver left credentials he had ( and I never thought he had any anyway) right out of the water. Hobson's choice - but sadly our only one if we want to rescue Labour .
Posted by
susan press
at
18:07
4
comments
Labels: Jon Cruddas, Labour leadership
Thursday, 10 September 2009
BIT LATE IN THE DAY, CRUDDAS
Jon Cruddas, Great Red Hope of the Islington dinner party circuit, is reported in the Mirror as saying it's time for Labour to turn left. The time for Labour to turn left and away from neo-liberalism was in June 2007 when Gordon Brown became Leader.
Of course, it was Cruddas and his comrades in Compass who aided the coronation of Brown, which made it so easy for Brown NOT to change tack and claim an overwhelming mandate in the PLP for same old, same old. So I'm afraid as far as I'm concerned it's a case of too little and probably too late. Cruddas is right to say the Party is in despair - however he is one of the chief architects of the despondency which is driving so many Party members to the point of walking away. And a significant number of others, sadly in my locality, to hand in their Party cards.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-stories/2009/09/09/turn-left-gord-115875-21658866/
Posted by
susan press
at
00:16
3
comments
Labels: Jon Cruddas, the abyss
Friday, 19 December 2008
NO SPLIT FOR LABOUR LEFT
Jon Cruddas's latest predictions that the Labour Left is set to leave Labour are way off the mark. I don't know how he has the gall to predict that our masterplan is a new left Party when it has been made clear by the LRC time and again that we do not regard this as a viable or desirable strategy.
In a webcast "conversation" with the IPPR and that great socialist Martin Kettle, he baldly states that John McDonnell and other left MPs are planning to up sticks and that the Convention Of The Left - which he played no part - was a surrogate bid to go in that direction. Which is utter nonsense. So there are two conclusions.
Either Cruddas has been wrongly informed, which is excusable, or he is being deliberately provocative in a bid to badmouth the LRC and misrepresent its policy position.
The COL was NOT, repeat not, an attempt to set up a new party. Had it been so, we would not have got involved. If he had done his research properly, he would know that. Such public statements are reprehensible and , as Vice-Chair of the LRC, I'm absolutely outraged he should make them.
The Labour Left has every right to fight its corner, win or lose, within the Labour Party. That's where we are and where we are staying. To suggest otherwise is either wishful thinking or downright malicious.
Posted by
susan press
at
16:04
13
comments
Labels: John McDonnell MP, Jon Cruddas, LRC
Sunday, 5 October 2008
CREDIT TO CRUDDAS.....
Not one of my most common headlines I concur but fair play to the man, who apparently turned down a Ministerial job. A wise move. With news of Blunkett's alleged return, Gordon's increasingly implausible Cabinet is beginning to resemble the crew of the Titanic. Resurrected.
Basically, I think anyone with an ounce of principle must distance themselves from this desperate throw of the New Labour dice - which is all now about damage limitation and installing Purnell after the next General Election. Miliband, in true ruthlessly Blairite fashion, blew it and has obviously been discarded. We on the Left have to start planning now - time is rapidly running out.......I hope ( but do not expect that ) the renaissance of Mandelson might just have opened the eys of a few blinkered trade union bureaucrats. But in the end, it's up to us the rank and file to turn things round....however difficult.
Posted by
susan press
at
14:07
10
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Jon Cruddas
Thursday, 24 January 2008
NOT TOP OF THE POPS.....
In life, I have always thought it better to provoke strong reactions in people. Mediocrity is not something I aspire to. Nevertheless, a few minutes ago I was surprised to note that an AMICUS poster on Labour Home had referred to me as the "most hated person in the Cruddas campaign."
Given my complete obscurity and lack of influence, I find that pretty risible. But not, necessarily, a negative. Likewise the fact that back in November it was a fellow member of the West Yorkshire LRC who personally challenged Jon Trickett as to why he had nominated Gordon Brown for leader. Good on him I say.......
Sometimes in politics you have to keep quiet. But there are times when you have to stick your head above the parapet. I have never had a problem doing that. And I don't suppose I ever will. Whatever the consequences.....
