Ann Cryer should be ashamed of herself for lending credence to statements about the Pakistani community by Phil Woolas. Oldham MP Woolas, an erstwhile leftie so I'm told, said inbreeding was to blame for birth defects in Asian children. So Cryer chipped in with claims that Pakistani culture was "medieval." It's not the first time she has come out with claptrap more suited to the BNP . Not, for a minute, that I'm suggesting she is racist. But the comments were ill-judged , wrong-headed , insulting and a gift to the far right. Not impressed, Ann.
Monday, 11 February 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
Yes it's me again and I'm confused again!
Are you complaining because either
a) the remarks were untrue, or
b) the remarks were true but "a gift to the extreme right"?
Finally, should an elected politician tell the truth as he or she sees it?
I would like to see what Ann said in context. In general I find that Ann is quite popular amongst young muslim women in Keighley, though she has been known to antagonise some parts of the community. I'm not saying she hasn't had some foot-in-mouth incidents, but young muslim women students of mine have told me off for being patronising and relativist when I've criticised Ann in the past!
Point taken, Dunc. The problem is that whatever Ann Cryer said, and whatever the context, it is seriously unhelpful.Would we be defending those comments if they had been said by a Tory. I think not.
Is there much of a BNP vote in Cryer and Woolas's constituencies? If so it might explain their rather ill-thought comments.
Griffin stood in Keighley last time, but it has to be said he didn't make that much of an impression psephologically (despite making a lot of noise). Whatever the rights and wrongs of what she's said (and I still haven't seen it) I really don't think she'd be trying to buy back BNP voters - she did a very good anti-BNP, anti-Griffin campaign last time.
Of course marrying a cousin does increase the risk of genetic problems slightly but according to Cryer, "If you go into a paediatric ward in Bradford or Keighley you will find more than half of the kids there are from the Asian community. Since Asians only represent 20 per to 30 per cent of the population, you can see that they are over-represented"
Could some of this be accounted for because the Pakistani parents (largely religious) are less likely than the wider population to choose abortion as a solution to the problem ?
The consanguinity issue is more complex than portrayed. There is certainly evidence that there ia an issue amongst Pakistanis from Mirpur - but the stats just don't add up when you look at other Asian-origin Muslim communities. Bangladeshis, for example, who also practice first-cousin marriages.
Some aspects of the pakistani community mores are medieval: attitude towards women and gays, and we ought to be honest about that. But things will change over time.
Post a Comment