There is a bit of a debate going on on the Hebweb about Labour's future. The following is a shorter version of my post on what Labour should do to recover lost ground.
New Labour was the result of many years of Tory Government and sheer desperation that Labour would never win office again. So many (myself included) were prepared to conpromise. In Tony Blair we (rightly) assumed we had an electable Leader who could win over a broad coalition of support. That broad coalition has now fallen apart and in its desire to keep Middle England sweet, Labour has lost much of its core support. Most siginificantly that of the working-class .
No-one disputes the achievements of the 1997 Govt. Surestart, Minimum Wage, Northern Irealnd, devolution. But in 2003 Tony Blair took us into an illegal and immoral war in Iraq which for many was the tipping-point out of the Labour Party. We have yet to recover from that.
When Gordon Brown became Leader many also hoped for a change in direction but it has not happened. Far from it. New Labour continues on its road of unnecessary and unpopular privatisations, ie Royal Mail, presides over a society in which the gap between rich and poor has widened, not lessened, and we have a tax system which remains beneficial to the rich. Well-off people actually paid more tax under Thatcher.
In 1997, we said we would re-nationalise the railways and not introduce tuition fees. We reneged on the promise re the railways and did what we said we would not do on top-up fees.We continue to allow the rich to get away with billions in tax avoidance.
Tax credits have helped many people but welfare benefits are derisory. According to the TUC, Jobseekers Allowance should be about £100 a week just to keep pace with inflation. It is about £60.00.
Yet we have committed billions to a new generation of nuclear weapons. At a time when four million people are on waiting-lists for council homes.
So it's not enough to say the Tories would be worse. The fact is many simply don't believe that. What to do? New Labour's status quo is not an option.
Labour backbenchers and trade unionists need to put pressure on the Government to put into place the policies which would win back support. Old state nationalisation might not be the answer but there are many models of social enterprise and alternatives to the iniquities of global capitalism - currently in meltdown.
We need to call for:
A fairer tax system
Millions more investment in social housing
More accountability for the banks we have bailed out.
Scrapping ID cards and Trident
The return of the private utilities into public ownership (doesn't have to be a State monolith) to end the profiteering which is leading many millions into fuel poverty.
The Socialist Labour Party and No2EU are not to blame for the BNP winning. Their vote was frankly, derisory.It says far more that Labour's vote collapsed and we got a BNP Euro MP. If people in the Labour Government are not prepared to listen to that message, then we really are doomed to have a Tory Government.
Thursday, 11 June 2009
WHICH WAY FORWARD?
Posted by
susan press
at
13:54
5
comments
Labels: BNP, Brown Govt New Labour, Euro elections
Sunday, 3 May 2009
CIVIL WAR AT WESTMINSTER
Charles Clarke has a majority of just over 3,000. Which probably explains why he is back in the business of slamming the Prime Minister and leaking stories to the media about leadership challenges. I was recently told by an NEC member that any MP with a majority of less than 3,000 should be scanning the jobs pages . The reality is many more seats are now at risk due to the unrelenting stream of bad publicity for the Government.
Most is self-inflicted. The issue of the Gurkhas, Damien McBride, MPs' expenses have all combined to make for a poisonous stew of suspicion and recrimination which means Labour is in freefall. How on earth to quell this awful miasma? Hazel Blears's "solution "is to have a go at Gordon Brown in today's Observer. With a rock-solid majority in my old constituency of Salford, she is one of the few Cabinet Ministers almost certain still to be there if it's as bad as seems likely at the next General Election. There is talk of 12 MPs defecting to the Liberal Democrats, a stalking horse challenge in the next few days, and inevitably a witch-hunt of the MPs who rebelled on the Gurkha issue. Downing Street strenuously denies talk of a hit-list which has been drawn up by the Chief Whip. The fact is that the NEC was recently treated to a presentation by Nick Brown targetting the rebels. And the intent is clear. Get rid of the Left because they are likely to be in the ascendancy after the next election.
If members of the Government would stop squabbling, take a step back and look at the recent policy mistakes they have made there might be hope of rescuing something positive from this mess. Scrap Trident, scrap ID cards, stop the smearing and the back-room manoevres. Likely? I fear not. The rabbits caught in headlights tendency is now not just sleepwalking to a Tory Government, it is actively encouraging it . And if they start on a witchhunt, then the Party really will be over .
