Being a woman of a certain age, my memories of Labour "dream tickets" go back a long way. Kinnock and Hattersley, Heffer and Meacher, Benn and Heffer, and, oh yes, Blair and Prescott. To my eternal chagrin, I actually voted for the latter.
Prescott, many of us thought in our naivete, would be the Old Labour ballast to stop the right-wing Blair from straying too far from the path of social justice and core Labour values. We all know what happened there. But at least in those days Labour won General Elections .We are now in a very different place. Yet union leaders and a sizeable number of MPs are apparently backing a so-called "dream ticket" of Alan Johnson and Jon Cruddas. ie a Blairite for the top job and a soft-left MP for a job that means nothing. Can someone please explain to me in what sense this would be better than what we have now? Because the bottom line is that New labour would still be in charge.
I would have far more respect for Jon Cruddas if he announced his candidature for the top job. That would be perfectly understandable and an honest position. And a soft left PM would arguably make a siignificant difference to who was in and out of Government.
Instead, the Compass wing is cosying up to the right and basically acting as a toothless buffer zone to hinder real policy changes and give the unions another chance to cop out of backing a real candidate of the left. Would Alan Johnson seriously change tack policywise? Even if he is less "ultra" and frankly more likeable than the likes of Milburn and Miliband the end result will be the same. And was it not Johnson himself who said he "was not up to being Prime Minister." He may have an aura of Harry Perkins. He certainly hasn't got his politics......

11 comments:
Indeed nightmare scenario...Johnson/Cruddas. I agree, I can't see any policy changes or direction change.
Gosh...I still have my Benn/Heffer badge somewhere. "Benn/Heffer: that's the ticket"... if I recall correctly.
Being realistic, though. John McDonnell is not going to be elected: nor is anyone else from the left of the party.
Is there anyone from the right or the centre who you would be content with? Because realistically, they are the only ones in contention.
I think it is agreed by most that many areas of policy need to change but I can't see any point in simply rejecting anyone without the necessary left credentials given the current situation in the party.
According to this poll three percent want Johnson as PM and ten percent want Brown.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601102&sid=aVGMiXagsSVk&refer=uk
So it is a suicidal plan.
Agreed that it is currently unlikely we get a left Leader.But one of the key reasons for that, frankly, is the timidity of the trade unions and the PLP. It seems as though people like Tony Woodley are, in desperation, concocting some spurious conpromise which will not change policy nor significantly alter Labour's prospects. What is needed is a fundamental shift back towards social democracy and socialist values. Something Compass was ostensibly set up for. Instead, its main protagonusts in Westminster seem intent on dodgy deals with New Labour - and to what end? OK, Cruddas will get a job in the Cabinet. We wil still get annihilated at the polls. Without a policy change, it doesn't matter who stands.......
even if all trade unions voted left
it would only be for Cruddas
as unfortunately John's so called supporters have pissed off so many friends in the unions
as for the CLP's god only knows how they would split
lets put it this way it wont be Milliband or McDonnell (and I rather like John)
I only hope the Tories will be as useless in putting party policy in place as New Labour has been
look to day the Tories speak on the battle for Georgia a very important issue, Labour nothing dead.
The Tories are more up front while out lot are looking at nothing which might up set the apple cart, Jesus lets get back to politics and win the fight, but Labour has lost it holds up it's arms and say thats it, it's over.
Anonymous, I see. It's the fault of John McDonnell supporters that trade union leaders are apparently supporting a Blairite for leader and Cruddas for Deputy (let's face it it doesn't matter tuppence who's Deputy). Wouldn't be anything to do with the fact that Woodley and Simpson have done nothing but sell the left down the river for the past two years then ?? And look like continuing.....and please don't confuse the bureaucrats with the grassroots members who I'm sure will hardly be whooping with joy at the prospect of Alan Johnson as Leader.
with all respect Susan we will be lucky if a majority of trade unionists dont vote Tory at the next election never mind Crudas
"Can someone please explain to me in what sense this would be better than what we have now? Because the bottom line is that New labour would still be in charge."
Susan, I think that, far from 'cosying up to the right', most Compass people are rather sceptical about the benefit that this proposition could bring.
This article coud mean anything-
Could johnson be attemting to cosy up to the soft left in preparation for a run? I think we all know he'd go for it. Perhaps this is a throwaway thought from Woodley which got published because it is silly season. Who knows.
Either way, it's not really serious speculation. The only people who would back AJ in practice are either Unison beaurocrats or general right-wingers.
Further, Compass was not formed to herald a 'return to socialism'. It was formed to work a way forward to a modernised and relevent social democracy. Let's put it this way; it would be unlikely to tolerate AWL infiltration, mass nationalisation or General Strike-ism.
It is just as likely to advocate a raising of the personal allowance as a moderate increase in top rate tax.
The list goes on.
"I think it is agreed by most that many areas of policy need to change but I can't see any point in simply rejecting anyone without the necessary left credentials given the current situation in the party."
Bang on. It doesn't matter if the key reason is timidity. What matters is if you have effective tools to counter it, or understand the material reasons behind why it arises.
Post a Comment