Good news from Glasgow East, where according to a poll in today's Sunday Mirror, Labour is 14 points ahead. If we can hang on to this seat then maybe there is hope of a recovery significant enough to avert a Tory landslide at the next election. Maybe.
I am often accused of "disloyalty" to the Labour Party but this isn't so. I have no loyalties at all to New Labour but I have no plans to leave the Labour Party.
On Friday night, I spent several hours discussing Party politics with a friend's new partner who is a member of RESPECT. I had promised NOT to get embroiled in the inevitable argument. So of course no sooner had we ordered the poppadums and cracked open the beers than we started bickering. By the end of the evening, we had amicably agreed to disagree but my point then, now, and probably to my grave is this.
In places like Glasgow East, minority left parties like the SSP and Solidarity will fight it out for whatever votes they can get. But the hard truth is that the SSP's Frances Curran, however good a candidate, hasn't a cat in hell's of winning. Despite the bleakness of the current situation, leaving Labour is not a sensible step to take. We must try and re-build the Labour Party. Not abandon it for some half-baked plan for a "new left party." Let's face it even a 1931 scenario - 50 Labour MPs - is 49 more than RESPECT has got.

10 comments:
So let's get this straight: Leaving Labour isn't sensible because there's no realistic alternative. Instead you spend a lot of your energy slagging off Labour, and ignoring any good done, so that Labour will suddenly see the light and move leftwards? I'm guessing an electoral defeat is envisaged first (hence the slagging off).
I can't imagine why anybody would call you and your ilk disloyal.
I hoper new Labour get bloody thumped the Mirror poll a Labour party rag which once had wet dreams about Blair, then moved over to Brown, now thinks Purnell would be a great leader, the problem is I do not see new Labour as anything other then a Thatcher copy.
I wait until the real polls come out but as I said before 22% lead is a lot but if Labour wins without a major majority it will sound the alarms bells my area use to have a 20,000 majority now is down to 7,000 majority and the area has 15,890 people on IB and they are steaming about the new rules for IB, and Labour now See's problem, hence the MP telling me disabled people should not be forced back to work, I said do not tell me tell Purnell and Brown. Sadly she did neither voting for the welfare reforms.
But lets hope the people vote for a left government the SNP
Let's get one thing straight. I don't want Labour to lose. But the reason Labour is on course to lose is because this Government - this Labour Government - has dissilusioned, disappointed and dissed its core voters. If Labour loses it's down to the failed policies of new Labour. The fact the PM doesn't listen . Tbe fact that the arrogance of New Labour will be its undoing. Good done? Yes I know the mantra . minimum wage, SureStart, Northern Ireland. Unfortunately most of that credit was used up in the first two terms and since 2005 the Govt has been floundering and getting it wrong. Change the policies, change our political fortunes.
God I hope Labour holds Glasgow East if not then Harman could seriously become prime minister and I would have to find a bucket to be sick into.
I think the problem for me would be that I actually think that the SNP policies are a lot more - well, Labour , social democratic, than the UK Labour government.
I tend to think that whilst the electoral system is as it is, forming new parties will inevitably fail.
However, I think it quite ridiculous to expect people in the labour party not to express their disapproval when some of their policies are right wing and diametrically opposed to basic Labour ideas. Tony Crosland advocated the mixed economy, but those ideas have no relationship at all to the market obsessions of Hutton et al. They love the market, as much as any Thatcherite. They are right wing, and not remotely Labour.
Susan
just thought I'd post a comment that agreed with most of what you had to say on this one. The problem with the far left is that they are congenitally incapable of working together, never mind with anyone else. The groups you mention [ parties seems to big a word] ... the SSP and Solidarity were once of course in the same group prior to their split. Respect in England have split....... with 'Gorgeous' George Galloway taking the SWP to Court in a copyright battle for the Respect name. The SWP have now changed the name of their electoral front organisaton from Left List to Left Alternative. Hell this is what politics is really about! Makes tax credits, Surestart, the minimum wage,etc, a lot more impressive doesn't it. Which is a where I part company from you somewhat. It's more than a Mantra and though I am on Strike Wednesday and Thursday I would rather have Gordon Brown there as the PM than Cameron. Where I think we can agree is that the government needs to take a centre left position and deliver through social democratic means in areas such as housing and transport where the market cannot deliver and is in fact disintegrating. The housing market is a prime example. Also they need to address the taxation system. Look to lifting the low paid out of tax and start taxing the flyaway wealthy at a higher level. Both would be electorally popular.
Dave Draycott
Australia, New Zealand, Ireland all had left splits from Labour all came to nothing
The truth is after the next election the only Party on the left to have a seat will be the Greens either in Brighton or Norwich, and my view its Norwich (where the Greens are the opposition on the council and Charles Clarke the Labour candidate)
I hear we have not got enough time to get in PR so its down to core vote. Thank you so much to those comrades who opposed PR you really did help the Tories
Your on Strike this week, Little wonder the teachers have said in my area they intend crossing the picket lines, the Schools in my area are open, I said to my wife I've never crossed a picket line in my life, but I think I will this time.
What the hell is the difference then if you have to go on strike to get a decent living standard if Brown is in power or Cameron, they both believe the same thing, that the working class do not count.
Tax fiasco should be enough, now we have the car taxation which will hit hard working people who try to raise up a bit.
God how far we have come that people who need to go on strike still back the arse hole who is causing it, I cannot believe the people in this country.
Exactly how is it a good thing if the corrupt, far-right party of war and privatisation wins a by-election?
That why the workers are voting Tory ????
Thats the problem with the ultra left its un electable
the class is looking to the Tories not the Left
unfortunately (as our Red Ken knows)
Post a Comment