Posted by
susan press
at
14:11
3
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, westminster gossip
Wednesday, 17 December 2008
HELLO, DOLLY< WHAT WORLD ARE YOU LIVING IN?
When you are part of the New Labour elite, life is a parallel universe. One in which you are immensely privileged and get more access to the media than the rest of us .So Derek Draper, writing in today's Guardian, seems to believe a rejuvenated Labour Government is on the up and that it's glad confident morning again for his cronies.
Derek, aka "Dolly" Draper, was one of the architects of The Project and a bag-carrier for Mandelson - he's recently been rehabilitated ( like his boss) Bizarrely, he almost turned up to our meeting the other night of the New Left Media Forum. It would have been interesting if he had because he might have been challenged for once in his take on political life.
I get back from France to find the Royal Mail being privatised, unemployment at its highest for many years and of course the wheels in motion to punish the poor and vulnerable via the Welfare Reform Bill .
We on the left will continue to fight those measures but if they do go through it will be with the help of the Tories who will block a backbench rebellion.
The good news is that the troops are seemingly on the way back from Iraq and due to their complete ineptitude the Tories' lead has been narrowed in the polls.
But that is a hell of a long way from what Draper describes as a " a shift towards Labour values." and a government which is on the side of working-class people. Whatever the empty rhetoric people like Draper and Purnell come up with.
Posted by
susan press
at
12:40
8
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Derek Draper
Tuesday, 2 December 2008
WELFARE TO WORKHOUSE
At the recent LRC conference, our Secretary Simeon Andrews referred to a "tidal wave of disgust" at some of New Labour's more reactionary policies. I predict this tidal wave will become a tsunami as James Purnell and Gordon Brown relentlessly try and steer Parliament into voting for punitive welfare reforms - a regime which will be backed by a newly privatised jobs agency. As a member of the Labour Party, it makes me sick to the stomach to read reports such as this one from the Press Association.
In the past few weeks, thousands of job losses have been announced. There will be more as the recession bites. This is what our Labour Government is planning........ no wonder decent people on the left are leaving the Party in droves
James Purnell is considering suspending benefits for some unemployed people
Unemployed people should do a 9 to 5 day looking for work or undertake community service style duties such as digging gardens under moves to tackle the hardcore of joblessness, the author of a Government-commissioned report said.
Professor Paul Gregg said there should be a completely new approach towards people such as parents of young children and those on incapacity benefit.
Virtually everyone on benefits should be required to take steps towards finding a job and should face having their benefits stopped for up to four weeks if they repeatedly refuse to co-operate with attempts to find them work, it was suggested.
Work and Pensions Secretary James Purnell said he "strongly welcomed" the report, adding: "
A welfare reform bill will be included in the Queen's Speech on Wednesday, and the report is part of the Government's drive to get more people into work and cut down the numbers on benefit.
Mr Purnell said: "The approach that virtually everyone should be doing something in return for benefits is the right one.
Professor Gregg, of Bristol University, recommended that sanctions should be quicker, clear and more effective, with a simple system of fixed penalties and an escalating series of sanctions for repeat offenders.
The report recommends a swift escalation of sanctions for jobseekers who fail to turn up to meetings and interviews.
Mr Purnell and Prime Minister Gordon Brown have visited Work Directions, a private sector organisation providing employment support and advice to those on incapacity benefit or income support.
Speaking afterwards, Mr Brown said: "We want to get opportunities for people to get jobs. We want to give them all the personal support that is necessary. We want to provide a personal service to everyone. I can assure people, having been here, that there are thousands of vacancies that can be taken up. We are determined to help people." This is not the way to do it.
Posted by
susan press
at
13:46
4
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Sunday, 5 October 2008
CREDIT TO CRUDDAS.....
Not one of my most common headlines I concur but fair play to the man, who apparently turned down a Ministerial job. A wise move. With news of Blunkett's alleged return, Gordon's increasingly implausible Cabinet is beginning to resemble the crew of the Titanic. Resurrected.
Basically, I think anyone with an ounce of principle must distance themselves from this desperate throw of the New Labour dice - which is all now about damage limitation and installing Purnell after the next General Election. Miliband, in true ruthlessly Blairite fashion, blew it and has obviously been discarded. We on the Left have to start planning now - time is rapidly running out.......I hope ( but do not expect that ) the renaissance of Mandelson might just have opened the eys of a few blinkered trade union bureaucrats. But in the end, it's up to us the rank and file to turn things round....however difficult.
