Tuesday, 25 August 2009

CAMPAIGNING FOR LABOUR 'S SOCIALIST MPs

Well, my summer inertia is wearing off so am busy organising an LRC meeting in Hebden Bridge - September 24 - just before Labour Party Conference.

Guest speakers will include Alice Mahon and I'm hoping to line up one or two others but the aim really is for all of us to discuss General Election strategy and how we campaign to help Labour MPs who need extra support in endangered constituencies in West Yorkshire. Venue is the Hole In The Wall pub ( near the packhorse bridge) at 7.30pm. More details anon......Alice has made it clear she will be voting Labour at the GE. Even if she has, sadly, left the Labour Party. Along with many other excellent comrades of my acquaintance. It's our job, IMHO, to keep the fight going for socialist values and give them all cause to re-join us.So, thanks Alice, for the support.

9 comments:

Merseymike said...

I just don't want to vote labour next time. The Tories are going to walk it in any case and I feel I can vote against Labour without it making any difference.

Then perhaps we can see, in opposition, whether there is any mileage in getting Labour back to some sort of reasonable position. That would be , for me, not as far left as for you, but still recognisably social democratic. Meaning sceptical about free markets. Without that essential critical stance, what you end up with is a right of centre party

Tom said...

Alice Mahon has divorced herself from the only viable working class party.

This is no path to socialism.

susan press said...

Tom, don't be so pompous.
1. Alice has not "divorced herself" from the only viable working-class Party.
She decided to resign becuase she regarded New Labour's policies as neither viable nor on the side of the working-class. Quite frankly if all in the Party who felt that way did so, there would be very few left.
Despite that, and despite being flooded with invites to go elsewhere, she's not hitched her star to SP, SPEW, RESPECT or any other non-viable electoral alliances.
She spoke at a No2RU meeting in Halifax on the Lisbon Treaty but made it clear she would be voting Labour.
2. It is no "path to socialism" to discard comrades like Alice who've devoted decade after decade to the Labour Party. Who have always regarded the Party as "family". And, in many respects, still do.Because we are.
3. Since when did Compass not have discussion and debate with non-LP members. Was not Caroline Lucas one of the Great and Good at your recent conference? And she WILL be giving Labour a run for it at the GE
4.Many people in my constituency have now left the Labour Party. The LRC is a way for them to stay involved and campaign for Labour as and where they feel they can.That very much includes people like Alice. To suggest otherwise is deeply insulting.Both to her and to all of us who feel simlarly "divorced" from the non-democratic structures, the Parliamentary stitch-ups, the policies like the Welfare Reform Bill which PUNISH the working-class. And, with 99.9 per cent of PPCs either career politicians or favoured sons and daughters of New labour, let's not pretend the new PLP will be "working-class" in any shape or form .
Until it is, until the Party in Government reverts to Labour values, instead of neo-liberal nonsense, then we'll continue to lose people we respect.Like Alice.
Which is why, at the GE, it is absolutely vital we retain the handful of socialist Mps we are likely to have left.

Tom said...

1)

"Quite frankly if all in the Party who felt that way did so, there would be very few left."

This is my point.

2)

The family requires a membership card and a bit of solidarity with those of us who have to soak up New Labour every morning.

3)

I'm not advocating not talking to her. I'm simply stating that I happen to disapprove. I would say the same thing about John Harris were he to have done what he considered in his book.

4)

To have an LRC with political tolerance of people leaving the Labour party created by the original LRC does our founders a great historical disservice, especially those unions whose Party Alice Mahon has now given up on rescuing.

If we were all like Alice Mahon, how on earth do you imagine that the party would 'revert to Labour values'?

The place for serious democratic socialists, without illusions, I should add, is in the party of the organised working class, and of the democratic socialist international organisations; that is the Labour Party.

Dave said...

Hi Susan,

isn't one of the differences between Carolyn Lucas and the Greens compared to the Groupuscles you list that the Greens are a credible political force. Whereas SPEW (what an appropriate abbreviation) and Respects 1,2 and 3 are a joke. Also there is a world of difference between Compass debating with the Greens and you setting up the Convention of the Left. A permanent organisation linking the LRC with a series of hermetically sealed groupiscles who despise the Labour Party.

