Friday, 1 June 2007

BBC CALLING.......


I did an interview earlier on on Radio 5 Live......the transcript is here.............


6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear Susan

Surely the main lesson from the 'coronation' is that the Left/Centre-Left of the Parliamentary Labour Party and their supporters in the CLPs, TUs and Socialist Societies were hopelessly disorganised.

While John McDonnell organised well outside Parliament, he failed in the first instance to secure committed support from inside the so-called Socialist Campaign Group of Labour MPs.

You could argue that he misled members outside by Parliament by the manner in which he launched his campaign without solid PLP support.

However, I don't believe that personal recriminations are the way forward. We need more forthright debate and discussion about why membership of the Labour Party matters, with its Values and federal structure.

In any event, all the signs so far suggest that Brown himself is not interested in following Blair's monarchical style of government.

http://petergkenyon.typepad.com/peterkenyon/2007/05/gordons_party_p.html

Letting membership continue to fall by disparaging the Leader/Deputy contest will almost certainly guarantee defeat at the next British General Election. Growing membership will not guarantee a 4th term, but it will help. Doesn't that mean we have to make membership meaningful, not mock it.

Anonymous said...

Peter
I would argue that if anyone has mocked the members and made our membership meaningless then surely it is the PLP and the bullying machinations of the leader-elect.I have read nothing in the Press in the past few days or weeks to suggest that Brown will be more democratic than Blair.Quite the contrary.
If membership does continue to fall, it's hardly down to dissident members - it's down to a New Labour bureaucracy and ideology which quells dissent and disallows the democratic process.Thereby disillusioning thousands.
As a member of Save The labour Party, I would also argue this non-election has been the ultimate in unacceptable control freakery.Something I thought STLP was set up to oppose.Shenanigans by the Party machine is not something I will defend under any circumstances. I am surprised you think I would.

susan press said...

.... and John didn't mislead anyone. He always said we had " a mountain to climb."

Anonymous said...

Hi Susan, In Preston we voted 10-2 for our MP to nominate John McDonnell. Unfortunately he nominated Gordon Brown. If you look on the Labour Party website Preston has gone behind Brown. This, I believe, is no enthusisatic endorsement of him. It is because those activists who wanted to see John on the ballot paper are that despondent they have had nothing to do with the the 'who's gonna be the wart on Gordon's chin' Deputy leader process. There are many people hurt still by the whole PLP nominating process. The establishment of the party is, as usual, keen to manipulate the truth to suit the man of the moment. If we all look beneath that the truth is somewhat different. Perhaps we should have been more vocal after John didn't make the ballot paper. I admire you for being that way.

Mike Baldock said...

I doubt anyone, even John, could have seen the disagreeable lengths the Brownites would go to squash debate and democracy. It wasn't just the left who failed to get representation on the ballot - the Blairites were too cowed to even risk it - at least John had the guts to make a stand.

Duncan Hall said...

Peter - it is the PLP and Brown himself who are mocking our members. If anything would be likely to see more members leaving it would be us just settling down to accept this appalling situation. I think Susan has been absolutely right to speak out against what Brown and his machine are doing.

If we want to reinvigorate our members, the last thing we should do is suggest they should sit back and accept the role of cheerleaders.

Of course we have to accept that Brown is now leader of the Parliamentary Labour Party (he has arranged it so he will never be leader of the Labour Party, and more fool him). But lining up to be whipped would make people feel membership was pointless. We've got to demonstrate that the membership does have a role, and it will exercise that role.