Tuesday, 5 August 2008

CLARE SHORT IS RIGHT ABOUT MILIBAND

Clare Short has made lots of mistakes in her time - not least not resigning over Iraq. And she was utterly wrong to abandon the Labour whip. Nevertheless, she makes some very salient points re Miliband in today's Independent. She shares my ( widely held) view that Gordon Brown's biggest mistake was not shifting left and sticking with the Blairite agenda. And that Miliband, far from being the answer to anyone's electoral prayers, would be an unmitigated disaster.


http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/clare-short-how-can-miliband-be-the-answer-to-labours-ills-885219.html

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pardon? She disliked Tony Blair, dislikes Gordon Brown and now critising David Miliband who is a much more able Minister than she was. What a woman - she asked an advisor (David Miliband was not an MP when the Iraq war started)to influence the PM rather than her cabinet colleagues. Funny that she was happy with all policies when she was a Minister - she of course all the perks. Fortunately we do not have to listen to her rants anymore - they and she are insignificant.

susan press said...

David Miliband has been MP for South Shields since 2001- the Iraq War started in 2003.
It is not about "dislike." Is it? It is about the policies which are wrong.And Short is absolutely right to say that. Her article isn't a rant. It's actually very measured.

Anonymous said...

Clare Short, like a stopped clock, is right twice a day.

What has Miliband done? He, like Brown, has an undeserved reputation.

I seem to remember that his first job was photocopying at the GLC (John McD must remember the brilliance of his photocopying, indeed had Thatcher not abolished the GLC Miliband's skills at the Xerox may have been brought to a wider public attention, surely it must be on his CV). Since then he has been a policy wonk, then parachuted into a safe seat (2001). He is a Blairite through and through, he bottled it last year and refused to stand against Brown - he has nothing new to offer.

Miliband's father, Ralph, on the other hand would have made a much more interesting member of the government - a man with a deserved reputation. Like the Benn's, the Miliband's have proved to be disappointed.

Anonymous said...

Sorry - I got my 2001 and 2003 dates mixed up. I don't think he was in the cabinet at the time of the war - he was a Minister at the time? I will read it up. Whatever, I still feel strongly about Claire Short.

I too remember Ralph - I had to study his work and he was a big hero of mine some 30 years ago! Interesting you say David Miliband is a Blairite. All my reading in recent weeks suggest that he is a friend but is very much to the left of Blair in policy areas.

Robert said...

You have been reading the hype, he is not left at all, he makes out he is , but left, left of what, he is another person who has problems telling left from right.

Ravi Gopaul said...

I've met Claire; she was on Question Time and she shook my hand (she has one demon grip I can tell you!!).

I think someone has been filling that boy's head with nonsense to make him make a suicide run on Brown, which is basically what Short actually said.

But I have to say what is true for Miliband is also true for any left candidate (sorry John!!).

Let’s stop the infighting and try and pressure Brown into making some left leaning policies.

Anonymous said...

http://hopisen.wordpress.com/2008/08/04/fightback-reshuffle/

Hutton - Chancellor?

Oh dear lord!

susan press said...

Ravi, what is true for Miliband is NOT true for a left candidate. Brown is finished. Hanging on to a Leader who will lead us to annihilation is not the answer.

Ravi Gopaul said...

Susan, we, (i.e. the party) is in no fit state to run a GE campaign. The Tories have more money, activists and at the moment public support than we do.

Surely what will transpire after an exhaustive leadership election would do the victor (if he is not Brown) have to declare a GE.

We would be slaughtered at the ballot box.

Now, considering what we are doing in office I have to say maybe deservedly (10p tax fiasco, the cost of living, war, privatisation, tuition fees, no new council housing etc), but as you know we could lose a good many left MPs and our base is even more withered than before.

New Labour is dead. 1997 is over and we have moved on. Just as the left have been saying since time immemorial the market has failed to deliver. The New Labour wing of the party is bereft of policy; Crosland's socialists are becoming even more vocal in their opposition to the leadership.

We all agree there is only one direction of policy: the left. Is Brown the man to deliver it? I don't think he has much choice.

Merseymike said...

But, Susan - being realistic - a left candidate won't be elected.

susan press said...

Ravi,it would be great if Gordon Brown suddenly had a Road To Damascus moment and came on board with the left. Sad truth is he won't.
I take your points re annihilation but I think we face that anyway. So how to fight it?
Do we carry on as now. No, we can't. This Miliband thing is New Labour's last gasp. But Brown IS New Labour. The left has to mobilise because in my view there will be a coup. And we have to be ready.A left candidate may not win but that doesn't mean we have to rally round Brown.The mood in the dwindling ranks of the Party can at least swing things round and who knows what would happen if we had a free and fair contest.Rally behind the Calder Valley resolution! GB isn't the answer- he is the problem

Anonymous said...

Until You (We?) have TB in court over Iraq, nothing good will happen to Labour. Grassroot Labour MUST understand that.

Thank you.