Friday, 18 May 2007

THIS LEADERSHIP IS A TRAVESTY

Just looked in the dictionary to check I've got it right. Yep."Ridiculous distortion or misrepresentation." Thought I would give it 24 hours to calm down.But as of now Friday May 18 I still think democracy in the Labour Party finally died this week. The ultimate control freakery after years of Party hacks taking the piss and taking over conference, turning it into a Nuremberg rally, blocking resolutions, "encouraging" delegates to vote a certain way.
Thousands were heartened by the fact that someone had the guts to stand up to New Labour in the hope that things would change, if not now, then the future. I argued myself silly getting people to re-join on that promising basis.
Now we have a Leader who I have no doubt is backed overwhelmingly by the PLP. But not, as we knew, by a significant number of Party members, trade unionists and affiliated organisations. That division, however small, was unacceptable to the Brown machine.But let's not blame them entirely. Let's also blame the cowardly, spineless MPs who put their perosnal interests before the people who put then there in the first place, the "left" MPs who failed to deliver, the trade unions who preferred to put their money on someone who wouldn't frighten the horses rather than help advance socialism.Yes, I know it's "blame culture" ,notconstructive, not positive, not helpful.But after years defending the indefensible, accepting the unacceptable, being desperate for Blair to go, what do we get? Something a hell of a lot worse. A Leader imposed on us from above, whom many had already decided they did not want to vote for, and who will almost definitely lead us to defeat at the next election. And you know something? I'm not sure I care

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

What are you gonna do about McCafferty then??? In my book, she's just as high up on the "Spineless 'Left' MPs" list as, say, John Austin and Marshall-Andrews.

susan press said...

I am seeing her tonight. She's standing down anyway and we're going to pull out all the stops to get left candidate.Yes, she was spineless too.

Anonymous said...

I don't think it's a travesty by your dictionary definition.

It's not a ridiculous distortion or mis-representation of the views of the PLP.

Given the rules, the outcome isn't especially surprising.

I thought JM ran a good campaign but it was always unlikely that the second most left-wing MP in the PLP would get the votes of 44 others.

If the Campaign Group had come together and decided they really wanted a candidate on the ballot, they wouldn't have run McDonnell.

That's politics.

susan press said...

It may be politics, but it's not democracy. And the PLP figure DOESN'T repreent, by any stretch of the imagination, support for Brown in the labour movement as a whole.One of the key things supposed to separate Labour from other parties is its federal structure, which has been utterly ignored. as I said, a travesty. I daresay the Miliband camp is equally pissed off. And, for once,am on their side.Still, no doubt they will be back too.
Given Alan Simpson is standing down and Michael Meacher will be over 70 by the time of the next election, this could well be a game of two halves.I hope so

HenryG said...

A contest would have been good, but I'm not that surprised John McDonnell didn't get on. I thought after Meacher stood down it would have been ok. Meacher's attempt to stand really put a spanner in the works - it stalled momentum for your guy and made the left look factionalised.

Chris McCafferty is standing down so she had nothing to lose in backing John McDonnell. I would be genuinely interested to know if she had a problem with him or something?

susan press said...

Meacher meant the whole thing was scuppered for the reasons you say. In the circumstances, John did well. With no Meacher factor, I'm pretty sure he would have madeit. But maybe not.
I'm starting to feel less negative now. he got 24 hours in the media sun,a Fabian debate with Gordon Brown, After all the work he put in, he deserved to get a contest. I think most agree on that.Something tellsme Brown won'tbe leader for very long.I hope the left gets another chance - with one candidate from Day 1.

Chris Paul said...

I'm not sure what to say Susan. There's little point in blaming Brown or PLP members in my view. We know what he's like. We know what they're like.

I just wish some of the Brownies had had more gumption in 2001 or 2002 or 2005. Playing hard ball to win is the only way politics can be played. Can hardly complain if they find their feet now.

If they believed there was a 1% chance of their man being beaten in a contest they needed to try and eliminate that small chance I suppose. They could perhaps have taken the risk and eased off but if the boot was on the other foot would John have done that? Or would he have crushed the opposition when he had the chance?

There's the rules (also a given) and then there's the left's response to the rules, the latter being the only thing immediately within our control.

I simply don't think the response was correct this time given the rules and the territory.

