Politics is a dirty game and after 30-odd years I see no reason why it should change - much as I would like it to. Stitch-ups, treachery and jobs for the boys have always been a part of Labour Party culture which is why in the early 1980's groups like the Campaign For Labour Party Democtacy struck such a chord with activists.
CLPD is still gamely hanging on and trying to reverse measures like the abolition of contemporary resolutions at annual Conference. The results of which we will see at Brighton in a couple of months but that will only happen if the unions come on board. Which, hopefully, they will.
OMOV voting for the National Policy Forums would be another advance , making the NPF more representative and ending the sheep-like mentality of the current set-up which is still overwhelmingly dominated by what's left of New Labour.
The mood locally in my Labour Party Branch is unremittingly bleak folowing the NEC's refusal to listen to us over the Parliamentary selection(s) and several of our keenest activists have resigned. Most members are just apathetic and unwilling to engage - and who can blame them.
As Branch Secretary, I face a Herculean task turning that round but we still have over 100 members and the only way forward is to try and motivate people which is not going to be easy in the current circumstances. In the long term, things can change and with local elections coming up next year we will need candidates in place who our members will campaign for.
If there are any more stitch-ups, or candidates barred for spurious reasons, Calder Branch will be in terminal decline.As things stand, most of us are just hanging on in there by our fingernails.
Monday, 13 July 2009
A DIRTY GAME.....
Posted by
susan press
at
11:35
Labels: Calder Valley CLP, Labour Party
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

11 comments:
Come on Susan, hanging on by your fingernails when the Tories are waiting for us just around the corner?!
I think you need to take a little more heed to the 'carping' by comrade Draycott , than listening to your friends in the NO2EU Sect.
Or do they not exist anymore?!
I think you need to stop being so nasty and making stupid assumptions which are also utterly wrong. I did not support No2EU. I thought it was a misguided distraction which would a) get little support and b) help the BNP.
Both yourself and comrade Draycott seem to think that having a go at left activists in the Labour Party is the way forward.Your comments are, frankly, tiresome.
You hang in there, Susan, and pay no heed to bounders like him, fella's a cad of the first water! What we need are more and more of you upstanding and principled Lefties thus leaving a clear run for - oh dear - us unprincipled Righties!
(Surely shome mishtake here - Ed.)
David Duff
Hi Susan,
'Mr. Centre-Left' may be wrong in saying that you supported the No2EU 'Thingy.' I would have said initiative but that would be taking it seriously. 1% of the vote ... wow. Even Arthur's Party (the SLP) got more votes. Well done Arthur ..1.2% was it?
I think the kernel of his point is correct however: you appear more concerned with connecting with far-left groupuscles via the Convention of the Left than with the electorate or others in the Labour Party you presumably consider too right wing ( e.g. Compass.) Now you may consider this 'hostile.' I consider it legitimate political comment.
You have accused me of 'having a go' and on other occasions of being 'hostile' to you and 'others' (at the time I was attempting to debate with a couple of anti-Labour people on the Union Futures blog,) which you 'contributed' to. You and others on your segment of the Left seem to consider yourselves above argument whilst you feel free to lash out at others. I was attacked on that blog as being 'scabies' plus adolescent insults about being a Virgin, a windbag, etc. Hostile? I think Marsha Jane's comment moderation leaves a lot to be desired.
I do apologise to you and your mates for having a different position on a number of issues. Not to say my approach to democratic political debate.
Dave Draycott
Susan, you misunderstand me.
1) I did not say you supported NO2EU, nor would I expect you to. (After all you would have been expelled by now).
I just think you are far too close to them.
2) I am a left activist in the Labour Party too. The question is what is 'left'?! To me, being left is about public ownership, building council houses, abolition of the monarchy, Trade Union rights, and supporting these principles through the ballot box.
(Of which Comrade Draycott would easily qualify).
However, some in our party are without a doubt entryists who use the Labour Party as a vehicle for their 'revolution'.
The truth is though Susan, those that are not 'democratic socialists' do not belong in the Labour Party.
I could not say where you stand in relation to that. Maybe you could enlighten me?
We all should hold to a firm political ideology. But it is how we carry that out into practice that matters.
I hope I practice what I preach. I think I do, but others may disagree. So for now I'll just carry on being mrcentreleft.
By the way, I hope I am not being nasty, I honestly don't think I am. Just opening up a debate, or making a statement.
After all, why would anyone want to leave the Labour Party now?
1. I am not "close" to No2EU. I had nothing to do with it and did not support it.
2.I am a democratic socialist
3.I don't think having a conversation with others in groups like the Convention Of The Left is at the expense of any commitment to the Labour Party.
4. I thought some of the comments on Union Futures were disgraceful. One of the reasons I had to impose comment moderation on my blog was horrible remarks and frankly no-one should be subject to such abuse.
However accusing anyone to the left of Compass of being a "Trot" ( as dave and Mr centre Left are inclined to) is not clever either....
An intriguing discussion... It seems odd to me that it can be a positive thing for Gordon Brown to want Liberal Democrats (and even Tories) in his Cabinet, but for left-wing activists to have meetings with socialist who - for a whatever reason - choose not be in the Labour Party is somehow a problem of loyalty.
