Sunday, 18 November 2007

LRC CONFERENCE

Actually I am too tired to write much in the way of detailed political analysis . It can be found elsewhere but just to note the following. Yesterday was a good turn-out with around 250 people attending . The mood decidedly more upbeat than the debacle of Labour Party Conference. Possibly because people were actually allowed to speak. Good speeches as ever from John McDonnell and Jeremy Corbyn, Tony Benn. Good to see Jane Davison AM on board too ( though she should have been given a time-limit) and conference offered solidarity to victimised UNISON activist Karen Reissman who got a standing ovation. Michael Gavan , another UNISON mmeber threatened with the sack, got a rousing reception too.
LRC is growing steadily following the John4Leader campaign, despite the disappointments of this year. ASLEF are the latest union to affiliate.
Compass's Jon Trickett MP had lots of lefty rhetoric in his rather rambling speech about New Labour and why the Government were way off course,.All very well banging on now about re-claiming the Party but he , er, did have a chance to change the agenda and NOT give Brown an easy ride. Anyway, the audience was largely polite and bridges have to be built I suppose . But I wonder what Neal Lawson would have made of his speech....
West Yorkshire LRC resolution in support of lowering leadership threshold passed unanimously and only real dissent was over an ambiguous motion from the AWL which suggested LRC might support non-Labour candidates. It was, quite rightly, thrown out.
No we can't - as if we did we would get thrown out of the Party. It's a no-brainer. As Owen Jones and many others said, the road to oblivion. Remember Lesley Mahmoud.....
Thanks to fellow bloggers Stroppy Bird, Jon Rogers, Tami and Marsha Jane for their excellent company after the conference ( can we have an organised social event next year as an added incentive for those who travel hundreds of miles....) . And a special thanks to Linda Riordan MP for giving me somewhere to sleep! Just as well the other residents who got there at same time could sort out my ineptitude with the fob and keys. Now have to work out how to fill two hours' teaching tomorrow. May do more considered piece tomorrow .Forgot to say got voted on to National Committee - so back in London soon.

46 comments:

ian said...

I look forward to the report.
I hear the NUM have affiliated as well.

susan press said...

Yes, they have . Bit knackered so forgot to include that. Apologies.

Duncan Hall said...

Sounds like a good do. I was unable to get down in the end, because of work. Sounds pretty encouraging.

Fr Simon said...

Trickett just confused me. The logic of his position was that he shouldn't have nominated Brown for the leadership. As you say, though, we need to build bridges.

It was nice to meet you by the way, albeit in passing!

E10 Rifle said...

Did people get a chance to grill Trickett on the leadership issue? What did he say?

Shame I missed it (work and, er, football-watching commitments prevented my attendance), but look forward to getting involved in LRC stuff in London.

Some good people seem to have been elected onto the National Committee too. And well done yerself, grim.

susan press said...

Trickett's position was utterly illogical. One person ( from West Yorkshire LRC, ahem, but not me) did challenge him from the floor but I suppose most of us gritted our teeth in the knowledge that he had not been invited to be heckled and it would just be counter-productive as far as building alliances goes.Good job Cruddas didn't turn up, though!

E10 Rifle said...

Yeah, fair point that you wouldn't want to give too hard a time to someone invited to speak, especially as how we relate to the 'soft left', so to speak, is a key issue for the LRC. But that bridge-building is a two-way process, which is why it might have been good to coax out an explanation.

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

I was there in the room at Conway Hall too, as was the elephant..namely, was the PLP responsible for John(4leader) McDonnell not getting on the Leadership ballot paper, or was it John McDonnell himself?

Judging by the clapping, cheering and self-congratulation it was all the PLP's fault.

As you know, Susan, from our work in Save the Labour Party if John had been bridge-building in the PLP as long as we have in the Party, the whole story may have been very different..but he wasn't bridge-building five years ago. I welcome suggestions that he wants to start now. But if he seeks credibility in that regard, it would be better if he owned up now to having been his own worst enemy by failing to build support in the PLP. And to do so very publicly.