Also Miller 2.0 is simply expressing an opinion in a straightforward fashion. The opposite of pompous.

Dave Draycott

PS I know, I know I am not a nice person.

susan press said...

In answer to both:

The LRC has always aimed to do its utmost to encourage people to stay in the Party and be active within it.Not everyone can.
You do not have to be an LP member to be active in the LRC. Th I believe the same is true of Compass, which has recently been reaching out to non-Labour organisations too as presumably people like Neal Lawson recognise that is a necessary strategy in the current climate
Trade unions like the RMT were ( wrongly) expelled but remain affiliated to the LRC -likewise FBU. Do you suggest, Tom, we only deal with the affiliated unions and the ever dwindling band of Party members? It is surely better to remain comited to working as a political bridge whereby activists in and outside Labour can work together. And that does NOT BTW include members of SP, SWP, RESPECT or any other Party standing candidates against Labour.
Alice stayed in the Labour Party more than 50 years. I hope, Tom, you display similar resilience in the years to come.
As ever, dave, you get it wrong.
I did NOT set up the Convention Of The Left.The Convention was planned long before I was asked to join its steering committee. It is NOT a "permanent organisation" but an extremely loose collection of people who meet to debate and try and find ways of working together on issues they share common ground on. Caroline Lucas , Tony Benn, John McDonnell and Jeremy Corbyn will all be speaking at a one-day conference in September in Brighton. So? I thought Compass agreed with such pluralist approaches to discussing progressive politics
I'm sure not everyone will agree.They don't have to.
One thing COL emphatically is notis an alternative electoral strategy nor a "front" for anything other than people coming together in a comradely way. Last year such "far lefts" as Austin Mitchell and Kelvin Hopkins contributed and I hope they do so again.
You may nt agree with groups like the SP nor the rather unfortunately titled SPEW. As it happens, neither do I.
That does not mean I can't have a conversation - and state the case for staying with Labour.

Tom said...

What do any of the points I made have to do with the LRC? I am talking about Alice Mahon, not the LRC.

But since you insist on bringing factions into it...

"You do not have to be an LP member to be active in the LRC. Th I believe the same is true of Compass, which has recently been reaching out to non-Labour organisations too as presumably people like Neal Lawson recognise that is a necessary strategy in the current climate"

Quite, but I'm a supporter of the Labour Party before a supporter of Compass. More to the point, Compass's coalition is about the fact that other parties want to enact at least some policies that are based on what Compass regards as social-democratic values.

Do you plan to enact a single one of the policies of the Maoist New Communist Party? I thought not.

I happen to think that the convention of the left is the only decent thing the hard left have done since the SWP pulled the Socialist Alliance to bits. Suffice it to say that I disagree with the politics of most who attended, but I appreciate their value in terms of pulling the centre of debate leftwards, and I wish they were more effective at it (less sectarian between themselves and less sectarian towards even left supporters of their natural second choice, the Labour Party).

I am not trying to claim that the LRC should not have dialogue with these groups. I expect that. In certain circumstances, such as the conflict against fascism, and in the anti-war movement, on Iran, and a a whole bunch of other stuff I still happen to believe, Bevan style, that working with the far left is essential, as much as I might disagree with them.

If new Labourite Peter Hain can feel comfortable saying that then so can I.

But I was actually talking about Alice Mahon, and about her behaviour as an individual, which I believe is an act of extreme disregard to those of us who want a Labour Party left of one nation conservatism.

Dave said...

Hi Susan,

I think Spew couldn't be more apposite.

Makes you think that the poor little darlings have no sense of humor.

Dave Draycott

Anonymous said...

Susan, please forgive me for experimenting on you but I am suffering with an irritation from Typepad which keeps interrupting my commenting on some sites including yours - you might think that a Good Thing! They needed an example and I am citing yours because you moniter comments before publishing so I can leave this and you can delete it later.