Thursday, 26 June 2008

SPATS AND SPLITS

All hell has broken loose on the Socialist Unity blog following the defection of four former RESPECT councillors to Labour. The four, I understand, were all members of the Left List - the SWP breakaway group forced to re-brand itself when Galloway kept the right to the original name. Former comrades are effing and blinding and, of course, ballistic that the four have gone over to the dark side. Or have they?

Yesterday I was reading the RESPECT ( mark Galloway) newspaper and its manifesto loooks strangely familiar: Pensions linked to average earnings, troops out of Iraq, no more PFI, repeal of the Tory anti-union laws, fairer taxation, end to tuition fees, return to public ownership of the railways etc etc . Yes, almost every single one of the issues on RESPECT's policy agenda is in line with the LRC. And in his editorial, George Galloway makes it clear he is "united" with the Labour Left and John McDonnell in fighting for these policies. Albeit outside the Labour Party.
It is tempting of course to say well if you have the same policies as us why for God's sake don't you do the logical thing and join the Labour Party to fight from within.
RESPECT's 12-point programme is after all a far cry from the revolutionary demands which used to comprise the "Where we stand" creed of the Socialist Worker And it can only be furthered by more councillors and MPs with a left agenda. Much easier, let's face it, under a Labour Party banner.
However, we have to avoid the mistake of being sectarian and accept that, despite our differences, it is better working together than apart when we can. Just look at the mess in Tower Hamlets.......The Convention Of The Left will hopefully be the start of more positive ways of working together

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is all to save Jim Fitzpatrick MP's neck at the next General Election. He is behind these "defections", last month he managed to recruit the Lib Dems laziest councillor into the ranks of the Labour Group - despite opposition from the within the local Party.

As it is likely that the General Election will be in May 2010 this will coincide with the Council elections. Tower Hamlets LP has not been allowed to select its own council candidates for some years - in 2006 all LP candidates were imposed by the GLLP (Jim's hand is also suspected in this).

Jim's new constituency (Poplar & Limehouse) is not as safe as his old one. There is a significant and growing Tory vote (not entirely confined to Docklands).

George Galloway is the Respect candidate - he cannot win, but he could still take enough Labour votes to ensure that the Tories do.

Jim Fitzpatrick, himself a former member of the SWP, is completely politically bankrupt, the defection of this latest batch of councillors is political opportunism and could yet backfire.

susan press said...

Well I never have much time for any defectors and it sounded more than a bit dodgy.

Anonymous said...

To be fair to George (these occasions don't come often) he was expelled from Labour for his outspoken and correct opposition to the Iraq war, so he wouldn't be allowed to rejoin.

Anonymous said...

I understand these were actually the better Respect councillors with a trade union base

most other respect councillors had no tu experience (unlike those in Preston)

The truth is the SWP/Respect is dead

who thought the Communist Party would outlive the SWP

maybe Respect and the CPB will finally get to affilate/join the Labour Party yet

Anonymous said...

In Tower Hamlets (before Respect) local LP membership was bucking the national trend and going through the roof. Not because we are a socialist party (although we have socialists in it), even less because we are a New Labour party (although we have many who claim that badge)- but because Labour runs the local council. As the best vechile to town hall influence we were being "infiltrated" by friends, releatives and supporters of individuals seeking the Labour ticket to get on the council - not a too unusaual tactic. Then along came the Iraq war, Galloway and the specatular defeat of Oona King in 2005. The council elections of 2006 saw the defeat of the New Labour leader and most of his cabinet by Respect candidates. The demise of Respect is well documented eslsewhere, but locally those elected on the Respect ticket (against the war, against privatisation etc) are defecting to the New Labour's sinking ship (the exception being a card carrying member of the SWP {and an elected member of Respect} who defected to the Tories!)So what has induced the defections to New Labour, what has been promised to those joining the bankrupt New Labour project? More than likely a shoe-in as a LP council candidate in 2010. To achieve this there will have to be impositions of candidates. Jim Fitzpatrick would probably claim to know nothing about any of this, but many suspect his dead hand in this. His is a a policy of everyone bar Galloway - he thinks this is the best way to save his neck at the General Election. Until New Labour the East End was somewhere where you weighed the Labour vote rather than count it. New Lab policies have caused a revolt locally and poisoned local politics, splitting long held coalitions. Comeupance may well be due, but should Jim Fitzpatrick fail he will recover far quicker than the local party will.

Chris S said...

It's a joke, it also kills off any illusions that the SWP CC was spreading in the rank and file over a 'left-right' split.

You are right, there aint much difference between the Labour Left and Respect Renewal. I am unconvinced of fighting from within the Labour Party (even though i think the LRC is interesting) when the space in the Labour party for the left to express itself is almost non-existant.

The SWP had to come into the convention after they have saw other sections of the Left in Manchester deciding to do something together. It would have been terrible for them to be left outside like the SPEW have decided to.