Saturday, 10 November 2007

WEAR YOUR POPPY WITH PRIDE

Tomorrow will be joining other councillors for annual Remembrance Day procession to war memorial then civic service in local church. And, yes, I will be wearing a red poppy. There was a time when it was fashionable on the left to wear white poppies. They were sold by groups like the Quakers and CND. But, largely, that trend has died out. I know one or two people who still manufacture their own but, actually, had a bit of an altercation in the pub last night with someone planning to do exactly that.

I pointed out that the local members of the Royal British Legion would not a) applaud his peacenik tendencies but b) feel insulted. I also pointed out it was a pretty pointless gesture which would do nothing to stop war. And, most importantly, I added that attending services like tomorrow's is NOT to glorify war, but honour and respect those who have died.
My generation is, I hope, the last to have wholesale direct family experience of war. My father (87) was in the Army in the second World War and my grandfather fought in the First World War, coming through the Battle of the Somme. He was so grateful to be alive that afterwards he remembered a priest who had assured him he would survive. On that basis, he converted to Catholicism.
Many might laugh at such naivete (no doubt the clergy said that to everyone as a comfort) but the fact is I would not be sitting here had things gone very differently for the men in my family.
Many families tomorrow will remember their loved ones who have died much more recently in Iraq and Afghanistan. To pause for a minute or two and honour their memories is not to be a warmonger - it's common human decency.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

I applaud you wearing a poppy...maybe you can go one step further and start urging this Labour Government to start treating wounded servicemen properly. Maybe they can get enough helicopters moved to Afghanistan and start giving decent housing to servicmens families. 3 Paras amputees wounded in Afghanistan have been awarded just 60K for their horrific injuries.
Labour took us into these wars...maybe they can start to deal in a decent manner with the results.

Bob Piper said...

anonymous... You miss the point. Respecting the dead has nothing to do with approving or promoting the war.

susan press said...

Bob has already made this point.But just for the record.I think Tony Blair's decision to go to war in Iraq was despicable folly which has resulted in the loss of thousands of lives.The subsequent justification of his decision and cowardice of his Cabinet in not stopping him inexcusable. Gordon brown should bring the troops home now and they should be treated with honour. I marched with everyone else in February 2003 and on many more anti-war marches since.

Anonymous said...

As a hopeless, old re-actionar, as far removed from Susan's socialism as it is possible to get, nevertheless, I agree with her post. Remembrance Day is, or should be, one of those very rare civic occasions in which all politics are set aside.

Anonymous said...

I think the first comment was about Afghanistan not Iraq

Are we seriously saying that we should not have taken out the Taliban in Afghanistan (backed by the UN), who stopped women from attending school, who destroyed the Buddha statues at Bamiyan. Apart from supporting global terrorism (Not just military, or commuters but night clubs).

I don’t recall much support for the troops after the Falklands War, and they didn’t even have proper ships to get them there (A war you may recall Militant supported)well it did bring down a dictatorship.

I was always brought up wearing white poppies of the Peace Pledge Union, but older in life happy to also wear a red one, not however an Earl Haig one for some reason most socialist I know frowned upon

Fr Simon said...

I agree about white poppies. I'm not so sure that I agree about the whole red poppy/ Remembrance Sunday culture. I might post something about it myself later! I simply do not agree that most remembrance services 'do not glorify war'. But there we are...

Anonymous said...

Some church services do glorify war in my experience.
But the act of wearing a poppy doesn't mean that the individual does.
Every year I buy a poppy and lose it withing 30 seconds.
That means I give money to the welfare of ex-service people while staying cool to my peacenik mates.
Perfect.

Anonymous said...

Susan your focus on male British fighters (all due respect to your family members) demonstrates exactly why you are wrong.

The white poppy seeks to remember all casualties of war. The current red poppy culture completely focus remembrance of war to the satisfaction of the warmonger.

A poster who says he normally disagrees with you has said he agrees and that politics should be taken out of remembrance. Thats the point. You take the "politics" out of it and hand the focus to the establishment. That doesn't de-politicise it, just makes it a right wing focus on the British military.

All casualties of war should be remembered, civilian casualties, children and refugees, as should the horror of war. Not everyone who wears a red poppy disagrees with me (e.g. I guess, you) but the general culture does. Ask the average person in the street what it is about, and they say our soldiers innit. I won't be party to such a one-sided annual fest. Wearing a white poppy is not to insult anyone (I know one member of my local legion when I was at school who wore both red and white). It is making a statement that needs to be mind in a world dominated by war.

I am not going to be intimidated away from the practice of wearing a white poppy each autumn as I have done for about fifteen years, because I might upset someone people who have a set of politics that needs to be challenged.

Anonymous said...

Susan your focus on male British fighters (all due respect to your family members) demonstrates exactly why you are wrong.

The white poppy seeks to remember all casualties of war. The current red poppy culture completely focus remembrance of war to the satisfaction of the warmonger.

A poster who says he normally disagrees with you has said he agrees and that politics should be taken out of remembrance. Thats the point. You take the "politics" out of it and hand the focus to the establishment. That doesn't de-politicise it, just makes it a right wing focus on the British military.

All casualties of war should be remembered, civilian casualties, children and refugees, as should the horror of war. Not everyone who wears a red poppy disagrees with me (e.g. I guess, you) but the general culture does. Ask the average person in the street what it is about, and they say our soldiers innit. I won't be party to such a one-sided annual fest. Wearing a white poppy is not to insult anyone (I know one member of my local legion when I was at school who wore both red and white). It is making a statement that needs to be mind in a world dominated by war.

I am not going to be intimidated away from the practice of wearing a white poppy each autumn as I have done for about fifteen years, because I might upset someone people who have a set of politics that needs to be challenged.

Anonymous said...

Well I served in the forces and your good meaning comments are well intentioned I'm sure....however, I think the Labour Government have a responsibility, here and now, to provide these servicemen with some proper support. The financial provision for the forces in virtually all respects is inadequate.

John Gray said...

Susan

Never thought I would say this but Good post! - wear your red poppy with pride!

Anonymous said...

The white poppies usually come from the Peace Pledge Union but, as you note, are often sold by Quakers and CND. I have a white poppy which I wear most years. As the son of a former RAF man and grandson to two (now dead) men who fought one in WW1 and one in WW2 no insult is intended or, indeed, taken by most people I know. We should remember the words, 'never again.' That's why I go for a white poppy.

Jim Denham said...

I very much agree with you, Susan.