Monday, 28 January 2008

AND NOW THE UNEMPLOYED ARE PRIVATISED

A new buzz word was coined today by the Prime Minister. "Incentivise." What does it mean? I believe a Plain English translation would be "punish and privatise."

Lost amid the media ballyhoo over Ronald McDonald degrees was the news ( long predicted by the left) that Brown is now to hand over back-to-work schemes to the private sector. No doubt the companies who take them over will be "incentivised" too. By the truckloads of money they will make out of schemes designed to force people back into work -who will basically risk losing their benefits if they do not comply.
This is being touted by the Govt as a "carrot and stick" approach to tackling unemployment. In fact it's just a stick. Another one to beat the low-paid and unemployed with. And one which in times past we would have expected from a Tory, not a Labour Government.
Instead of shelling out cash to private companies, why not extend and renew public sector schemes to give people a bit of hope and a new start? There are many many models of social enterprise which could be worked on, too. Those really DO provide incentives for the people who work toigether collectively.
Still, looks like arch-Blairite James Purnell is going to have a fine time down at the DWP. Coming up next, closing down the Remploy factories. Anyone out there still think Brown is an improvement on Blair??

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

You're largely right, sadly, but it's not quite true it's only a stick - there are to be more apprenticeships for both young people and adults, and more training opps - that's obviously a good thing, but you wonder why it has to be accompanied by persecution...

susan press said...

Point taken. But as you say we don't need the stick nor should we be admonishing it .That's the shameful bit.Along wiht the privatisation of what should be a public service

Anonymous said...

Tbh, it is surprising how little most people understand about benefits, welfare etc, it is no soft touch, For example, it is already extremely difficult to claim benefits such as Incapacity benefit: (IB) the process involving stringent eligibility criteria, regular interviews and 'tough' and invasive medical tests, amongst the most stringent in Europe. Yet, with these nasty neo liberal ‘reforms ‘ it is going to get harder still, talk about blaming the victim!

The speed of these all these changes have been breath taking and one can argue this is ultimately about the end of a rights based welfare system in the UK and a move to privatised and minimal U.S model with big private training companies benefiting. The legislation on which much of this policy is based (see above), has also been criticized as ‘rushed, prejudiced and ‘short on detail’, (the Freud review took all of 13 weeks, so much for evidence based policy making)with the government also ignoring the many submissions to its consultation’s which were critical of the reforms

What is also staggering is the silence (with a few exceptions) of the left, the PLP, charities, etc to this turbo dismantling of the welfare state, Britain is about to become a much harsher place, shame on new labour…

Merseymike said...

Its not only the fact that it is moving down the private company route - its the nature of the companies concerned and their ideological assumptions. Having said that, they may have some good ideas. But their success in the US has been against a backdrop of the temporary nature of US benefits and the 'stick' of food stamps

Will that be next?

Anonymous said...

Well, he's not started any wars yet but give him time...

Anonymous said...

I find this approach to unemployment utterly frustrating. There are occasions when it is necessary to persuade someone to act in their own interests: having taught adult literacy to long term benefits claimants this is something I am very aware of. But it should be done with great care and shouldn't be done with the threat of a loss of dignity. Forcing people into apprenticeships and training posts is not the answer: offering bonuses for attendance is a much better method imo.

One of the unfortunate side effects of enforced retraining is that the attitude of some of the training staff towards their clients becomes unpleasant (again in my opinion). Whilst many people work in that field with the best of intentions, there are those who operate from a 'deserving and undeserving poor' standpoint. This is exacerbated when their clients are their through compulsion. The tension that exists in that situation between client and trainer can be very damaging to the success of the training.