Tuesday, 15 July 2008

INDEFENSIBLE- INEXCUSABLE

Read John McDonnell’s article about the alleged collusion of UK intelligence services in torture: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2008/jul/15/humanrights.terrorism

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Couldn't agree more - this is beyond party politics.

Robert said...

I think anyone with an ounce of sense would agree.

Anonymous said...

Let me put it in the form of a question.

If our MI5 man in Karachi is contacted by some dastardly brute in the Pakistani security services and told that he has some important information extracted from a prisoner and concerning possible terrorist activities in Britain, does the MI5 man say:

"Shhh! Don't speak a word until you tell me, and confirm it by swearing an affidavit on the Koran, that you did not do anything to infringe the prisoner's rights and that his defence lawyer was with him at all times?"

or, does he say:

"OK, what is it, and was it extracted under tortue, not that I care, but just so as I can grade it accurately for reliability?

If, as a minister, you insisted that he adopt the first approach, and subsequently a bomb kills several dozen people in London, what would you say was your fair share of the moral responsibility?
David Duff