Shiraz Socialist questions the wisdom of this Saturday's Beyond The Market Economy conference in London. On the basis, and forgive the over-simplification, that no matter how good Labour Left policies may be, we have no chance of implementing them. I must confess this is an argument which I find exceptionally tiresome.
Last Saturday, I did what I swore I would never do again, and got into a huge row with an ex Labour Party member who I have to hand it to because he left in 1987. His line was "how can you support war criminals" to which of course, one says, I don't. I support the 140 MPs who voted agaunst war in Iraq, Blah, blah.We've all had those arguments in the pub on a Saturday night.This weekend's event, to which I will be going, will have a rather higher level of debate.
It is a serious attempt to bring people on the Left together, discuss capitalism and how it's failed us and advance progressive, socialist solutions to the problems which we face.
I will be there just to shut up and listen because , whatever other strengths I may have, I stake no claim to being an economist and I also admit a lot of my politics is tribal. But this is not, as comrade Shiraz suggests, just another talking shop.
Along with the experts from LEAP - the Left Economics Advisory Panel - there will hopefully be trade unionists, students and grassrots campaigners of all ages . Have we given up on the Labour Party? No. Are we working also with those outside it? Yes. We are also getting out there and campaigning. What we are not doing is sitting at home moaning and not doing anything so I urge as many who can get there as possible to do so. And I'm sorry, Ron, for shouting at you.But please don't write us all off yet.....

9 comments:
"Beyound the market economy" ... and back to the laager.
Didn't 18 wasted years teach you anything?
That stuff will never be sold to anybody outside of your lot. You need another lot in the middle to do anything. Another lot is never going to have anything to do with the Left Economics Advisory Panel.
Tax it, spend it, fuck you and fuck off is no way to treat an electorate.
And using foul language is no way to treat another human being, anonymous.
I think anonymous's contribution speaks for itself. Its eloquence is stunning.
Whilst I might not agree with the manner the anonymous contributor made their point I do agree with their sentiments.
I agree with much in the LRC platform and I'd love to seem them put into place. But I honestly don't believe we have enough support to get re-elected on such a platform. So, as a realist I can see we need to be careful and ensure we have policies that appeal to a wide range of people.
Having belief and principles and wishing them to happen isn't enough. Pragmatism is required too.
Do you honestly believe the Labour Party will be re-elected on a LRC type agenda? Or are you just wishing it to happen?
I think it has a much better chance of that happening than being relected on a New Labour agenda again.
The 'third way' is a busted flush. Failed. Over.
Much of the "LRC type" agenda is also backed by COMPASS. Yes, we could get elected on it. Will we get the chance? That's another issue......one thing is clear. The new labour agenda is finished, over. Dead
I suggest you carefully read the debates in the Labour Party that took place for the whole of the 1980s.
Fundamentalism might give you a warm messianic glow. But it will not give you the opportunity to do anything. I thought the Labour Party learnt that lesson the hard way.
Still, your purity will remain unsullied. Professional tiddlywinks might be a more meaningful vehicle for your energies.
But surely there is a way between the LRC and the current government - I would have said sensible, mainstream, Labour ideas.
Look at the issues people are angry over - it certainly isn't because the Government are too left wing!
Susan,
Whether it pisses you off or not, my essential point is true, and you haven't answered it. My argument manifestly is not the same as some old geezer saying the LP are war criminals. My stance is this - that you have no means, mechanism or agency to make any policy changes within the Labour Party at all. The annual conference is toothless post-Bournemouth, and you know as well as I that there is no other means, whatsoever, via which the membership can push its will on to a leadership that is hardly going to voluntarily follow your lead.
So rather than going "it pisses me off", why not try answering the question. If so, you'll be the first person to successfully do so.
Post a Comment