I hope Owen, who works for John, doesn't mind me sharing his thoughts on the story so far..........welcome to Albania
Even when Brown had won over two-thirds of the PLP, he was still ringing round MPs and doing all that he can (with his power of patronage, blackmail etc) to ensure that they nominated him.After Sunday's debate, Brownites decided that they did not want a contest with John. John impressed even the most hardened Brownites. Even the Blairite deselected MP Jane Griffiths - who on Saturday described John as a "trot gobshite" on her blog - wrote, after attending the hustings, that John was the best performer.Brown knew that John had every chance of winning a significant section of both the party and union votes and he decided to do all he could to prevent that from happening.Whatever the parliamentary gatekeepers decide, there is a) grassroots support for John and b) overwhelming grassroots support for a contest.If the MPs block a contest, then you have no way of disproving either a) or b).


10 comments:
Whenever a friend or colleague laments to me that there is no one in the government that shares their views I send them the link to John's website. The response I always get is some form of 'why isn't this guy prime minister?', and after the debate it was obvious that this could happen on a national scale. Even if John lost the election by a big majority he would certainly succeed in shifting the frame of the debate to the left and Brown wasn't prepared to take that risk.
'Even if John lost the election by a big majority he would certainly succeed in shifting the frame of the debate to the left and Brown wasn't prepared to take that risk.'
If John had got battered then the left would actually have been weaker. You've been saved.
I am absolutely gutted that John never made it and my immediate reaction was to cancel my recent re-entry into the Party that I first joined in my early twenties.
However, your comments here, and on other sites, have inspired me and I am determined to stay in and fight to reclaim our party.
Many thanks for your work, commitment and inspiration.
And good luck to John and his many supporters.
Cheers, Newsnight. A rotten day.Let's hope for better ones.....
Is it true that Marsha Singh MP appeared on McDonnell's list when he met with Meacher even he has never signed anything for McDonnell?
No idea.Sounds like pointless mischief-making.
It was mentioned in the Guardian:
"Mr McDonnell's hopes evaporated amid allegations that someone had signed on behalf of the Bradford West MP, Marsha Singh, to help ensure he became the candidate of the left.
On Monday it was announced that Mr McDonnell had secured more nominations than Michael Meacher, his challenger to lead the left's fight against Mr Brown. As a result, Mr Meacher pulled out of the race, conceding that Mr McDonnell had more support than him.
It is understood that Mr Meacher was furious when he was made aware of the uncertainty around the signature and demanded to see the nominations again. But he was told they had been shredded.
Mr Meacher refused to comment last night on what he described as private meetings. But it was noticeable that very few of his supporters switched to Mr McDonnell.
Speaking from Thailand, where he was on a parliamentary trip, Mr Singh denied that he had signed Mr McDonnell's nomination paper.
He said: "Michael Meacher came to my office twice, once to see what I thought and once to bring the nomination papers.
"I never signed John McDonnell's paper. My signature was not on both ... I have never sat and discussed the matter with John McDonnell and never ever had a conversation with him."
Mr Singh's office confirmed the quotes were accurate and said he would be raising the matter directly with Mr McDonnell"
I don't believe it. Meacher's "nominations" were always highly dubious but John was several votes ahead of Meacher anyway.If John had known how dubious some of them ie Meacher's were he would probably have pulled out before but at least we had the joy of seeing Meacher stand down....
They will be trying to disprove a and b by getting as many party units as possible to send in supporting nominations.
Susan, there's a letter by Simpson and Wood in the Guardian about that MP nomination. The relevant part is "Marsha's nomination was properly allocated to Michael Meacher, but made no difference to the overall result, which was amicably agreed"
Post a Comment