Saturday, 19 May 2007

WHY I'M VOTING FOR HILARY BENN

Hilary Benn and me go back a long way (well. sort of). Back in 1983 I campaigned for Hilary when he stood as MP for Ealing North.Yes, we lost.
Then two weeks ago I did a phone interview with Hilary for a publication I work for. I was impressed with his honesty and integrity and clear respect for those who are to the left of him. Yes I know he has to be nice to his dad but, on issues like Iraq and Trident, he agreed to disagree while sharing the same aims as me. ie peace, social justice and democratic socialism. That used to be the way in the Labour Party. It was a broad church. The way to champion one's beliefs was via honest debate. This week, the broad church tradition was renounced by the PLP. The deputy leadership candidate allegedly with "left" views, Jon Cruddas, failed to back the leadership candidate who shared his views on Trident and party democracy.So he lost my vote and, I suspect, the votes of thousands of others. The other candidates veer from unspeakable (Blears) to wishy-washy (Harman) . Alan Johnson is all things to all men and Hain will get my second preference if Benn doesn't make it. I cannot pretend I vote with the same enthusiasm as I did when Tony Benn stood as deputy in 1981.But it's better than the alternatives.

15 comments:

HenryG said...

Errr but Hilary Benn didn't vote for McDonnell either and voted for trident, top-up fees, isn't backed by any trade union and was heckled last week for stereotypical remarks about women. I think you've totally lost the plot. Bye.

Anonymous said...

Well Cruddas' voting record is fairly dodgy, and that's despite not having been bound by any sort of collective ministerial responsibility.

I agree with Susan that Benn is a broad church Labour figure. I didn't hear his 'stereotypical remarks' (what were they?) but I think he's probably the best of a bad lot.

Basically all we're voting for is which member of Brown's Cabinet can have a bit of job security after all. Why not give it to Hilary? Party members generally rather like him, in my experience. He may struggle a bit with the union section (surprising really considering, unlike Cruddas, he hasn't proposed eroding the link).

susan press said...

Benn said something like women tend to stay at home and look after the kids. Er, they do......
Cruddas voted for Iraq was but has decent policy positions on Trident, top-up fees and the Trade Union Freedom Bill.He then delberately nominated the person who opposed all three having garnered support from the left.That's dishonest.And if cruddas were in the cabinet no doubt he would have toed the Govt line.The man is a careerist and a sham.Benn is honest and consistent. He's not my ideal candidate. But none of them are.

Unknown said...

I would agree on Benn being the best candidate for deputy PM, what really matters here is a clear break from the recent past, some real belief from the polictians combined with integrity and honesty. I feel you get that when you hear Hilary Benn speak on the issues.

Anonymous said...

Bloody hell, talk about sour grapes from the hard Left. Jon Cruddas will probably be better off with you lot instead backing the most pro-war candidate running, if this is how you treat your first choice because he exercised some individual thought.

E10 Rifle said...

Can we drop all this "hard left" stuff please. McDonnell stood on a policy programme that was essentially shaped by recent party conference votes - it was hardly calling for workers' militias and nationalising the top 50 companies.

Anyway, I still think the left should back Cruddas. OK, it was gutless of him to nominate Brown, and I can't say as I massively trust him, but - however decent and honest Benn is - Cruddas has the most left-tinged actual policies. It would send out a bad and misleading signal about the party if Cruddas was to poll badly.

And it would make it easier for people to portray the left as fractious toys-out-of-pram throwers.

Anonymous said...

e10 - I agree that people shouldn't just vote anyone-but-Cruddas because of last week's events. However, if people choose to vote for a different candidate, that seems fair enough.

Anonymous said...

Looking from the outside in, I do rather wonder at you football, ooops, sorry, political fans. (My slip is excusable when you spend as much time as me listening, uncomprehendingly, to 'TalkSport' radio on which two sets of fans in the same stadium see two different matches!) Your *surprise* that the Brown machine flattened your, shall we say, less than impressive candidate (the PLP opinion, not just mine) simply confirmed my opinion that political activists who pursue their 'hobby' do so for its own sake not for any realistic purpose. And just to prove it yet again, here you all are getting tremendously het up about who will win the utterly useless non-job of deputy leader of your party.

Forgive an outsider offering a little advice but lift your heads up from the narrow channel in which you beaver away and look around you! Dave Osler is dead right (no pun intended), the world has moved on. You are in danger of emulating the Flat Earth Society.

susan press said...

Jon Cruddas did not exercise "individual thought" He cynically used the left as a platform then dumped on us. Call me old-fashioned but I don't find that kind of behaviour very impressive.

Anonymous said...

Mr. Duff - you're quite right. The deputy contest is a complete distraction and waste of time. Which begs the question: what has happened to democracy in the Labour Party?

Anonymous said...

Well, it's a choice for me between Cruddas, Hain and Benn. The reasons for possible voting Hain have been well-voiced by ex MP Harry Barnes on his site
http://threescoreyearsandten.blogspot.com/
He wrote
"I kept pressing for Peter Hain to stand for the Leadership of the Labour Party on the grounds that he was a closet Libertarian Socialist who could come forward with a feasible left-leaning platform that could stimulate a much needed debate in the Labour Party."
Also see his comments under "I Had A Dream"

susan press said...

Harry might have had a point. I will vote for Hain 2nd preference, mabe 1st. Fact is, it doesn't really matter.

Archie said...

What preference will you give to Cruddas if you dont mind me asking?

susan press said...

None.

Anonymous said...

It is a waste of time, the post of DPM is just not needed. What is it but a fancy title, pay rise and some extra perks of the job - it's just for 'social status' - the kudos for having the name.

As it doesn't matter, people who don't agree with what happened in the PM 'elections' should spoil their ballot paper and they should be sent back in their thousands to send the message that this is 'fake democracy' and is just not on.

Personally, i look at the candidates and i find that non are representative of the majority of 'working' people, so i couldn't actually relate to any. It reminds me of the last local elections where my mum went to vote and i asked her who and she didn't know, so i said why are you voting then and she said 'oh, feel as though i should vote for someone'. She didn't know, no one was standing who would do things for normal, working people and the candidates (who were likely to win) were nothing more then pawns for 'fake democracy'.

Jon