More unbelievable guff from P Toynbee in today's Guardian.If I appear to have a minor fixation with the female columnists who act as propaganda machines for Gordon Brown/New Labour then it's largely because I am also a journalist and find it utterly baffling they get paid so much money for writing such garbage. Polly, for example, simply cannot believe that it's possible Russia has better literacy levels than this country. In fact, she says the Russians are way above us because they , er, fiddle the statistics. Really.
When I visited the Soviet Union ( as it then was) in 1989 people were desperate for books - Penguin novels were prized items and other languages were taught as a matter of course in schools. Even the youngest of children could speak some English and/or German.
How can reading skills improve when no-one picks up a book? In very recent conversations with older students, and I'm talking university level, I'm amazed at the fact the vast majority simply do not read. Nor see the need to. But were I 30 years younger with hundreds of satellite channels, ready access to computer games, and junk magazines with no words but plenty of pics of "celebrities" , maybe I would be the same. My generation got one hour of children's TV , precious little spending money and public libraries offered us escapism now found 24/7 elsewhere. In Russia, I suspect, things are as they were here 40 years ago. As for the rest of Polly's article well it's the same line trotted out by Jackie Ashley the other day. And, talking of Russia, I have no doubt they would both have been gainfully employed on Pravda. Because their blind loyalty to this Government is similarly unacceptable.
Friday, 30 November 2007
LET'S BLAME THE RUSSIANS,,,,,,,
Posted by
susan press
at
10:51
Labels: Guardian columnists, guff
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

1 comment:
It was always "Isvestiya for the Truth and Pravda for the news". But these columns are published in a completely different milieu with acres of critical copy and the likes of CIF as a counterbalance and opportunity for discourse. This makes the columns acceptable to my eyes. They are one view of many. They are not a "line" as exhibited in other media and other groupings.
Post a Comment