Friday, 10 August 2007

NEAL LAWSON IS DELUDING HIMSELF.......

Still catching up on politics stuff missed while I was away. And ploughing through the 152 comments following Neal Lawson's blue-sky pro-Brown piece in Wednesday's Guardian, it was striking how few people actually took on board what he was saying. ie that well-meaning pressure groups like COMPASS can somehow push Brown to the left and turn New Labour into a social democratic "progressive" phenomenon to create a "seismic" shift to the left. Clearly miffed by the negative tone of much of his readers , Lawson countered by saying his approach was better than "sterile lists of correctness" , which echoes fellow Compassite John Harris's dismissal of the hard left the other week. And is equally misguided and unhelpful.
It is Lawson and his clique who choose to delude themselves that Brown is politically malleable. This justifies their decision not to back a left leadership candidate and throw themselves heart and soul into the deputy leadership campaign ( hey, what was all that about in hindsight) and, specifically, Jon Cruddas's candidature.Has this changed ANYTHING Brown is planning in the weeks and months ahead. I think not. Yes, there has been a nod to social housing ( but nothing concrete), a less strident tone on Iraq, and Brown's stern , sensible manner appeals to a nation fed-up with Blair's doe-eyed schmaltz.That's it.
The hard fact is Brown is no socialist manque, and I expect his first Leader's speech at conference to make that absolutely clear. It will be be pro PFI, pro Trident, business as usual in Iraq, and pro a "flexible" economy ie kowtowing to globalisation.
What's utterly mystifying about this collective hallucination on the soft left is that Gordon Brown makes it absolutely clear what his position is. He is nothing if not honest.
Yet the Lawsons of this world pretend otherwise - presumably because they won't face up to the harsh alternative Which is to fight within the Labour Party for a fundamental change of direction , stop sticking to a neo-con agenda, and stand up for working people.
Lawson once worked for Brown, his attitudes are basically New Labour.His world is metropolitan middle-class.I'm not surprised by the Alice In Wonderland direction COMPASS has taken. Just a bit tired of them dissing those of us who acknowledge we have a mountain tio climb, but don't pretend we're even halfway there.

2 comments:

Andreas Paterson said...

Neal Lawson isn't the only one who's upbeat about a Gordon Brown, at out last GC meeting Ian Gibson (who I respect greatly and would hardly classify as a loyalist) was very upbeat about the Brown government.

I would like to hope that such optimism isn't misplaced.

Anonymous said...

So would I . But I seriously think many on the centre-left are believing what they want to believe.Meanwhile, 4 soldiers dead this week in Basra, UK signs Menwith Hill (without ANY consultation in Parliament) up to Bush's defence policy, Trident goes ahead. Immigration rules tightened.Etc etgc etc