Without wanting to rub salt in, I would go one step further and say it might have been helpful if he had had solid support from the Campaign Group of Socialist MPs in the first place.

Anonymous said...

The fact John did not have enough support in the PLP is not a reflection on the candidate. I know you would not argue with me Peter that John worked exceptionally hard and gained credibility over the months ( confounding I seem to recall your expectations) with the grassrots and trade unions. That was always the focus of the campaign and rightly so. Courting MPs and doing the tea-rooms, as Meacher did, was hardly a winner. The fact the PLP chose to ignore the wishes of so many Party members for a contest (my MP included) refelcts their spineless lack of principle. I'm sure many (probably Trickett) regret that now. My view is he SHOULD have said something about that on Saturday. I think it is a marker of John's magnanimity that he was invited in the first place. As for the Campaign Group, the vast majority nominated John. For all your "bridge-building" the STLP is a vastly smaller body than the LRC and frankly Gordon brown listens no more to you or COMPASS than he does to the left . Which is why from now on I will be focussing on the LRC And hopefully, yes, building stronger links

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

Thanks for responding. No amount of self-congratulation will obscure the facts.

When did the Campaign Group (majority of) vote in favour of John4Leader?

Before or after he launched his campaign?

Duncan Hall said...

Peter - it was absolutely right NOT to have a vote in the Campaign Group about the leadership (I fear...) - I think it very likely that John would have received the backing (as, by that time, the alternatives were Meacher and Brown, both of whom would have received fewer Campaign Group supporters, though some - so it would have made no difference in that regard, but may have led to some (Brown supporters, rather than Meacher supporters I would guess) to leave the Campaign Group, just as the same issue did re: the Benn/Heffer campaign of 88. The whole point of the campaign was to strengthen the left, and if the net result of the first stage of the campaign had been to weaken it, then we really would have been our own worst enemies. Strategically that approach was right.
Strategically, focusing on the grass roots and the trade unions rather than the tea room trail was also right (in the end the strongest argument for nominating John - and one which convinced a number of MPs who would not have been natural supporters - was the strength of support outside parliament). In the end it wasn't enough: but it damn nearly was. Without 'toning down' the policies (and thereby rather undermining the whole point of a campaign) John was not going to get a large number of MPs suddenly converting to the LRC, etc. - what the PLP should have done was to ensure a contest and to allow members and affiliates a say. And no, nobody can be blamed for that but the PLP itself.

Anonymous said...

Dear Doctor Dunc

What this boils down to is that John knows what's best for the Left. Sorry, what's the difference between that standpoint and the ruinous one for the Labour Party adopted by Blair?

The anti tea-room schmoozing defence is really sad. What I am suggesting is that John could have targeted PLP members with left-leaning CLPs and started campaigning with their MP, the grassroots and TUs together - in partnership. Then if they had failed to back him there would have been something to complain about it. As it is, it was all too predictable.

Anonymous said...

Oh do desist, Peter. You're a tedious, pompous, politically isolated, irrelevant buffoon who manages to unite left, right and centre in shared contempt.

Stop your pathetic arrogant bleating and look at the reasons for your own irrelevance before you start slagging anyone else off.

Anonymous said...

I of course support the objectives of the LRC

But all to often the agenda LRC follows has already been spouted by a variety of Left groupings

the LRC would do well to model itself on the old Tribune

Broad based Left, looking to include rather than exclude, setting the agenda

Commenting on boring issues like accountability of Labour councillors, MPs'the best form of communication with the elcectorate, has knocking up had its day, is telephone canvassing really that great (I fear it is and I hate it)

How do we get our communities to sign up to a Left agenda and keep with it when times get hard

But again we could discuss Iraq or past internal LP election defeats for a few more hours

With regards to Respect members who slag of Labour MP's and the Party, demanding total support when they are victimised at work...what do they expect ? why should they care ?, lets get real

susan press said...