Posted by
susan press
at
14:31
13
comments
Labels: anti-christ, hate figures, Jon Cruddas
Thursday, 6 December 2007
WELL SAID CRUDDAS AND TRICKETT
There is an excellent article here http://www.newstatesman.com/200712060017 signed jointly by Jon Cruddas and John Trickett. My only quibble is they are still clutching at the straw that somehow Gordon Brown is going to listen to what they have to say and that change will come from top down. I just don't buy that one anymore. I suspect they also think that privately but anyway it's a good piece and let's hope the left can build alliances in the months to come. Because we're going to need to muster all the resources we can.......and thanks to Peter Kenyon for pointing this out.
Posted by
susan press
at
12:40
5
comments
Labels: Compass, Jon Cruddas
Tuesday, 30 October 2007
THE PARALLEL UNIVERSE OF THE SOFT LEFT
I have just had a rant on Comment Is Free and now I am going to have another one.
Posted by
susan press
at
10:35
9
comments
Labels: Compass, Jon Cruddas, Trickett
Wednesday, 19 September 2007
CRUDDAS TEAMS UP WITH McDONNELL TO BACK TRADE UNION RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS BILL
I am very glad to note that Jon Cruddas is venturing out once more beyond the comfort zone of COMPASS. Since almost getting the deputy leadership ( and OK OK on reflection I should have voted for him) Cruddas has been very quiet. He went up in my estimation when he apparently turned down a minor job in the Government to paddle his own , very individual canoe. Once Conference is over, he will be speaking at the next big event of the political season.
A National Parliamentary Rally in support of the Trade Union Rights And Freedoms Bill proposed by John McDonnell will be held on Thursday October 18. First introduced to the House last year and with an EDM signed by over 187MPs, this has every chance of being passed - if enough of us speak out in support and lobby our MPs . More info . http://www.unitedcampaign.org.uk/ Other speakers on the day will include Tony Woodley, Bob Crow, Paul Kenny and Katy Clark MP. My union, the NUJ, is one of around 20 ( including UNISON and UNITE) backing the campaign .
Posted by
susan press
at
16:20
6
comments
Labels: John McDonnell, Jon Cruddas, Trade Union Freedom Bill
Friday, 20 July 2007
KEEP LEFT
Political pundit John Harris was talking drivel in yesterday's Comment Is Free . He praised Jon Cruddas to the hilt (OK, faur enough) but then rubbished the hard left on the grounds we were calling for "comfort zone shibboleths" like the re-nationalisation of the railways and more trade union rights. Someone should have told him that both were supported by his man as he was made to lookm rather foolish.
Still, whichever way you spin it, the left campaigns of both Cruddas and John McDonnell have had an impact on Gordon Brown's mood music policywise as he continues to enjoy a honeymoon period.The moves towards constitutional reform and more council housing are not enough- but they are at least a start.
In the wake of yesterday's by-elections, it really does look as though the Tories are toast and that is excellent stuff. But people on the left must keep the pressure on in a positive way and continue to campaign for a more radical agenda. Cruddas has gone very quiet indeed but I'm glad to note that John McDonnell is embarking on a series of articles for the Morning Star If anyone thought the left were going to roll over and die in the wake of Gordon's accession they are going to be seriously disappointed.
Posted by
susan press
at
10:25
2
comments
Labels: Brown Govt, John McDonnell, Jon Cruddas
Sunday, 10 June 2007
ANOTHER WORLD IS (STILL) POSSIBLE
In case anyone out there is wondering what has happened to John McDonnell well bob over to his blog www.john4leader.org.uk
Moves are now underway for the next stage of campaigning...... and all ideas and comments gratefully received.
I will be doing my best in this neck of the woods to carry on building the Labour Left and urge you all to do the same. Nil desperandum!
Posted by
susan press
at
17:10
0
comments
Labels: John McDonnell, Jon Cruddas
Friday, 25 May 2007
THE QUESTION OF CRUDDAS
Posted by
susan press
at
17:42
4
comments
Labels: John McDonnell, Jon Cruddas