As someone who has only followed the goings-on in Calder Valley from the outside, it is a very sad and depressing situation - apparently created by the local right-wing of the party, your current PPC and a majority on the NEC - that serves to undermine the party way beyond the local area. In many ways too. For example, I've hesitated to put my name forward for selections since these incidents, as I don't want someone who I'd previously considered a comrade to consider it fair game to slander me up and down dale because they consider my politics 'beyond the pale'. I hadn't thought we were that sort of party in the constituencies (even though there has sadly been too much evidence that we can be that sort of party at the top).
It sounds to me that the branch affiliating to the LRC is a really positive move, which should prevent it from imploding altogether.
Our local organisation hangs by a thread in many CLPs, and its this sort of situation - idiotic sectarian manipulaton, etc. - which threatens to cut those threads.
If we still want a party to rebuild we've all got to re-learn that we are a broad church and no one section or wing has a divine right to dominate.
Not that there's anything intrinsically wrong with considering onesself a Trotskyist. Most Trotskyists share more policy goals with the centre-left than the centre-left share with the Right of the Party. In the history of the UK, their means of achieving these goals have been far from revolutionary.
I think one reason so many on the Left distrust Compass is because the group associates with people (Cruddas! Trickett!) who have different speeches for different audiences. And there are plenty of so-called "centre left" supporters more inclined to attack the revolutionary Trotskyist element within or outwith Labour than to condemn the outright Toryism and pandering of pretty much the entire professional apparatus of the Party, most of its MPs and both our Youth divisions.
So, MrCentreLeft, with your professions of faith in nationalisation etc, doesn't it seem that instead of bothering about No2EU, you should concentrate on the governments' continual attack on workers' rights and wages, its continuing endorsement of Thatcherite union policy and its simple unwillingness to allow its own auditing divisions to report the truth?
Take care of those things and the far- and hard-left will fall into line because their votes and membership will collapse as people return to Labour in droves. Unless (gosh!) a self-confident and active union movement and working class actually feels compelled towards revolutionary democratic engagement! Heaven forfend.
I would be very happy to hold anyone's coat if needed?
By the way: "The question is what is 'left'?!" Indeed so! After the next election I'm betting less than a 100 Labour MPs - what's that - oh, I see, you meant 'Left', well "Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn!"
David Duff
Hi Susan,
think you should be listening to duffandnonsense....he makes a good point in his first posting and with humour ... enjoyed it .But don't get too excited DnN I think you're second point is 'in your wildest dreams." Also this little scuffle is just that a 'little scuffle."
I think it's a shame that you equate my calling someone a trot to them calling me scabies. I appreciate you condemning those attacks however...even if you did not do so at the time. And indeed supported your 'comrades', though within reasonable limits of debate.
I do not call anyone to the left of Compass trots. If I call anyone a trot it's on an individual level and a result of their political responses. Usually a tendency to define a political opponent as not just wrong but bad, a tendency to start talking before they put their brain in gear, a tendency to line up with any political force no matter how reactionary as long as it's anti-western ( something they share with tankies like George Galloway) and putting the interests of their particular corner of the Left well ahead of the interests of working people. I could go on but it's near my bedtime.
And Dave (Dave Semple) it certainly has nothing to do with anything as esoteric as political theory. Trotsky's conception of the political party has as much to do with modern politics as collecting sea shells. Also of course they are possessed of a certain purity that those of us who get involved with the 'dirty' compromises of day to day politics could never aspire to. Still Pontus Pilot had clean hands.
And Duncan. "Socialists who choose for whatever reason not to be in the Labour Party." Politics is not merely an intellectual excercise. The point is to achieve change which is of benefit to people. On this it's not simply a matter of loyalty it's a matter of effectiveness. The entire hard left outside of Labour can amount to no more than 2,000 people. Their leadership despite their protestations are profoundly anti-democratic and they run the entire show. They can amount to no more than say 100.
'Their ( the hard lefts ) votes will collapse and people will return to Labour in droves.' I have news for you Duncan the people who left Labour never went in to the hard left (with a handful of exceptions.) "The hard left will collapse": Respect has collapsed and is now Respect 1,2 and 3, the Socialist Party imploded and we now have Solidarity and the SWP are about to fade away like the Cheshire cat in "Alice" ( leaving only a smug far left smile.} The fact is they are a a huge irrelevance though on an individual level they can waste the time and energy of some good people.
Politics is about achieving results.
BtW mrcentreleft I like your style.
Dave Draycott
I always thought of myself as being on the progressive centre-right of the party - which meant very radical on the equalities agenda, pro-EU, pro-electoral reform, opposed to the cuts agenda and in favour of active interventionist government but more centrist on economic and industrial issues. Just to be more contrary, I am very left on defence and right wing on economic aid and I believe in population control as opposed to immigration control. Classify that.
However, I was always clear, and still am, that there is a basic divide between democratic reformists and revolutionaries. That is why I did and do think that Militant should have been thrown out of the party, and why there should be no truck with the SWP and its acolytes now
Post a Comment