Peter, I find it very sad that after several years acknowledging our differences yet working together you should launch such a spiteful attack. I don't take it personally. You are just plain wrong.
CLPS with left-leaning MPs WERE targetted.My MP got the first invitation to the John4Leader meeting in her constituency yet refused to come and listen to the arguments. Unlike Ann Cryer, in the neighbouring CLP ( also targetted) who was won over by the support John had with her mmebers. As for the trade unions, the leaders of the Big 4 did all of us a huge disservice. People like Tony Woodley particularly.
It wasn't about "John knows best" and frankly to compare him with Blair is, well, risible.
What's the difference? Apart from John being a principled and committed socialist, he undertook the campaign not for self-aggrandisement but to inspire people and give them some hope that the Labour Party was worth saving. A view I thought you shared. Thousands of the grassroots wanted to see the end of New Labour. For those of us in the LRC, the fight goes on.

Anonymous said...

The campaign was not broad enough

by the campaign supporting candidates against the sitting Union General Secs in a number of unions, allowed John to be effectively cut off from his natural supporters - not a clever move

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

Let's try and keep things in perspective.

Why not answer the question about timing first?

John started his campaign before he had a viable support group inside the PLP. IMHO it was a mistake. There are too many people inside the Party who know or think they know the circumstances of his candidacy for him to be a viable leadership candidate in the foreseeable future.

You may not appreciate me writing this, but there are also too many people in and around LRC who would not be unhappy if Labour were to lose the next election and shift decisively and IMHO self-destructively to the left. Having worked with you, I know you don't want that. John and the newly elected LRC national committee have to decided whether they want to broaden their appeal organisationally or not.

It's your choice.

E10 Rifle said...

It strikes me that this is an argument over two issues that needn't be incompatible - the need to broaden the appeal of left politics more generally in the wider community (ie outside the party, even 'talking over the heads of the party' to steal an old Blairite maxim), while at the same time building bridges WITHIN it - primarily between the 'soft' and 'hard' left. But as I said earlier that would include, for example, Compassites doing a bit more walking the walk to add to their talk-talking. They've not done enough of the former so far.

This is why both the spinelessness of the soft left over the leadership campaign and some of the subsequent embittered sniping at Cruddas from the hard left during the deputy leadership campaign struck the wrong note.

But, Peter, surely you must agree that there's only so much banging a head against a brick wall about the internal tea-room machinations of the party one can do before going a bit mad. The LRC SHOULD reach out beyond all that, beyond the party (while at the same time trying to attract people to it), and remember that the biggest task ahead of us all is to engage people with coherent, progressive, democratic left politics generally - in a climate that is tricky to say the least. (There's some decent points on this in an article by Andrew Fisher in the latest Briefing, BTW). Idealistic people aren't going to join the Labour party to cut deals in the tea room.

Similarly - and apologies if I'm misquoting - I was at a CLPD meeting at the TUC at which you said something along the lines of how it was important that people should not get sidetracked by the various parliamentary selection campaigns going on in their CLPs from the important task of opposing Brown's conference reforms. While I agreed totally with your opposition to Brown's changes, it seemed a bit wrong-headed to imply that this was more important than, say, trying to get actual, real-life progressive left candidates selected for winnable seats. To my mind, that's more important than conference motions that have been ignored for years anyway.

Fr Simon said...

Peter - can we perhaps all agree that, whatever the circumstances of John's failure to get on the ballot paper; (a.) that is in the past?, (b.) those of us who want to see the Labour Party change direction probably have better things to be doing than sniping at each other?

Anonymous said...

One of the anonymous commenters above takes a pop at Respect members who are in trouble at work and then ask for support from Labour politicians.
I assume this is a reference to Karen Reissmann who has been sacked from her job as a mental health nurse in Manchester for speaking to the media as a union rep.
Karen is in Respect but she has been paying the political levy for 25 years.
She is on the health executive of Unison - an affiliated union - and she is being supported by a 100 striking colleagues.
Many of whom live and have families in the marginal constituency of Manchester Withington.
Labour councillors have slagged off the strikrs.
Lib Dems and Greens have backed the dispute.
If Manchester Labour doesn't support Karen it will be a huge blow the the party.
For more info see http://www.myspace.com/reinstatekaren

susan press said...

