Like millions of others, I somehow got sucked in to the brouhaha over Susan Boyle against my better judgement and- being somewhat sentimentally drawn to middle-aged women getting an unexpected break - was willing her to win on Saturday. The plain fact was she was beaten by the better act.
And now the predictably horrible media circus begins charting what is likely to be a tailspin of sharp decline for the 48-year-old from West Lothian. What wasn't clear during her first, jaw-dropping, performance on BGT was that this was someone utterly unsuited to cope with celebritydom. As indeed most instant celebrities are.
To get up on a stage in front of millions of viewers you have to be supremely talented or supremely delusional. Had Susan been average-looking, or even better than average, with the nice but unremarkable voice she's got she would have got nowhere. People were simply astounded that someone so patently homely and unworldly could get out there and show a bravura which was superficially extraordinary. In reality, it was down to the fact she had no conception of her limitations. A plus on the night- but ultimately a disaster.
In the past few weeks, the media certainly put paid to that, dubbing her the Hairy Angel and coming up with all kinds of other deeply unflattering epithets which undoubtedly led to her defeat on Saturday.
Britain loves an underdog, but unfortunately our national psyche also loves nothing more than building someone up - and then bringing them down with ruthless precision.
A couple of years ago, I interviewed a professional opera singer. It was on the day Pavarotti died and we talked about Paul Potts, a previous ( also unlikely) winner.
She was philosophical about the shedloads of money such figures can earn, saying that in the long-term they are doomed to fail because they a) don't have the talent nor b) the years of training and experience required to stay in it for the long haul. Potts, I understand, is still doing the rounds but is hardly the name on everyone's lips anymore. The same will happen to Susan Boyle - perhaps a lot more quickly as she grapples with her demons.
Her story appealed to all of us who can belt out songs from the shows after a couple of drinks - and feel sympathy for someone whose life seems spectacularly humdrum
But , in hindsight, she might have been better off sticking to the karaoke nights and the devotion of her cat Pebbles. The dream she dreamed may end up being a nightmare.......

4 comments:
When I first saw this, I thought you'd had a genuine moment of honest self reflection. Then I read it again and realised it didn't say 'the sad case of Susan Press'
How predictable. And how predictable it is anonymous.
Bit like Gordon Brown dreaming of being the leader but without the guile or the balls to make it happen, now he is moving his balls to a better job so he can blame his balls for making the mess.
love it.
Robert
Beaten by a better act? A load of kids who looked like a bad warm-up act? I think not...
Post a Comment