Posted by
susan press
at
14:07
10
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Jon Cruddas
Friday, 3 October 2008
PRINCE OF DARKNESS RETURNS......
I've been feeling pretty poorly and out of it for the past few days - so much so that I had no idea till just a few minutes ago that Peter Mandelson had returned to Government. Let's just say it has not improved my health one iota.
Posted by
susan press
at
13:37
9
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Peter mandelson
Monday, 8 September 2008
MESSAGE TO NEWS OF WORLD - CHECK YOUR FACTS
I have come to this late because I got home very late last night from London and have spent most of today to-ing and fro-ing from Manchester but it seems my journalistic colleagues on the News Of The World have picked up - inaccurately - a story about my constituency's resolution to annual Conference
Yesterday, the NoW reported that "rebels are plotting to hijack the Labour Party conference with a spectacular protest against Gordon Brown." It also stated a resolution backed by CLPs would aim to unseat Gordon Brown. Wrong on both counts. The resolution from Calder Valley states quite clearly that the proposition to lower the threshold is when THERE IS A VACANCY. It's been tabled in the interests of democracy and the interests of a proper, transpsarent debate. This, of course, is not exciting enough for the News Of The World so they have been economical with the truth - and told a fib. Let me be absolutely, 100 per cent clear.
This resolution aims to rectify the mistake made last year when there was not a contest - it is about giving all wings of the Party a say. It is NOT about" hijacking" anyone. But it might of course annoy New Labour.......
Posted by
susan press
at
19:53
0
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Labour Party Conference, resolutions
Tuesday, 19 August 2008
IT''S THE POLICIES, STUPID.....
To the Guardian on-line this morning after night of insomnia ( got to sleep 5.30am but got through 300 pages of Michael Palin's Diaries) to read that changing Brown with Miliband would make absolutely no difference to Labour's poll ratings.
Maybe I'm just exhausted from lack of sleep but is anyone really suggesting this is front-page news. Why, exactly, would changing the face ( but not the policies) change anyone's mind? In the ICM poll, when people were asked to choose the best prime minister between Cameron and Brown, or Cameron and Miliband, the Tory leader beat both men by the same 21% margin.Well, he would. Because no matter how much fresher-faced he is , Miliband has exactly the same policies .And frankly people have wised up to that.
Labour MPs still sunning themselves in Tuscany or wherever need to take that on board and come back determined to change direction. A change of leader, in itself, would change nothing. A change of leader, and a change in policy towards the left-of-centre, would. Interesting. though, that more Tory voters are minded to vote Miliband. Will this news stop a coup in its tracks? We shall see in Manchester........at the moment we are still on course to lose 140 seats.
Posted by
susan press
at
10:47
8
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Saturday, 3 May 2008
NEW LABOUR'S DEAD
Forgive me for getting over yesterday so quickly but spirits lifted after today when I went on a May Day march in Leeds and then drinks with new friends and comrades on the Left. Maybe it was when Jeremy Corbyn MP said he had to leave as he was doing TV interviews re the state of the Party that I thought, yes, New Labour is dead. Not quite buried, not quite cremated, but definitely on the way out. Suddenly, the Left is news again. We have a major oppportunity now. When was the last time the media were seriously interested in anyone other than Blairites and Brownites ??? As we stare disaster in the face now is the time for the Labour Left to rally, build and get the message across it doesn't have to be this way. Our Real Labour policies could turn the picture round very very fast. Paradoxically, New Labour's death could herald the rebirth of Labour. As the rats leave the sinking New Labour ship. we have a serious opportunity to grasp victory from the jaws of defeat
Posted by
susan press
at
22:52
5
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, left values
Friday, 25 April 2008
IGNORE THEM AT YOUR PERIL
Today I got my P60 from the university where I have been teaching for six months . After tax, I earned just £3400. That was two days a week - with additional day prep time and marking on top. Shortly I expect my Head of Department, who lives in the next Valley in Colne, to arrive at my house with a shedload of scripts which will take at least three days to get through. No extra money.
I tell this tale not out of self-pity but to perhaps explain why teachers and university staff have had enough of dreadful wages and being undervalued.