Absolutely right, Miles. We need more labour councillors .. tohught of standing ??????

Anonymous said...

Yes McDonnell's candidacy is in the past, but we should be able to learn lessons. Otherwise we just keep repeating past mistakes.

In my view McDonnell's campaign failed to recognise the shift there had been in the party since the 1981 Benn campaign he modelled himself. Benn was within a whisker of winning, McDonnell didn't even reach the ballot paper.

Cruddas, meanwhile, topped the poll of first preferences, and pushed housing up the agenda. The deputy result was good for the left. The leadership election was a disaster.

Anonymous said...

Yes McDonnell's candidacy is in the past, but we should be able to learn lessons. Otherwise we just keep repeating past mistakes.

In my view McDonnell's campaign failed to recognise the shift there had been in the party since the 1981 Benn campaign he modelled himself. Benn was within a whisker of winning, McDonnell didn't even reach the ballot paper.

Cruddas, meanwhile, topped the poll of first preferences, and pushed housing up the agenda. The deputy result was good for the left. The leadership election was a disaster.

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

Thanks for providing the peg around which some plainer talking has been possible.

If the LRC wants to broaden its appeal, then you really have to change your script re Jon Cruddas.

The least I would expect is that you withdraw your earlier comment:

"Good job Cruddas didn't turn up, though!"

Deriding the PLP, applauding Bob Wareing and brandishing menances against the left candidate in the Deputy Leadership contest will be the LRC's downfall.

Pity, LRC has done some good work. Peddling delusions is not going to give it a future.

A reapproachment with Jon ought to be a near - term LRC goal.

susan press said...

I think Jon Cruddas should change HIS script. My comment re him turning up was a throwaway one ( not everything I write is a careful PR job) but you would hardly expect garlands of flowers and thankyou notes, would you Peter? .
I hope Jon Trickett's appearance at the LRC was a sign of a rapprochement ( and if you knew a bit more about the history then maybe you would realise JUST how magnanimous that was) and that COMPASS will stop pretending Brown is the answer and start asking some serious questions
. Bob Wareing was in the room and has devoted his life to the labour movement. Why wouldn't he be applauded. I think his replacement by twigg was precisely the kind of cynical manoevring which leads to the PLP being criticised harshly. Watched many of them laughing like drains last night over Darling's speech on not nationalising Northern Rock. Frankly, I think some of these MPs are nauseating in their sycophancy and I will say so. This blog is a personal one. MPs are not sacred cows. We should be looking to find better candidates - not just accepting the current bunch as the status quo. Oh, as for cruddas being the "left" candidate I'm not even going there. It's all been said. Where are those policies now ?? Certainly not ( apart from a nod to social housing) on Brown's agenda.

Anonymous said...

who said Cruddas was the left candidate?

Anonymous said...

In moving on Jon and John and Michael need to kiss and make-up, well, at least, shakehands.

Just as you and I do, Susan.

Time to draft the statement for the Centre-Left Grassroots Alliance candidates for the Labour Party NEC elections next year.

Anonymous said...

Saturday was a maze for lefties trying to find their way around the miriad of conferences.
Who spoke where?
I've compiled a dossier at http://action-without-theory.blogspot.com/2007/11/three-out-of-five-aint-bad.html

Anonymous said...

For a considered account of the LRC Conference, go to:

http://martinwicks.wordpress.com/2007/11/21/labour-representation-committee-conference/

Where does the LRC stand over support for candidates standing against official Labour Party candidates either in principle or practice?

Owen said...

Peter,

I'm not sure if you were paying attention, but you may have noticed that the motion proposed by the AWL was overwhelmingly rejected by the Conference precisely because it could have opened the door to LRC groups supporting candidates standing against official Labour Party candidates.

