There is an excellent article here http://www.newstatesman.com/200712060017 signed jointly by Jon Cruddas and John Trickett. My only quibble is they are still clutching at the straw that somehow Gordon Brown is going to listen to what they have to say and that change will come from top down. I just don't buy that one anymore. I suspect they also think that privately but anyway it's a good piece and let's hope the left can build alliances in the months to come. Because we're going to need to muster all the resources we can.......and thanks to Peter Kenyon for pointing this out.
Thursday, 6 December 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
The assertion that 'Society was no longer to be master of the market, but its servant,' could only be made by someone who believes state capitalism is the remedy for market failure and who has never come close to understanding the intellectual underpinnings of New Labour.
The truth is that New Labour accepted that markets exist whether we like that or not. And more importantly that market failure needs to be addressed with, for example, smart regulation (e.g. the minimum wage) and targeted taxation (e.g. on fossil fuels).
Sadly a decade on the backbenches has left the Jons so embittered that their only pleasure is to see the government flounder.
And I don't see how this can be squared with bourgeois socialism's desire to champion the petit bourgeoisie shopkeeper.
I think this is completely wrong. Markets may exist whether we " like them or not" but the solution is NOT to let them rule our public services, wilfully privatise, wilfully not extend trade union rights and protection to agency workers. And of course waste millions on nuclear weapons.
And I am SICK of people banging on about the minimum wage. How much do you earn, Stephen? It is £35 take-home a day and NOT a living wage. I am not in fact a particular champion of either Trickett or Cruddas for reasons I won't bore everyone with again but your comment re their "decade on the backbecnhes" is utterly unfair. Cruddas was in fact a New Labour supporter and to some extent remains so. I think it would give neither John pleasure to see the Govt founder. Their point is that it it will unless there is a change of direction leftwards.
Hopefully, a defence of ‘core labour values’ as mentioned in this article would include a robust defence of the welfare state, this is needed urgently. The pace of welfare ‘reform’ as epitomized by Peter Hain with his 'ending Sicknote Britain call, (with its attendant benefit scroungers’ as the new folk devils), is breath taking in its scope and ferocity. Sixty years of decent social democratic welfare provision is being dismantled in front of our very eyes, with US style ‘welfare to work’ being introduced, housing benefit abolished and disabled people being forced, yes, its compulsorily, into unsuitable work and even medical interventions.
The welfare system is also being marketised very very rapidly, again taking its cue from neo-liberal countries such as the US and Australia, with massive private training companies replacing accountable civil servants, thus the profit motive enters vulnerable peoples lives. Jon and others must make defending the weakest and most vulnerable in our society, any reconfigured left’s priority, yes, internationalism and global issues are crucial, but so is what is happening in our own backyard.
regards
John R
Hopefully the unions and the party left will really turn the screws on the New "Labour" wing of the party, it is clear that New "Labour" has failed on almost every level in government, and is still managing to use the fear of the Tories getting back in as a tool to try and control the oppisition within the Labour Party to it.
I agree that the minimum wage is far too low and I'm not bothered if raising it destroys a few crap jobs. But it's Labour (new and old) that established the principle.
And I agree that it's disgraceful that this government fails to support rights for agency workers and fails to extends union rights for fear of a Daily Mail headline.
Sadly, Labour has not been bold enough to follow through. But it will only develop that boldness if people stand up and support it.
I don't agree that public services are best shielded from market forces by total state ownership.
What matters is that health and education, for example, are free at the point of use, of the best quality and conveniently available.
Post a Comment