We must now concentrate on making Gordon as true to "we're strongest when we're Labour", trying to leverage the most from a dull DL contest, winning elections where we are, and being a lot smarter in working with the media and the rules aad the party structures than we have been.

Some good less learned I hope.

Anonymous said...

Actually Chris I disagree re: response to the rules. We did it the only way we could and it NEARLY worked. It had to be a grassroots campaign that fought its way in. A parliament-led campaign would never have got off the ground.

The campaign has actually done a lot of good. The fact that we're all talking to each other online here today is thanks to this campaign. Let's keep doing it and keep building. We'll win next time.

Anonymous said...

Chris is right.

People who thought McDonnell would get on the ballot paper were deluded.

As Diane Abbott said on This Week, his candidacy was misconceived.

Anonymous said...

No we weren't, anonymous. And Diane's very Westminster-based view is a long way from seeing the full picture.

Let's not re-write history: have a look at the Guardian today; the only reason John didn't get on the ballot paper is because Brown and his team fought to the last vote to prevent it. And that was pathetic and an affront to millions of party and union members who deserved more respect.

Anonymous said...

Susan, chek this out! I'm sure you'll find it interesting!

http://politics.guardian.co.uk/labourleadership/story/0,,2083186,00.html

Anonymous said...

how does the Guardian change the fact McDonnell was never going to get on the ballot paper, and everyone knew it?

Anonymous said...

Because it shows how Brown fought tooth and claw for every last nomination.

Archie said...

You should be very proud of all your hard work during the John4Leader campaign.

John getting on the ballot paper would've been the icing on the cake, but even without the icing its still a bloody yummy cake.

Left wingers have been brought back into the party and are now more organised. The ideas of the left were giving an airing in the media not seen for a very long time, including the excellent Fabian debate.

The left is stronger for all your hard work and is much better placed for the battles ahead

E10 Rifle said...

"As Diane Abbott said on This Week, his candidacy was misconceived."

Yeah but she would. She's had the hump with McDonnell ever since he criticised her for sending her kid to a private school. I mean, fair play to her for backing McDonnell, but she was never very enthusiastic about it and her reasons for this lack of enthusiasm were pretty petty.

She isn't much of an asset to the left anyway.

Anonymous said...

"No we weren't, anonymous. And Diane's very Westminster-based view is a long way from seeing the full picture."

In terms of getting on the ballot, the Westminster view was what mattered.

There was never any prospect that Compassite MPs such as Jon Trickett or Jon Cruddas would nominate JM.

Rightly or wrongly, the whole basis on which Compass is attempting - successfully or otherwise - to rebuild a credible centre-left of the Labour Party is the basis that it's offering a modern left programme not connected to outdated hard left thinking.

You might disagree with this idea but I don't think it's never been a secret.

susan press said...

David, what exactly is the point of Compass then? It advocates soft-left policies then backs a right-winger.Have you guys never heard of solidarity? I joined Compass thinking it was about building links with the left and centre-left.Not renewing my subscription.

Anonymous said...

David - if we'd taken just a westminster view, we'd never have got close (we'd just be like John Reid!) - and nobody would be talking about it now. The grassroots-led campaign was absolutely the right strategy. The mistake was underestimating Brown's utter ruthlessness and disregard for his own mandate.

Compass can look to themselves - but it will be hard for those MPs to complain about Trident, etc. next time around because they new exactly what they were nominating.

Anonymous said...

none of this changes the fact that John McDonnell was never going to get on the ballot paper. Another candidate could have done. Just like Cruddas. Anything other than a strong vote for Cruddas would be a disaster for the left.

Anonymous said...

No, the disaster for the left is not getting McDonnell on the ballot.And, er, Cruddas could have facilitated that.Exactly how will Cruddas being DL help? Do you really think Gordon will listen to the grassroots?? Face facts.He listens to no-one

Anonymous said...

i think the system of letting MPs decide who should stand in a leadership election is just open to abuse - then to gve them a third of the vote is unfair!

Why doesn't every CLP have a quick hands up vote with their MP as to which candidate they should nominate (muc more democratic huh?) the after that it should be the Unions and party members who decide. MPs as being representatives of their members should be allocates just a vote like everyone else.

That would make the 'system' fairer, less open to abuse and take the power away from the PLP in nominating and electing candidates.

Jon