Sunday, 18 May 2008

FOUR DAYS FROM BY-ELECTION DISASTER?

On Thursday night I expect I will stay up to wait for the result from Crewe and Nantwich. And something tells me that Labour will lose. Maybe it's the fact that their exceptionally stupid "toff" campaign has backfired. Indeed one of the Labour Party lads dressed up in top hat and tails is apparently a former pupil of MGS - Manchester Grammar School - one of the top independent schools in the country. What a crass message to the electorate.
Frank Dobson, not the most subtle of campaigners, was apparently on Newsnight the other night slamming the Tory candidate for being an Etonian (actually he isn't) . How pathrtic is this line of attack ?
As Dobbo well knows ( or maybe he doesn't) even left icons like Tony Benn went to public school (Westminster). So did, for God's sake, the late Paul Foot of the SWP (Shrewsbury). Frankly, I couldn't care less where someone went to school , because in the end it is their values and the way they live their lives which matter.
I'm a council house kid who went to Cambridge. I mixed with plenty of "toffs" And many of them were socialists. Many, yes, were Tories. But a working-class background is not necessarily an indicator of great socialist credentials.
What's left over at the Crewe campaign? Oh, yes, Xenophobic leaflets criticising Edward Timpson for being against ID cards. Well, that's really clever - and very likely to annoy the core Labour voters who also oppose them. So.
Yet again, New Labour has gone for cheap stunts, right-wing rhetoric and what amounts to a complete failure to understand the gravity of the situation we face. Tamsin Dunwoody deserved better than this farrago.As Dick Gaughan famously sang, "It isn't what you're born with, it's what you do with what you've got."

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

//On Thursday night I expect I will stay up to wait for the result from Crewe and Nantwich. And something tells me that Labour will lose.//

Gee, could the mass of daily newspaper stories which from the start pushed the notion that Crewe would be a Conservative win have anything to do with it?

No, apparently Labour blew it with a bad campaign. Balderdash!

Does it matter what school you go to? Not really. Does it matter that you've never, for instance, known what it's like to worry about financing your own debt, or finding enough cash for the kids' dinner? You bet it does.

Still, if Labour lose Crewe you'll all have another reason to blame it all on Brown and assist in the ushering of a reactionary class-ridden Conservative Government. Let's see how happy that makes you.

David Floyd said...

I agree that particular life experiences can help make people better politicians.

But I think saying stuff like:
"Does it matter that you've never, for instance, known what it's like to worry about financing your own debt, or finding enough cash for the kids' dinner? You bet it does."
would be a strange tactic for Labour on the campaign trail in Crewe given the government's recent failure to understand the impact of their taxation policy on people in those situations.

Anonymous said...

crew is far to close
to write off yet
I see Tory Ian Dale isnt calling it yet ???
so why are you

I remember a certain Bermondsey election...and a Liberal disgraceful campaign...yet who is the MP today

In an ideal world it would be down to ploicies

remember the wilderness years of the 80's we were very clean fighters in election only problem was we had the whole media against us

Chris Gale said...

Dear 'anonymous'

Clement Atlee went to private school but he became one of the great social reformers of our age.

David Miliband comes from a very wealthy family as do many others in Labour so its hardly clever politics to go in for this 'toff' nonsense.

It is playground politics run by politics students.

It is not Susan on this site or anyone else who are causing the disasters or 'ushering in a Conservative government' its no nothing apparatchiks who think they are being clever but are anything but.

susan said...

Thanks to supporters of proper Labour politics. My point was/ist hat these highly overpaid PR consultants are possibly/probably helping the Tory cause. Why not listen to the grassrooots for a change??Chance would be a fine thing.........