I have just had a rant on Comment Is Free and now I am going to have another one.
Jon Cruddas and John Trickett seem to live in a parallel universe. Their jointly-signed piece in today's CiF is a masterclass in self-delusion. They are, understandably, dismayed at Brown's performance since they both played a key role in helping him become Leader without a contest.Yet both continue to waste their breath calling on him to build a "progessive consensus"
Bits of the piece are utterly breathtaking in their distance from reality. Brown , apparently, wants to "deepen democracy" ( right, so he takes away voting rights at Conference and blocks the Trade Union Freedom Bill ) and is "stepping away" from privatisation ( by backing more Academies and outsourcing more NHS work ? ) Their call is for Brown to move back towards social democracy as he promised three years ago at the first Compass Conference. Actually, I was at that conference. In those days, Brown did use left-leaning rhetoric. But I think it's time Cruddas, Trickett and all the similarly confused comrades on the soft left woke up and faced some unpleasant facts. The only way Labour is ever going to move back in a leftward direction is by a realignment of ordinary members, trade union activists and left MPs prepared to take on board the fact that the leadership we have is the most right-wing ever in the history of our Party (the current pronouncements on immigration, frankly, make me sick to my stomach) The soft left is doing all of us a disservice by pretending otherwise.

9 comments:
Amen, sister.
What's so amazing is that it reads as if the Compassites have ONLY JUST realised what Brown is about, as if we didn't already have 10 years of evidence. I don't know whether this is a sign of breathtaking naivety, stupidity or just calculated and self-interested political timidity.
I even, in a way, found myself in agreement with Luke Akehurst's criticism that the article doesn't actually contain any meaningful concrete suggestions, even though he's coming at it from a different angle than us.
That said, the rebuilding of the left and basic social democratic tenets within the party does have to include yer Cruddas-ites. Though it's now patently obvious that Compass itself is just a useful idiot Brownite front.
I have no objection at all to working with Compass, Cruddas or anyone else prepared to admit they, er, got it wrong and we have to move forward.At the moment, they seem reluctant to admit the obvious truth which is that Brown wil NOT champion any kind of meaningful return to social democracy. Never mind socialism.....
I agree with what you say, except for the bit about the leadership being "the most right-wing ever in the history of our Party"... I think that dubious honour still remains with J Ramsay MacDonald, whose first administration called out troops to suppress a dock strike in London in 1923 (led by Ernest Bevin!), whose second administration refused to deal with the National Unemployed Workers Movement, or meet with hunger marchers, and who of course then skipped off to the Tories saying "every duchess in London will want to kiss me", because he felt that was the best way to cut unemployment benefit.
"by backing more Academies"
... but stopping any of them being run by anyone other than institutions with an interest in furthering education.
"The only way Labour is ever going to move back in a leftward direction is by a realignment of ordinary members, trade union activists and left MPs prepared to take on board the fact that the leadership we have is the most right-wing ever in the history of our Party (the current pronouncements on immigration, frankly, make me sick to my stomach)"
This is wrong. Surely the way forward is for us all to call each other insulting names, denounce each other, and march around with banners from the 1900s outside parliament?
Cruddo, Cruddas, Cruddat.
It's Latin for:
I desperatley try to keep my career alive, You desperately try to keep your career alive, He desperately tries to keep his career alive.
Oh come on el tom, that's poor. You're just caricaturing some very valid criticisms of the Compass camp. I'd certainly agree that we need unity between "soft" and "hard" left, but it's a bit rich to blame the hard left for the lack of it, when the Compass camp have always undermined such chances and backed the leadership when hard, serious choices - as opposed to producing warm words in pamphlets and at conferences - have had to be made.
They cocked up in backing Brown - a polite, comradely acceptance of that might be a bold and admirable thing to do.
Agreed.The soft and hard left dp have to work together.Who said anything else? Last week Jon Cruddas was I understand at the rally in support of the Trade Union Freedom Bill proposed by John McDonnell. Which I applaud. But at the same time the Compassite wing is still living in la la land and calling on Brown to jump through left-of-centre hoops he has no intention of even contemplating. And, yes, they did make a mistake in nominating Brown. That could not, I'm afraid, be clearer.
Without a realignment with comrades on the left who share their values and also an honest appraisal of where we are ( which the hard left is doing) Cruddas and Trickett are wasting their time.
Susan's suggestion she supports unity of the hard and soft left, when she doesn't appear willing to accommodate them, are laughable.
Yes you have differences on certain issues...but as you can see you have agreement on things like the Trade Union Freedom Bill and a large number of other areas...so stick to where you agree rather than sniping all the time...
Trickett wasn't just writing pamphlets when he was very constructive on organising the rebellion on Trident. Thats hardly backing the leadership when hard serious choices have to be made. Cruddas wasn't just organising a conference when he organised campaigning activity against the BNP.
If you are going to insult people, try to make it an accurate insult.
Post a Comment