Sunday, 19 April 2009

STAYING IN......

I spent much of yesterday with Alice Mahon while she was doing media interviews in the idyllic environs of Hebden Bridge. In the evening, it was my civic dinner over in Mytholmroyd and someone asked me had I thought tof resigning from the Labour Party.
Quite frankly, if I'm not going to do it now then I probably never will. But I must say I feel more disillusioned than ever before. As Alice said yesterday, the old ways of changing policy just aren't there any more. And, after what has happened to me as a candidate in Keighley and Calder Valley, I honestly think left-wingers do not stand a chance of beating the machine. The selection process would have to change radically to maje it a fair contest with a level playing field.
I think the only way forward would be possibly a truly OMOV process, an upper limit on campaign spending of around £1000 and an end to the "nomination" process by trade unions which to be honest is an uter stitch-up for favoured candidates. In both Calder Valley and Keighley, UNITE actively campaigned against me. As someone who has spent 25 years as an active trade unionist, I think that's a disgrace.
I used to have faith that the unions would help us "re-claim" Labout but the truth is they do their damndest to stop the left having a voice in the Party. Last yar at Labour Party conference, their cabals joined forces to ensure our resolution on leadership challenges was defeated. I was actually told by a senior union official that they did not want candidates like John McDonnell, someone whose voice is among the strongest in Parliament for trade union rights, having a chance. The resolution was actually one suggested, not by the LRC, but by the Campaign For Labour Party Democracy. Didn't matter - they trashed it
The truth is that at the moment democracy is not something we have, either as Party members nor as PPC candidates.It's all decided in rooms which may not have smoke any more but which still serve to block anyone who might not toe the line.
I've come to the conclusion that nothing will change until after the General Election. If it doesn't, then even lifetime Labour members like me may well vote with our feet. I am truly sorry Alice Mahon has left Labour, but I understand why she did.

18 comments:

Lee Skevington said...

Dear Susan,

I do truly understand why Alice left the party. However I don't understand why she did it in such a way that fed the anti-Labour media machine.

I have been on the doorstep campaigning this morning and a few people in Enfield North mentioned the McBride-Draper thing to me. They weren't happy about the things our party were doing. I made no attempt to defend it on the doorstep either. I accepted that it was an appauling state of affairs but suggested to anyone who brought it up that it shouldn't cancel out the other hard work we are doing.

Surely this just intensifies our problems? If anything, the right time to have this debate about what our party is doing shall be AFTER the coming general elecction. And that debate will be all the more important if we end up losing that election. But in the meantime surely it isn't such a good idea for the likes of Alice (who I do agree with on welfare reform, royal mail, etc) to undermine the party in such a public way?

susan press said...

Lee, Alice has not undermined the Party.She's spent months agonising about leaving and is one of the finest people I know.
The McBrides, the Mandelsons, thw whole New Labour cons[piracy has taken, as she said, much of the heart and soul from Labour. There was no "good" time to go.If the media are interested, that's because the ruling elite have taken the Party to the brink of disaster.Their backroom manoevring is something all of us should speak out against.Because, as we know, there are still thousands of fundamnetally decent Party mmebers left. But their ranks, due to the McBride scandal and the policy mistakes like Royal Mail and Welfare Reform Bill, are dwindling all the time

John Buckingham said...

Who knows, maybe next year you'll be able to stand for the NEC and be a part of rebuilding the party in a more democratic way? I'd certainly vote for you. Please stick at it so young members like myself have a chance to see the party as it should be.

Voltaire's Priest said...

Turn in your cards and give the money to your favourite charity instead. You'd be doing more for the vulnerable that way.

Anonymous said...

I know about her but never met the lady so have no idea why she left, I can understand why mind you.
But I've been in the GMB Union for too long, I've seen it at work many a time, and yes Unions still believe that New labour is better then a Tory government, why I've no idea, Unions have got sod all out of Labour except of course position for the hierarchy of the Unions. Nothing like being asked to go onto a quangos or think tank or become a special adviser.

Nope it's getting harder now to become part of the Labour party without having friends high up with Money, sadly thats Politics around the world these days.

But I left the party well I've got no intention of sitting at CLP saying sod all, while being asked to give donations.

IN Wales the Welsh Assembly are asking what use are local parties and maybe we should have regional offices in a county not in each town or village, something to do with money cost and not causing uproar.

Merseymike said...

Its depressing, but its the conclusion I came to a while back. There just didn't seem to be any way that being in the party gave one any sort of influence about what the party policy actually was. I also agree that the selection system has become corrupt. Postal votes were designed purely for those who were physically incapable of attending a meeting - not a way for the party machine to harvest votes for favoured sons and daughters.

The thing is that it is NOT only left wingers feeling like this. I've always seen myself as a progressive social democrat, but thats a long way from New Labour as we now see it.

And there is just no excuse for the McBride nastiness. None at all.

Anonymous said...

Hi Susan,
I have to say your suggestion that the Trade Unions should be stripped of their right to nominate is totally outrageous coming from a 'Left' winger. What happened to the we need more democracy and maintaining the Union Link? I am proud of the political activity of my Union Unite which you appear to have a particular bind with. Could it be that there is another reason why Unite has not supported you, other than the idea you have that we're just a bunch of right-wing bureaucratic nasties. You oppose the expansion of Heathrow and we in Unite - the biggest Union in the Country and the biggest in Civil Aviation support it. So why would you expect Unite's nomination?

