Sunday, 3 August 2008

GORDON BROWN AS TRAGIC HERO

In the early hours of the morning, I scoured the Sunday papers and decided I could not be bothered blogging any more about who's leaked what, to whom and why. The dying days of New Labour are febrile with disloyalty, betrayal, ambition, and all the other ingredients which make politics a very nasty game.
Undoubtedly, it's the policies as much as the personalities which have contributed to this sorry tale. But Brown's innate insecurities have also contributed to his imminent downfall.
He is, indeed a tragic hero - in the literary sense .
Eng Lit students of a certain age will have read A C Bradley's Shakespearean Tragedy - in which protagonists are all assigned a "fatal flaw" which leads to their downfall. Othello's, obviously, is jealousy. Macbeth's ambition. Hamlet's is procrastination. In his 25 years in Parliament, Brown has somehow managed to combine all three of these very human traits. So no wonder he's in serious trouble.
Aristotle also had five prerequisites for tragic heroes . They normally start off being nobly born or blessed with wisdom. Unfortunately, they then fall prey to something called Hamartia, roughly translated as an error in judgment. This then leads to peripeteia - a reversal of fortune brought about because of the hero's mistake. Closely followed by anagnorisis - recognition it's basically his own fault. Then there's catharsis - a purging of all all the above.
Where is Brown amid this Greek tragedy? Stage 4. As he broods on the beach at Southwold,
my guess is he knows that his current malaise is all his own fault. The question is what happens next.
As the Blairite vultures gather round, my guess is he will end up, tragically, like King Lear, alone on the "blasted heath" of New Labour.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

It's all Greek to me, he had to say. And to read any heroism and tragedy in Brown's predicament is way over the top.

How about a socially dysfunctional misfit got lucky, got found out and is now getting shafted.

Anonymous said...

Susan I LOVE your analysis!

It's good to see someone not just lambasting Gordon for once, the unfortunate thing in this entire disaster is that Gordon is beginning to get a reputation as being quite the moron, which on a personal level he isn't - it's very unjust really, he has become the punch bag representing everything that people hate about the past 13 years of the new Labour project.

Personally I actually find Brown more likable than Blair, which is why it's so easy for me to feel sorry for him, but part of me suspects that soon the majority public opinion is going to swing into a sympathetic state and start to lay of someone who has deteriorated into quite a pathetic state; (at least once the editorials in the Red Tops have decided that they must do so in order to avoid being the villains of the affair).

Anonymous said...

ministers and ex ministers to fill policy gap say BBC news tonight

come on we all know this is the Blairites last hurrah

they want to have a big fight then walk out and no doubt later claim it was Gordon not Blairite policies that lost the election

its the worst kind of politics

as if these policies have any support in the Party anymore

and they should be expelled from the Party

Anonymous said...

Good Shakespeare sister

Robert said...

Well I will admit is very cleaver man, which is a worry as to why he forced through the 42 detention.

Why he does not say to people ID cards are dead, but that will annoy the American who hope to make a bit of money out of the USA new State. How can a bloke with a good understanding of money or so he says make a balls up of the 10p tax rate.

How can a bloke make the biggest blunder ever made stand in front of millions days before the world credit crunch and say no more boom and bust and do not forget that, three days later the words hitting the media was credit crunch , we sitting at home were saying we are in for recession, and he was saying nope we are safe.

Is he that stupid the answer has to be yes or he is being protected form reality.