In today's Guardian, Polly Toynbee finally puts the knife into Gordon Brown and says he must go. Just as two years ago she counselled Gordon was the only man for the job.
Her antidote to the current miasma is another coronation - this time for Alan Johnson.To say this smacks of desperation is putting it mildly.
One can only smile wryly at her suggestion we "valiant few" still left as Party members should go to our MPs and urge them to instal AJ ASAP without an election as if that would make a ha-porth of difference to Labour's chances.
I'd like to remind Polly that a "valiant few" of us tried in vain to get our MPs to have a contest last time for the Labour leadership. We were resolutely ignored by the vast majority of MPs.Over 300 of whom now bear the responsibility for installing a Leader who has turned out to be a catastrophe. That catastrophe just might have been less had he had to face opposition from a swathe of candidates and a proper debate about Labour's future. But the kingmakers in the PLP ordained otherwise and now we are where we are.
I see little point in a leadership contest now. But if Brown were to go, we would have to have one. We would also have to have a General Election pretty much immediately afterwards in a climate febrile with disdain for all politicians, disgust at MPs who cut welfare benefits then demand £400 a month themselves for food on top of a Ministerial salary, and even "left-wing" MPs who claim for posh rugs and furnishings.It is a mess of such fantastic proportions that we can only sit back and see what June 4 brings. But a whisky and revolver for Gordon Brown without some fundamental U-turns on policy and humility in front of the electorate is not the answer.Polly's "mea culpa" is below
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/may/11/labour-gordon-brown
Tuesday, 12 May 2009
THE HISTORY OF MS POLLY TOYNBEE
Posted by
susan press
at
12:47
Labels: Labour leadership, the abyss
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
those who flipped houses
must be told they cannot stand
thats leadership
not Camerons pay back the money for tax payers paying for the cleaning the Castle Moat or Heli Pad
An excellent blog Susan. I only usually agree with you about 60 per cent but I always respect your honesty and integrity. Polly Toynbee is like a windmill and chnages her mind every ten minutes. A few weeks ago she thought that Brown could be saved by his new policy on absentee fathers. Then it was the great post office sell off that would save him. She was a Social Democrat when it suited her.
On Bank Holiday
Monday I watched the BBC Parliament rerun of the 79 election which featured her late husband, the very erudite Peter Jenkins who was a Guardian columnist in the days when that was a great paper. I remember back in 68 or 69 when he wrote a scathing 10,000 word piece for the Statesman attacking Harold Wilson.
These days Polly is more likely to write 10k words sucking up to whover is the next great white hope of the party.
If she was a bloke I suppose the best word would be "creep".
Integrity she hasn't.
The Guardiand and Observer are sacking 50 hacks so I hope that she gets the boot.
This is the first time since I've been involved in politics that I can remember disagreeing with her profoundly (though i didn't actually back a leadership candidate in the first place as I thought the field too narrow).
You're right, the last thing we need is another coronation. But the second last thing we need is a leadership election right now.
Polly views on whether or not there should be a leadership election once Brown goes (whenever that is) are of no relvance whatsoever - if she thinks that such an election would be uncontested see clearly has no understanding of the the current Labour Party, and given her demonstrable ignorance a period of silence on the subject might be appropriate.
Well, today's Brown is the same one Toynbee and co. backed so firmly at the time of his coronation. His strengths and weaknesses now are the same as they were then.
I did think we needed a leadership election last September and I think Miliband should've stepped up and put Brown out of his political misery.
The 'we can ditch Brown and win the election or get a hung parliament' horse has now bolted.
The only person who'd really benefit from Brown going now is Brown himself, who is currently in serious danger of ending up as Michael Foot without the socialism (but with the nationalised banks).
Post a Comment