I'm not entirely sure why you're going around the blogosphere at the moment trying to antagonise the Labour left - but given your own near total political marginalisation, perhaps this isn't actually the most tactically astute move on your part?

Anonymous said...

Dear Owen

Yes, I was there when Resolution 2 was defeated. I was also there when the PLP was deplored, Bob Wareing was applauded and Mark Serwotka announced he'd be backing Bob.

Whether I am 'near total political marginalisation' or not does not detract from the question I raised on this issue.

Your National Committee has certainly been empowered to take a position on this issue as a result of Resolution 2 being defeated.

The question is whether it has got the political courage to take a tough stand and put the RMT and FBU, and individual members on notice that they face expulsion from LRC if they support opposition to official Labour Party candidates for public office.

Owen said...

Peter,

I fail to see exactly what your point is or what your current motivations are. You posed a rather bizarre question about the LRC's view on supporting non-Labour candidates which I answered. As you know, a resolution was overwhelmingly defeated on the sole basis that it could be used to advance such a position. Indeed, the resolution didn't even call for such a policy - but just the perception that it hinted in that direction was enough to get it smashed.

Yes, the PLP was deplored. Shock horror. Perhaps you expected a group of Labour party socialists to congratulate MPs who had voted through privatisations, attacks on civil liberties, or the war against Iraq or who denied party members and trade unionists a democratic contest. I think that it's inevitable MPs are going to come under fire - and I think that, if the Labour party is to be a democratic party (!), this is perfectly healthy. Call me old-fashioned, but surely we have a right to keep our elected representatives to account?

As for applauding Bob - well, this is a man who has been a dedicated member of the Labour party for decades. He has just been deselected in favour of a middle-class Blairite clone carpetbagger from London who is supposed to represent the interests of working-class voters in Liverpool West Derby. I wouldn't expect people there to be giving Twigg a standing ovation and am unsurprised that they clapped a progressive Labour MP who has dedicated his whole life to the party.

Given you were present at the Conference, you know what the answer to your question is. As far as I'm concerned, this was an attempt to throw mud at the LRC that doesn't even have any foundation.

And afraid your political marginalisation has everything to do with this issue. You are not trusted (by people who know you are) on the right. Therefore I don't think it's sensible on your part to alienate those on the left of the party who (unlike the right) would actually support your proposals to democratise the party. I think, if I were you, I wouldn't go out of my way to burn potential bridges. Perhaps the fact you are currently going round the blogosphere attacking both the LRC and John McDonnell is an attempt to ingratiate yourself with the right: I'm afraid I'm not convinced that will actually work.

I don't have a problem with criticisms of the left or the LRC. I do have a problem with dishonest criticisms from people who are fully aware of the truth.

Anonymous said...

Dear Owen

Carry on smearing...politically marginalised...distrusted...and dishonest.

I think members of the Labour Party will see through that sort of behaviour.

None of it detracts from the questions I and others have posed to LRC.

My problem is with the organisation of Labour Party, its leadership and policy making procedures.

Owen said...

As I've said, you are patently being dishonest because you already know the answer to the "question" you have been posing.

The fact you are distrusted by the right is not an insult - it is simply an observation that those who are deemed in any way critical of the Labour party leadership are distrusted by the right. Accordingly, you will never be able to form an alliance with them.

And yes, given you are distrusted by the right and are going out of your way to alienate the left, you are indeed politically marginalised.

I'm not sure what's behind your current attacks on the left - but all I would say is that it's hardly going to do you any favours.

Anonymous said...

Dear Owen

This is getting very tedious.

Calling people 'dishonest' for asking questions you presume they know the answer to doesn't square to my mind with winning many hearts and minds.

So I will repeat the question set out above:

"The question is whether it (LRC)has got the political courage to take a tough stand and put the RMT and FBU, and individual members on notice that they face expulsion from LRC if they support opposition to official Labour Party candidates for public office."

You would be correct in assuming that I believe your national committee will have to address it, if the LRC wants to broaden its support inside the Labour Party significantly.