This Government ignores the public sector workers at its peril. The old line of "but the Tories would be worse" frankly doesn't wash any more with many people I know. They have simply had enough of the hectoring tones of this Government and being lectured that there is no alternative to below-inflation wages while the rich carry on getting richer.
The latest YouGov poll puts Labour 18 POINTS behind the Tories. Which is pretty serious
Government concessions on the 10pence tax issue ( only forced by the 46 rebels) may temper that slightly next Thursday but the message from the electorate is loud and clear. Carry on down the New Labour road of punishing the poor and privatisation and we're chucking you out at the next election.
Posted by
susan press
at
17:13
3
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Tuesday, 22 April 2008
TUITION FEES REVISITED?
Remember when the departure of Blair was going to be the magic bullet? Not exactly worked out that way....... But I remember how everyone got terribly fired up by the rebellion over tuition fees in 2004.
At the time, it was said that if Blair lost the vote then he would go down. And he almost did - until Gordon Brown told his almost namesake Nick Brown to take the tanks off Number 10's lawn. The Prime Minister now of course advocates tuition fees and everything else - and more - which Blair stood for.
And where we are is with a situation where a vote against the Government is spun as "no confidence" and therefore eminently whippable. The Frank Field amendment, which seems to be the focus of attention, actually does not go far enough IMHO.
The 10p tax rate cut could and should be restored - I simply don't believe that it's impossible. Look how much money has been poured into Northern Rock , Iraq and Afghanistan.
This is the issue which will cost Labour hundreds of seats next week - and probably the next election. Promises it will be sorted out in 2009 simply won't wash with the millions affected by the loss of hard-earned money. Gordon Prentice, a splendid local MP who is "one of us" on the left, said that on Newsnight last night. And let's be honest. The issue of the low-paid being penalised affects far many more than the tuition fees issue ever did.
Posted by
susan press
at
10:18
3
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, election defeats, Labour rebels
Wednesday, 16 April 2008
ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE......
In my local the Fox and Goose tonight and someone said they thought I had gone over the top last year about Gordon Brown. They begged forgiveness.......comrades, gives me no joy. But we on the left were right........
Posted by
susan press
at
00:12
0
comments
Labels: A year is a long time in politics, Brown Govt New Labour
Monday, 7 April 2008
GIVE IT A REST, JACKIE
Talk about Groundhog Day. Wouldn't it be great to be Jackie Ashley and Polly Toynbee - getting paid for writing the same column every week. Today, Jackie A calls for Gordon to "return to Labour values." Oh, just give it a rest. What planet are these people on......
This is the man who has just given the 10p tax rate the chop, who loves hanging out with the money men in swanky hotels, an apologist for globalisation.
When, just when, are you going to get it? Gordon does not WANT to return to Labour values. No amount of cajolery, persuasion, whatever , is going to put the Old into Gordon Brown's Labour Party. Hell's teeth. he's even brought back the "New Labour " brand.......so please. If you're going to get paid a large amount of money by the Guardian find another topic to write about. Like how about it's time we had a new Leader and a Labour Government worth the name. Not this bunch of self-serving careerists.
Posted by
susan press
at
13:22
0
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Sunday, 6 April 2008
REBELS WITH A CAUSE.......
Gordon, according to the Sunday Mirror, is set to clamp down on rebels. I have sensed and will not be remotely surprised if the leadership resorts once more to witch-hunting and kicking people out of the Party. Such stories make me deeply pissed off, angry and determined not to leave But last night, I spent some time trying to persuade a young woman who two years ago was seriously enthused about the chance for change in Labour ie a leadership CONTEST with a socialist candidate NOT to leave. Frankly , who can blame her. It just gets worse and worse.....
Posted by
susan press
at
22:02
6
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Saturday, 22 March 2008
BROWN'S NEW "DEAL"
I am still getting over a particularly virulent bug - so my low spirits have not been exactly cheered by the news that Gordon Brown has struck a deal woth Sarkozy on nuclear power and immigration controls. The latter will be tightened up and the former will be championed by our Government. Every day, this apology for a Labour Government comes up with some new draconian right-wing policy. It's so depressing I can't be bothered to comment any further.
Posted by
susan press
at
14:32
1 comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Tuesday, 11 March 2008
FROM OUR NEW GENERAL SECRETARY.....
