Tuesday, 18 March 2008

TRICKETT'S TESTAMENT

Yorkshire MP Jon Trickett has a piece in today's Guardian criticising New Labour. Its content is nothing we haven't heard before many many times and I would agree with all of it. But I take issue with a piece of new political jargon presumably coined by Trickett's Compass colleagues rather than the man himself . He refers to the "modernising left" - which means what exactly? It sounds horrible and is an unnecessary semantic device which frankly sounds more like Neal Lawson media-speak rather than blunt and rather blustering Trickett. As does the piece.......
Why can't the word "left" be used in a posiitive fashion. Why the need to qualify and apologise ? The point is that all left-of-centre Labour MPs need to start working together - and stop kow-towing to the leadership - if Labour is to have a hope in hell of winning the next election. To state exactly that - and then attempt to distinguish yourself from colleagues not of the Compass left - is not a clever move.....I hate the terms "hard" and "soft" left, too. So let's just start talking "left"

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

A good sign would be if the Compass M.P's signed JM's EDM challenging welfare reform, all good social democratic stuff, no extremism!


btw, in the Guardian, pollshows NL sinking to a 24 yr low, their draconian policies clearly aren't working

susan press said...

I agree. The "modernising left" tag makes me wince. About time they decided whose side they are on and stopped buggering about.

Anonymous said...

"To state exactly that - and then attempt to distinguish yourself from colleagues not of the Compass left - is not a clever move.....I hate the terms "hard" and "soft" left, too. So let's just start talking "left""

It's a very sensible move if you want to get selected as a PPC.

susan press said...

But not if you want to build the left as a whole - and win the next election. Frankly "modernising left" sucks and exudes the fingerprints of Neal Lawson.Trickett would never come up with such a phrase

Tom said...

"Why can't the word "left" be used in a posiitive fashion. Why the need to qualify and apologise ?"

Because the 'hard' left in reacting against 'new' Labour have reacted against modern campaigning and media techniques and have clung to many policies, often for decades, which with the benefit of hindsight, other on the left believe to have been mistaken.

On the media point, you only have to look at the way the primary weapon of the LRC is a nostalgic one; starting with the name and the logo!

The left IS progress. Where tradition has a cost it must be left behind.

susan press said...

The primary weapon of the LRC is NOT nostalgia. The primary weapon is its policies, which Jon Trickett seems to have no trouble espousing when it suits....... As for media techniques well the LRC has embraced new technology, set up Facebook groups made videos and targetted websites, and is doing its best within limited resources to build and grow. John McDonnell is now regularly quoted in the media as a champion of the Labour Left. And not just in the Morning Star....... The LRC also now has 1500 paid-up members. Many more sympathisers. Looking proudly to the past does not mean we don't go forward. Neither the badge nor the name needs to be ditched. Re-branding may give people a temporary buzz - it doesn't last . You need political substance and commitment, not superficialities . And as for the idea of a "modernising left " - well the semantic connotations with New Labour of that phrase make that already a tainted brand IMHO.
PS: Whatever happened to "New Wave Labour?????

Anonymous said...

In policy terms Compass and the LRC are not far apart. It is a question of tactics.

I think the fundamental difference between the "Compass left" and the "LRC left" in the Labour Party is that the former want Labour to win the next election and realise that to deliver a left agenda they need to work in the party to achieve this. The latter seem to believe it would be better to have public arguments and if Labour lose the next election then this will allow the left to regroup.

It's a question of tactics and in my view the LRC are wrong cos the spectre of a Tory government is too scarey to imagine.

E10 Rifle said...

I might also snipe that another difference between Compass and the LRC is that while the LRC walks as well as talks left, Compass only does the latter. This isn't about "oppositionist" posturing - it's about behaving credibly. And credibility is a problem that all wings of all main parties have with the general public at the moment.

That said, Compass has some useful ideas and people and it's encouraging that those ideas and people appear to be making the running a bit within and without the party at the moment. I wish them well - and just hope they don't just turn into a modish progressive-sounding career advancement vehicle. As the IPPR did in the 80s and 90s.

susan press said...

The "spectre of a Tory government" is not one cherished by the LRC. It is one positively advanced by New Labour and those who do not speak out enough against the neo-liberal drift of this Government. So far, that has included Compass. The notion that LRC wants Labour to lose the next election is nonsense. The point is that New Labour policies are helping make that more of a prospect day by day. There comes a point when you can no longer fudge and faff about and frankly the Labour Party reached that point years ago. It's time to choose a left agenda - or get ready for a Tory Government.

Merseymike said...

I think the point is, surely, that there are many of us who have never thought of ourselves as 'on the left' who are utterly bemused by the current government and view it as having abandoned social democracy altogether.

So many of us feel, quite simply, that having not moved from a simple belief in social democratic redistribution and fairness, that we find ourselves way to the left of a government which appears to have no solutions other than further economic liberalism.

I think a major priority must be to do something about taxation, in particular the removal of many low paid workers from tax altogether (much more of a disincentive to work than anything else) and the introduction of a higher earners band of 50% for earnings over 100K.

susan press said...

Merseymike, I wouldn't disagree with that. As you say, even the old social democrat position is now way to the left of New Labour. And if groups like Compass can't recognise that and start saying so we are, in the words of Private Fraser, doomed to a Tory Government.If all the 137 or so Labour Mps who backed the Temporary and Agency Workers Bill ( even that was opposed by Govt) abandoned their quiescence and fear of upsetting new Labour's agenda we just might be getting somewhere......

Merseymike said...

I agree. It is a sad day when Labour can't even support those who are very clearly being exploited.

As someone who currently does work on temporary contracts it would have benefited me.

Do they not realise just how totally fed up people are with Tired Labour (its hardly 'new' any more...and it ain't Labour!)
The problem is that they really do believe that chasing the swing voters is all thats needed. Do they not realise that in the process, the core voters are simply walking away - both the working class core and the progressive intelligentsia, our base voters both, are totally dislillusioned