E10 Rifle said...

Well Peter, let it address the issue WHEN it arises. It would seem a bit sour for the LRC, at this early stage, to start already throwing around warning notices and hypothetical expulsion threats before anything's happened. Not really a way to create an atmosphere of togetherness and co-operation.

As I said earlier, soft-left/hard-left dialogue and fraternity is essential, which is why I'm a bit puzzled and saddened at all this frostiness. Especially as both soft and hard left are being shafted by the leadership.

Anonymous said...

Dear e10 rifle

You are right we are all being shafted by the leadership. That's why I though it was sad that Susan was so uncharitable towards Jon Cruddas.

My observations and those of others at Conway Hall on Saturday are offered for what they are..observations.

I first met John McDonnell and Simeon Andrews in 2004 before the LRC was formed when Save the Labour Party put together the Grassroots Umbrella project in an attempt to unify efforts to rebuild the Labour Party.

They went off and formed ..the LRC.

In short, our analyses of how the Labour Party power structures are going to be changed are fundamentally different.

The results of STLP's work to date are set out in the LabOUR Commission interim report. The next challenge is the role of the NEC.

Anonymous said...

Peter, this is getting seriously unhelpful. You know and I know that the LRC is much much more successful than the Grassroots Umbrella Network, or STLP.I'm at a loss to understabd why you are launching these attacks.You are just not helping anyone.

E10 Rifle said...

They have different roles too, surely, which aren't incompatible. To get all huffy about the LRC allegedly 'treading on the toes' of CLGA is a bit, well, borderline-sectarian frankly. I'd hope the next Grassroots Alliance slate is a decent mix of hard and soft lefties, just as others have been.

Anonymous said...

Dear e10 rifle

You are right about different roles. I have not spoken out before about LRC. Personally I was sad about the way LRC was set up when others expressed a willingness to work together.

I don't know if you remember or not but a year earlier Neal Lawson has launched Compass. For better or worse, I had come to the view then that policy think-tanks and personal glee clubs were the last thing the Party needed.

Anyway we are where we are. Compass has attracted some 2,000 members some inside the Labour Party, some not, mainly from the centre/centre-left. LRC has recruited some 1,000 members mainly from the left again from inside and outside the party. StLP hasn't tried to recruit members like either Compass or LRC. But working with Michael Meacher and Mark Seddon we did manage to raise £25K to pay for the research that underpins the LabOUR Commission report and attracted not the usual suspects to form the Commission itself.

Most fairminded party members credit StLP with getting membership on to the national agenda and that is reflected in the new Leader's Party stance. We have a hell of a mountain to climb, but at least the new Leader is not trying to waste the membership.

The job of establishing a bridgehead on the Party's NEC is underway. The new CLGA slate is being put together, and a fresh statement drafted rooted in Labour values, but recognising today's real politik. Susan has a copy.

I'm surprised at all the broohaha on this blog in particular. The About this Blog includes that Nye Bevan quote: "This is my truth, now tell me yours."

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Susan does not have a copy.Perhaps you will get round to sending me one

Anonymous said...

Susan does not have a copy.Perhaps you will get round to sending me one

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

It was sent to you and all other attendees of the CLGA post NEC briefings at 2:31:23 yesterday, except Walter Wolfgang. His copy is in the post.

Anonymous said...

Oops, Wednesday.. not yesterday.

E10 Rifle said...

"I had come to the view then that policy think-tanks and personal glee clubs were the last thing the Party needed"

Well, we agree on that anyhow. Though I welcomed Compass's initial intellectual output anyhow - they've put out some thoughtful stuff, just haven't backed it up with any political bottle, or nous. If this year's proved anything, it's that the LRC and Compass are very different beasts, and that those who set up the LRC would have been wasting their time depending on Compass to DO anything, as opposed to saying it.

Though I personally, as an LRC-ite, was happy to support Cruddas in the deputy campaign, because of the issues he was prioritising.