Dave Draycott
Unite Shop Steward

E10 Rifle said...

Lee

The "undermining the party in a public way" is all coming from the leadership and the entrenched Right of the party at the moment, not people like Alice.

Recent events - the selection shenanigans and the pathetic sixth-form politics that underpins the antics of McBride and Draper's childish nonsense among others - demonstrate that the Rightwing leadership are much less interested in party unity than in undermining their opponents by foul means and foul.

If they've got a choice between keeping the party together as a broad church and picking a fight with other, left-leaning, elements within it, they choose the latter every time. They simply AREN'T party loyalists, but the most sectarian headbangers to have ever infected the party - for whom defeat of their enemies is everything, usually in the most puerile student-politics fashion.

This parochial nonsense comes from the top and is emblematic, sadly, of a leadership that no longer knows who it's speaking to, what it's saying or what it's purpose is. It grieves me to say this because the consequences of an election defeat will be grievous and we must all try and stop the Tories but, if like me you spend much of your time trying to defend the party to outsiders, you must have some idea of how bedraggled and unprincipled and ineffective the top brass now looks.

Anonymous said...

I loved the way that Brown spent the last big tranche of union cash on hoardings that boosted his ego: Not Flash Just Gordon. And then the man dared to ask the unions to bail the party out again. I'm not in a union now, I think the leaders are amoral.

Adam Spencer said...

I fear that you are right that the left cannot now win parliamentary selections. Actually, I think it is probably worse than that. I think that many in the party now no longer thing we are a legitimate part of the party. Labour used to be a broad church, now the right seem intent on turning it into a sect.

susan press said...

Let's make a distinction between the union bureaucrats who stitch up the processes and the activists.
I have defended the Labour link at countless meetings .I was recently at a rally in Parliament with Tony Woodley.
I've spent 25 years in the NUJ. UNITE's conduct in the Calder Valley selection , or should I say the conduct of one or two individuals, is already part of a complaint which has gone to the Labour Party.
I don't think it is outrageous to say that small cabals agree who is, or isn't supported in Parliamentary selections. Which is why maybe it's time to change the process - and leave union activists to make their own minds up nothe strength of the candidates' capabilities, not who they happen to know in high places. The Branch nomination process, which currently does NOT allow canddiates to attend selection meetings, aloso needs looking at. So stop getting on your high horse dave and start listening to the people on the ground who are sick and tired of being done over by cliques

Anonymous said...

Hi Susan,

if I am on my 'high horse' (and I don't think I am) at least it improves the chances of our seeing eye to eye. Interesting bit of furious backpeddling though. Still begs the question why my Union should support a candidate who they disagree with fundamentally on a major policy: Heathrow which you have described on your blog as 'an environmental and political folly' and 'political suicide."Whilst Unite supports the expansion.

Dave Draycott

susan press said...

Not backpedalling at all. I would be interested to know your views on why UNITE would suppport an advocate of neo-liberalism and privatisation.
The Heathrow issue will cost Labour seats in the south-east - and it's oppposed by many MPs, inclding Linda Riordan?

Anonymous said...

Hi Susan,
not backpeddling? You appear to have backed of stripping the Unions of their right to nominate candidates and are now talking about 'cabals'. Or does your original position stand: a 'strange' position for someone on the Left.
The questions still stands but is unlikely to be answered, as to why you should have expected Unites nomination.

Dave Draycott

susan press said...

Dave, you haven't answered my question, have you? Was UNITE's candidate in calder valley in favour of secondary action, the Trade Union Freedom Bill, the Welfare Reform Bill, Are these questions ever asked? Why aren't ALL candidates invited to union hustings? . Is Linda Riordan supportive of the third runway at Heathrow? There are other issues regarding UNITE's role in this selection but as they are the subject of a formal complaint by my Branch I am not going to be drawn on them. I think they are best dealt with by the appropriate channels.

Anonymous said...

Love Alice but would Joan Maynard have left

we have had right wing leaders before and stich ups

but its our party and we must stay and fight

in times of trouble people turn to OUR Party (no other Party)

to quote a famous saying

there is no no land beyond the Volga

Anonymous said...

Dont worry when the Tories get in they will stop all trade union affiliations

so that will be the end of that

if we only looked after are Class in the same way as the Tory bankers and Toffs

Anonymous said...

Hi Susan

didn't answer your questions as I was trying to get you to answer mine. Why should Unite support a candidate who opposes Heathrow expansion when they support it? 170,000 jobs are reliant on Heathrow. It operates at 98% capacity and aircraft 'stacking' accounts for 330,00 tons of C02 ommissions and as Will Hutton said in the Observer this weekend C02 cuts need to be planned across the economy. So the issue is about more than cheap electoral calculation. Triangulate or die eh? Tough call for Unite. As for Linda Riordan she abstained (she is a Unite sponsored MP) and as you have previously published the rebels names on your blog you are asking a question you know the answer too. Sectarian nit picking? Has to be said the Halifax MP is not a 'rebel without a pause.'

Dave Draycott