In life, I have always thought it better to provoke strong reactions in people. Mediocrity is not something I aspire to. Nevertheless, a few minutes ago I was surprised to note that an AMICUS poster on Labour Home had referred to me as the "most hated person in the Cruddas campaign."
Given my complete obscurity and lack of influence, I find that pretty risible. But not, necessarily, a negative. Likewise the fact that back in November it was a fellow member of the West Yorkshire LRC who personally challenged Jon Trickett as to why he had nominated Gordon Brown for leader. Good on him I say.......
Sometimes in politics you have to keep quiet. But there are times when you have to stick your head above the parapet. I have never had a problem doing that. And I don't suppose I ever will. Whatever the consequences.....
Thursday, 24 January 2008
NOT TOP OF THE POPS.....
Posted by
susan press
at
14:31
Labels: anti-christ, hate figures, Jon Cruddas
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

13 comments:
Do you regret voting for Peter Hain?
Just read your piece on Hain. Surely Cruddas was the Left Candidate? Even if Centre-Left?
If Cruddas was the "left" candidate then he should have supported John. End of story.....
Ho-hum. John Cruddas called for more employment rights for migrant workers, raised the issue of trade union rghts in the workplace and put housing on the agenda so that even cabinet ministers like Hain had to take notice and shuffle left. That made him the Left Candidate. And the fact is his performance rescued the reputation of the left: he beat 3 cabinet Ministers. That's why it's not the end of the 'story'. Left politics should not be reduced to the usual rather sad litany of betrayal. John 'McD' was a candidate not a saint.
I'd still like to know if you regret voting for Pete Hain. Wouldn't it have been better to bury the hostility for Cruddas and vote for the Left candidate.
If Jon Cruddas and his supporters had really wanted to set a left agenda then obviously they should have supported a contest for the leadership. The policies which Cruddas espoused had all been raised by John McDonnell and the only realistic chance of a serious debate was if John was on the ballot paper. A Brown v McDonnell debate would have seriously boosted the left's faith in Labour as a viable platform.Now many are disillusioned, Cruddas has contributed to that,
You've said on another post that you do not regret voting for Hain but no explanation of 'Je ne regret rien'?
Dave - it is in the past, but people have to recognise it: left unity cannot only be an expectation on those further to the left! You make that very clear in your earlier post - "Cruddas could have won with a little more support". Well, I'm afraid he lost that support through the actions of a) some of his parliamentary supporters retreating from agreements they had made (you only need to see the number of McDonnell-and-Cruddas nominating MPs who didn't vote Cruddas to see the full impact of that) and then the crowing and nastiness of some of his extra-parliamentary supporters. Yes, I think some left unity could have enabled Jon Cruddas to be deputy leader, but I don't think it was those furthest left of the equation who stopped that from happening. And what he'd have done with it anyway, we'll never know - but a Blairite right-wing fixer can only change so many spots in my experience.
OK you want to up the ante. Fine. You can "understand why he didn't deliver support." Well , I can't. Call me old-fashioned. But I believe in loyalty and solidarity with comrades.I don't do reneging on promises.
Cruddas, let us remind ourselves.voted for the war in Iraq and most of the New Labour agenda. He was also one of the key players behind the bid to see off Ken Livingstone. To use your phrase, he is hardly a saint.
And what exactly has he achieved in real terms by not supporting the left. Not a lot as far as i can see.
What he achieved was rescuing the reputation of the Left, as I said. John McD did not get on the ballot paper. John Cruddas came third and beat 3 cabinet ministers. Yeah, John Cruddas is no Saint.I don't believe we should be in the business of plaster saints.You're correct on the positions he took on for example Iraq - but you're into accentuate the negative, eliminate the positive - his election would have meant something for the positions he espoused -housing, union workplace rights for e.g. At least he did not have the arrogance to declare £100,000+ in donations late and take for ever to resign. But surely the rules are for the little people?
Doc Dunc.....'the Blairite right-wing fixer'had good positions on housing and Trade Union rights. Would TB have supported those positions? He was the most left on the slate. Sorry mate at the end of the day whilst it is of importance, who promised who what is not the main thing. Electing a Deputy leader of the Labour Party who supports Trade Union rights is far more important to the millions of Trade Unionist operating in the real world beyond the left-wing bubble. A bubble which you may not have noticed has gotten a lot smaller over the last 30 years.
And yeah it is in the past. But I come on this blog and it's very much part of the present with current critiscm flying in. I felt I should put a different point of view. That's the nature of democratic politics. I would suggest it's time to move on.
You are right.Left Unity should not be an expectation just on those farthest to the left.
I think having a Labour LEADER who supports trade union rights would have had far more impact.
As I have been in the Labour paty for over 30 years,I am quite well aware of the parlous state of the Labour left. In the last 18 months it has, however been resuscitated by the efforts of people like John McDonnell,the LRC, and Jon Cruddas. Now let's move on....
I agree that 'who promised who what' is not the main thing - but it does give you an insight into people's principles and their way of doing things. Still, if there'd been a bit of diplomacy or even sympathy from the Cruddas camp in the days following the nominations closing, as opposed to offensive and unconvincing self-justification, I might have voted differently. I don't regret choosing not to support Jon Cruddas, and I am yet to be 100% convinced that being the only candidate not bound by collective responsibility really equates to being 'the left candidate'.
However, I have been impressed that he hasn't retreated from his entre-left position, suggesting it wasn't just a pose for electoral gain, so I look forward to working on the same side as him in the future.
I just did.
Post a Comment