Do I hear the collective sound of Keir Hardie, Nye Bevan, Clem Attlee spinning in their graves? This "manifesto" is written by David Pitt Watson - author of "The New Capitalists" It could have been penned by a Tory. Well done NEC.....
THE CAPITALIST MANIFESTO
1. Be profitable and create value.
2. Only grow where you can create value.
3. Pay people fairly to do the right things.
4. Do not waste capital.
5. Focus where your skills are strongest.
6. Renew your organisation.
7. Treat customers, suppliers, workers and communities fairly.
8. Seek regulations to ensure your operations do not cause collateral damage and your competitors gain advantage.
9. Stay clear of partisan politics.
10.Communicate what you are doing and be accountable for
Posted by
susan press
at
10:51
9
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, NEC
Tuesday, 8 January 2008
LET'S PUNISH THE POOR.....
Hat tip to Don Paskini ( who have also added to my bloglist)for an excellent analysis of how Labour and the Tories are vying with each other to punish the poor and disabled by cutting their benefits. Pretty sickening stuff. As Don points out, even the Tories concede that over 90 per cent of claimants are utterly genuine. This is just a case of Brown and Cameron trying to out-macho one another ( putting it politely) and grab the Daily Mail headlines.
Posted by
susan press
at
18:56
2
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, David cameron, New Tories, Punitive policies
Thursday, 27 December 2007
CONSPIRACIES AND REBELLIONS -
Christmas finally over with and news emerges that in the New Year Gordon Brown will face the prospect of a parliamentary defeat . Why? Because he stubbornly presses ahead with plans for 42-day detention of suspected terrorists with no clear evidence this is worth pursuing. Even the DPP has condemned him, along with civil liberties groups and a swathe of MPs, including people like Leeds MP Fabian Hamilton ( hardly a serial rebel) . As the Tories and Liberal Democrats will also oppose, it's quite likely Brown will lose the vote. And he deserves to. Why? Because, as Alan Simpson says in today's Independent this is a
Labour backbenchers defied the whips 43 times, with the first rebellion coming less than an hour after he took over the reins of power. By way of contrast, Harold Wilson enjoyed 16 months of unity before a lone Labour MP rebelled over pensions policy. But that was in the days when we had Labour Governments which did not ape the Tories at every turn......It really hasn't been a good few months for Brown and already the conspiracy theorists are talking up talk of a plot to oust him. Things, it seems, are not going to get better......
Posted by
susan press
at
10:28
0
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, Plots
Monday, 3 December 2007
SAVE THE LABOUR PARTY!
The true nature of New Labour's planned agenda in the wake of the Abrahams scandal today revealed in the Guardian. And, apologies for yet again quoting Jackie Ashley. But this is the way the wind is blowing in the media "elite." And at Number 10. They can't wait to have a go at finally putting the last coffin in the nail of Labour's federal structure. Indeed, it is hailed as a "new dawn."
And, as Ashley says: "If Labour breaks the union link, and relies instead on donations from individual trade unionists and members, then the party would be profoundly changed. One of the great differences between Labour and the liberal tradition, going back a century, would vanish." And so, of course, would the Labour Party.
Posted by
susan press
at
07:35
8
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour
Sunday, 2 December 2007
TRADE UNION LINK IN MORTAL DANGER.....
Yes, I said I wasn't blogging today but fortified by Diet Coke and aspirin feel sufficiently outraged to report that Brown is now considering - wait for it - capping trade union donations and changing the political levy system. Effectively, that would be the end of the Labour Party as we know it. And if it happens I will resign my membership. End of story.
This move, originally proposed by the Hayden Phillips enquiry, was vehemently opposed by the PLP and NEC. Now, disgracefully, the furore over David Abrahams is being used as an excuse to revive the idea again. This MUST be nipped in the bud immediately. It's, frankly, a sign of Brown's desperation and I would urge all members, MPs and union activists to mobilise NOW to stop it happening .
Meanwhile back on Planet Zog Roy Hattersley, writing in today's Observer, says his faith in Gordon Brown is " undiminished." He then refers , mysteriously, to a speech made by Brown in "Manchester" on the theme of "Best When We Are Labour." Actually, Roy, the speech was made in Bournemouth in 2003 when Gordon was still grandstanding to the left. Light years ago.......
Posted by
susan press
at
12:37
7
comments
Labels: Brown Govt New Labour, New labour sleaze
