Tuesday, 29 July 2008

I DON'T MEAN TO DEPRESS YOU BUT.......

This is what actually happened to all those centre-left amendments at Warwick. Or at least the view from a councillor in Darlington. Gallows humour, I suppose, that the Centre Left Grassroots Alliance is absurdly dubbed "far left". In truth, it shows just how far removed the NPF is from the rest of us. As Duncan Hall says on Labourhome "fraudulent and useless." Worse, steering this Party to crushing electoral defeat .Pretty depressing stuff.


What was striking was how marginalised the far left were during these votes. The heirs to the Bennite tendancy in the Party are now coalesced around the Grassroots Alliance, a group which does secure some members on the Party's National Executive Committee via internal elections. At Warwick, where they pressed for decisions to abandon Trident, for example, or overturn our academies policy in education, they lost overwhelmingly. In most votes, where 161 delegates were present, the Grassroots Alliance got fewer than 10 and in most cases around 5 votes.
It shows just how distant the far left is in Labour politics now from the mainstream, and that Gordon Brown leads a united party. Clearly with the economic outlook looking uncertain and potentially negative, the Party is suffering in the polls. Gleeful Tories are assuming some kind of 1997 meltdown in two years time. The difference I think is that we are now, and do not appear to be a divided party in the way the Conservatives did then, over Euurope and other issues. If the economic situation begins to improve, and with a coherent manifesto for the next 5 years in place, we are much better placed to stage a recovery

8 comments:

Tom said...

In my view this shows the lack of political knowledge and understanding of the right and the obstinate refusal to organise and adapt of the left.

susan press said...

Tom, that is arrant nonsense. I know people in the LRC and other groups like Save The labour party and CLPD (those "mad bennites") who spent WEEKS painstakingly going through NPF documents and tabling amendments. They seriously seriously tried tiomake a diffeence this time. This is the result. NPF representatives are chosen at Conference -there are a handful per region. They do not represent anyone other than a right=wing New labour cabal. The only way the NPF will change is if we choose our reps as we choose NEC members. Strange that four out of six CLP reps are, "far left" when chosen by the membership as a whole?
161 delegates determine the future of the Labour Party.About the same number of people as are in my Branch.Difference is we have a spread of opinion and proper debates.With votes.

Merseymike said...

The NPF is a stitch-up, and always has been.

Still, its their look-out. Labour are going to be absolutely crushed at the next election, and the sheer complacency of the assumption that somehow it is all going to be OK 'if' the economic situation improves....

Duncan Hall said...

Well it's interesting to hear something of the process. There were 161 delegates there - presumably this is including union representatives and ministerial figures as well as the 'party activists'? - and they voted on the amendments. (Do we know if they voted on all amendments or whether there was some process by which amendments were selected?) and between 5 or 10 of these delegates tended to vote for the left or leftish policies.

Of course, the decisions of the NPF are entirely invalid - there is no consitutional basis for that being party policy. That is granted by conference. If local parties could be persuaded of how their amendments have been ignored, maybe we could agitate for a 'no' vote at conference? We wouldn't win of course, but it could at least be a germ around which resistence might be able to coalesce.

susan press said...

Duncan, there isn't any voting at Conference any more - party policy was referred to the NPF. The union colluded last year in the abolition of contemporary motions - I hope they are pleased with what they achieved. I know many people who put real effort into those amendments ( I must confess Ithought it would be sadly futile) and they have been utterly disregarded

Duncan Hall said...

Is there not even a 'take it or leave it' vote on the NPF report as a whole?

Anonymous said...

So the left can't change Labour Party policy. Simple as that. And while I applaud the Calder Valley resolution, you have to admit that the chips are heavily stacked against any left candidate like John McDonnell in a direct bid for the leadership. It's still true that socialists have a better chance of being elected if they stand as Labour candidates than if they stand against Labour. (Though the Labour brand is so tarnished now that many will lose their seats.) But if they are elected, what then ? How many compromises and sell-outs will they have to make even to get a junior cabinet post ?

susan press said...

I think it is desperately important that we fight to sace the admittedly few socialists we have. They have absolutely nothing to gain by leaving Labour. And, most importantly, the working-class has everything to lose.